Old Mill Ice Cream

Erin G.

2023-10

Yummy ice cream. Bit overpriced, (payed about $16 for only 3 of us if that helps). But they do give you a good portion and they have lots of flavors to choose from. Highly recommend Carmel Caribou. Get yourself an ice cream and enjoy the beautiful scenery!

Derrick La Borde

2023-09

Excellent ice cream and a very authentic, small-town country atmosphere. Well worth the beautiful drive from alpine. Get the wild huckleberry!

Clifford F

2023-07

Trendy ice cream where you play quite a bit for some ice cream from Farr's. It's fun, it's a cute atmosphere, but it's also the same price for a half gallon at a grocery store as it is for a double scoop waffle cone.

sharona lee peterson

2019-05

Cones are great price and great value. Friendly people, plenty of space to sit and eat. Disney channel in tv... our kids loves this!Go here!!!!

Peter Lynch

2023-05

Nice ice cream store. Typically has 15 flavors or so. Cups, cones, waffle cones and other treats are available. Inside and outside seating available. Not cheap but good sized portion served so an okay value. Parking available.Returned in 2022, still just as good.

Joseph Ong

2023-06

we stopped by here on the drive from jackson down to salt lake city for a treat – the huckleberry ice cream was delicious and the scoops were huge!

Allen Hall

2023-08

The banana split was huge, very good

Ashley

2023-05

Delicious! We just moved here and have been coming almost every week. Prices are great. The serving size are huge. Friendly!I am sad they are close for the season.

Stan Owens

2022-05

This is a great little place. Prices are good for the serving you get. The young ladies running the counter were very pleasant and professional in their service. If you are around the Star Valley area during their open season, stop in. Even if they are busy, it's worth it.

Rick Reed

2022-05

They used to have no sugar added ice cream. We went there because 3 out of 4 of use are diabetic. Unfortunately, no longer do they have no sugar added ice cream... We all were disappointed.. Guess we will do something different. Hope they advertise if they ever go back to at least carrying vanilla no sugar added products.

Share Fell

2023-06

The ice cream was good. I love the huckleberry. Staff was friendly and service quick.

Ava beal

2023-05

It was there first day on the job so it they were slow making the ice creams but over all very good and everyone there is so nice!!! Very nice service and nice table

Mary Deis

2022-05

Delicious ice cream, good choices and large portion sizes. Stopped here on a whim on a long road trip and if ever coming by this way again would do it again.

J W

2018-05

Such a cute place! We have tried stopping several times and it was always closed. It was fun to finally try it. Employees were fantastic and ice cream was great.

Keri Chandler

2019-05

Love the ice cream and keep coming back for the great environment and friendly faces. Great location, just off the highway and a great place to stop by to grab a sweet treat!

chris b

2017-05

This was a fun place to eat at. We shared a waffle cone with a scoop of cookies and cream and other scoop of Huckleberry. Both were fine, nothing spectacular.

Jessica Rainey

2021-05

This is our favorite icecream shop. We have been coming to star valley for decades and this is somewhere we always have to stop. The prices are really great & serving sizes are big!! Pictured here is a single scoop. Definitely stop here!!

KS SK

2022-05

It's our favorite ice cream Service is great place is clean Ice cream delicious We wish it was open all year

curtis runnels

2018-05

Stopped in while house shopping from Texas, great ice cream and even better people. Nice family. Looking forward to making them my neighbors.

Dan Petty

2023-09

Got some great milkshakes here, it was a stop I'll make again.

Tyler S

2023-07

My kids enjoyed having the books to read while we were here.

Mike Swanson

2022-05

Best Huckleberry ice cream you'll find! Our dog loves their vanilla cones!

Leda Pierce

2019-05

Love it. Kinda spendy, but you do get a generous amount of ice cream. And the staff is friendly and fun to visit with.

Andras M Marton

2020-05

Just as we remembered it when we came a few years ago. Too bad they ran out of chocolate and other favorites, but we went for new flavors and they were great!

Carol Perkins

2023-05

The ice cream is good but pricey.Some of the staff are rude.

k crosby

2018-05

Great place to treat your family to ice cream cone or smoothie. Outgoing positive personalities.

Megan Ward

2021-05

Uses Farrs ice cream out of Utah. Generous portions with a mid range price.

DJ Mills

2019-05

Went to Maggie's upstairs. Great place to eat a fine dinner. Well worth the drive to get a excellent dinner .

Jas Ritzema

2022-05

The kids really enjoyed their ice cream and the restrooms were very clean

Nick Malone

2020-05

Best milkshakes on this side of the country. Would drive another 18 hrs to have one, in fact...