Frosty Moose

Grant Parry

2023-05

This is probably my favorite ice cream shop in the area. I swear I get withdrawals when they're closed in the off season. Their prairie dirt sundae (kind of like a dirt cup with ice cream instead of pudding) is what childhood dreams are made of. It's got a base of Oreo ice cream, Oreo dirt, gummy worms, whipped cream, and some sort of marshmallow topping that takes it to the next level. Seriously, get it, it's that good. I've also had the spicy chicken wrap here which was great. Always great service.

Luvmarley Tahara (luvmarley2645)

2021-05

Love this little shop! Their ice cream was amazing as were the cone choices. I love the tie dye shirts that had wide sales. The employees were friendly & helpful. Highly recommend when you are in town if you are looking for the best ice cream & goodies😋💕

Nicole Riopelle

2023-07

I love this place! Just a few minutes walk from where we were staying. Chocolate Shoppe ice cream is my favorite, and they had so many great flavors. Can't wait to try the food.

Joy Crusio

2023-09

Our favorite ice cream shop is nearby. They have an outside table where we can take our dog with us.

Sandra Kirkpatrick

2023-09

Great sandwich. Great selection of ice cream. I forget about it because I don't go to Williams Bay often. . I have to change that. I need to try every sandwich because the 4 times I have been there, I have not been disappointed.

HobbitJack

2023-05

Excellent ice cream/sweets store. They use excellent ice cream, and have no shortage of other candies and stuffs available. They also have a nice lunch menu. Being a fairly simple guy, I had a nice hot dog. No complaints.

Brian Palmer

2023-05

Very friendly family owned place they have snacks ice cream and have sandwiches that are made fresh. The crab salad is made in house and very good. Will definitely be stopping when in the area. One sandwich could feed 2 people. Was my first time there and very impressed.

Nicole D

2023-05

My family and I LOVED this eatery! The sandwiches had more than enough meat on them, and the walking taco was AMAZING! I also highly recommend the ice cream. All in all, if you're looking for a great local place, make sure to stop here!

Lola Napolitano

2023-11

Best place for delicious sandwiches and ice cream. It’s always a joy going there!

Ben Johnson

2023-08

THE ICE CREAM was killer. They should call it the Killer Frosty Moose. I got to taste test a few. The MaltAmore was my fav.the Burbon Spiked Espresso was also amazing. prices are fair for the area.. we will be back.

Paul Rzepka

2023-07

Great sandwich and ice cream place! Have gone many times when in Lake Geneva area! Awesome gluten free options

Kate DeCiccio

2023-05

Great ice cream and great prices but the ordering experience feels chaotic and overwhelming, and I'm just the customer.I think some organization and strategy on who is doing what behind the counter could lend itself to a better customer experience and a shorter wait time all around.Edited to respond: I actually wasn’t with any group. Just a random customer that followed the line as directed for only ice cream.

Rachel Horst

2023-10

I love their ice cream. me and my mom went there and it was awesome

Dan Norz

2023-08

Delicious dairy free ice cream (they had cherry, vanilla with real cherries when I visited) and gluten free cones! They of course have dairy ice cream and regular cones.

James Labuz

2023-08

Placed an order for 15 hot dogs with several different topping requests. Ready in 15 minutes and everything was labeled. Great service.

Doug

2023-09

The best deli sandwiches around, tied together with great ice cream. Perfect small town place.

Reegs

2022-05

Although it felt a little weird with sheets of plastic up, this review is posted just after mask mandates were lifted, so I understand in this environment, taking precautions.The corned beef was fantastic. I highly recommend the pretzel bun!Italian in white was great.Shakes was delicious.And of course the ice cream was amazing! Some traditional Faves and some newer blends. Everything for full service ice cream.Can’t wait to go back. Very friendly.

Ken Hagen

2023-10

Cute Deli and Ice Cream shop in Williams Bay, Visited while hiking the Lake Geneva shoreline path. Shop is a short walk off the path in Williams Bay

Sarah Sladek

2020-05

Great ice cream and shakes! There are a lot of treats we haven't tried, but the lines suggest everything is good. Not only is the ice cream smooth and creamy, but the sandwiches are the best in the area! They do not skimp on the meat! Sometimes, in the off season, they may be open and have a couple of different soups. This is a favorite place for sure!

T L

2023-10

Best ice cream at the lake. Lunch sandwiches are phenomenal. Great value!

John Adamowski

2023-11

…More

Jim O'Keeffe

2020-05

Great ice cream variety - literally any flavor you want! Generously sized sandwiches made fresh...with nice options. Very friendly service. Outdoor seating available in good weather. Nice pick-me-up if you need one going around Lake Geneva area.

Christine Parvin

2021-05

Such a cute and fun family running this shop. They care about their guests.... you can tell! We enjoyed their delicious and generously portioned sandwiches. Fresh produce and meat, and i was actually full after-- wasn't expecting that as most sandwiches in our society don't fill ya up! Good job!!

Kelsey Teske

2018-05

Ice cream is delicious. Server was patient while we all decided on flavors. Nice seating area next to the store. The hidden gem was their made-to-order sandwiches! Picked up several turkey sandwiches & enjoyed them during a swim day at the lake.

Jennifer Lumsden

2020-05

I had a waffle cone with exhausted parent flavor, it was espresso flavored ice cream with dark chocolate chunks. It was amazing! The owner was working alone and still made the ice cream cone perfect with a packed house. I would highly recommend this quaint gem in Williams Bay.

Grace Nogueras

2021-05

So many awesome ice cream flavors!! (Try the Exhausted Parent or Zanzibar Chocolate ice cream. Absolutely delicious!) Decent amount of ice cream given for the price you pay too. Quaint little sitting spot beside the building, or if you want to walk, the lakeshore path is just about a half mile away from the parlor.

Dave S

2021-05

Pretty good prices, for the area anyway, with a very premium ice cream brand, The Chocolate Shoppe. Many of the very latest flavors too. Nice outdoor eating area with nice, comfortable wrought iron chairs and tables, picnic tables, and a couple Adirondack chairs.

Robert Aalund

2019-05

This place has really good ice cream, but they are often overlooked for their sandwiches. This is the first year they’ve stayed open all winter and I hope they can continue. Seriously, they are great sandwiches! Will return again and again.

Pavlo Cherkashyn

2019-05

Good ice cream. The best thing after the lake Geneva trail hiking!

Susan Gaston

2019-05

We have to stop by the Frosty Moose every time we are in Williams Bay!! This is a family owned business... stop in to meet grandparents, parents, and kids. The ice cream is delicious and the food is great, too! We also love that they are open late! Highly recommend!