Good Thyme Restaurant and Catering

Zoey Zou

2023-11

Traveled from Minnesota for a weekend getaway and had dinner at this place. Ribeye was exceptional - the best steak I had in months. Great value ($39). The all you can eat fish fry was also a great value, but the taste was standard and was as expected. The complementary salad was extremely good - such a nice surprise. Highly recommend this place! Amazing food and service. Really enjoyed my night.

Elizabeth Wartzenluft

2023-07

…More

Christine Cagle

2024-05

My husband and I were celebrating our 30th anniversary. We had the peppercorn crust Ribeye. Hats off is all I have to say what an excellent meal. From the first bite to the last. This restaurant is great and this is steak done right.Vegetarian options: Not sure sorry.

Jacob Tonn

2023-08

The place was booked solid but the bar had open seating. We ordered the clams, whitefish, and the Ribblets. All were excellent. Chris the bartender was the best!Parking: It does look like Somebody's house but it was well layed out inside.

Lauryn

2023-09

…More

Sara Mark

2024-01

The best place!! The new owner has made this place incredible. They don't have a lot vegan options, but I don't even care! The few they do have are outstanding- I would be stoked to see more options though! The service is always great and I always leave beyond happy. The tofu curry is the best dish I've had in years and the pasta night rocks! (I would love to suggest adding a vegan protein option to pasta night though! Beyond or Impossible meatballs/meat crumbles would be SO delicious!)

Olivia Swanson

2024-02

10/10 service- all of the staff (owner included) were so wonderful and attentive. Their suggestions were on-point and they took the time to chat with us despite it being busy in the restaurant.10/10 food- every single dish that we tried was beyond phenomenal. The Old Fashioneds that the bartender made were some of the best drinks we have had in a long time.10/10 atmosphere- while the space itself is small, our group never felt crowded or rushed. We never had to shout to hear each other and the space itself was absolutely lovely.My family and I cannot wait to come back!

Nate Wilson (Organic Squirrel)

2024-03

Solid 4-star (Google rating) experience. Food was good, and better than a normal "dinner restaurant". Wait staff fine, though they might never get around to refilling your water glass. 🤷Pricing ok for entrees and drinks, though around $10-$15 over what you'd expect. Only a couple main entree/meals under $20, so plan on paying at least $140 per couple

Rachel Rasmussen

2023-08

…More

Emily Duquaine

2022-05

Came across this place from a recommendation while shopping in Bayfield. Although we did not have a reservation we were seated quickly at the bar. Service was excellent despite short staffing. We were informed their menu had been downsized due to staffing, but I feel they had a good selection. Ordered the parmesean crusted ribeye which was out of this world! Will return if we ever come back this way from Green Bay again!

Karly H (Exploring the lakes!)

2023-05

The food is out of this world. The fish Friday is so good. The drinks were ok but glad they fit us in because we didn’t have a reservation. I would suggest calling ahead to see if they have spots.

A Kearns

2024-01

Always a restaurant that I stop at when visiting my mom. Food, service and atmosphere are amazing. Just tried their cheesecake and compote for dessert this time. This dessert is to die for and wish I could buy an entire cheesecake to take home with me. A++ restaurant and will continue to go here when in the area. Make sure to stop and visit…and make sure you make a reservation, as they are very popular.

Travis Lewallen

2022-05

The moment we walked in, the host was super friendly and helped us get a drink at the bar while waiting. They ended up getting us a table faster on the patio and the waitress we got was so much fun (and sassy!). I highly recommend this place. Great food and fun staff!

John Vinar

2023-05

We enjoyed our meal very much. We made the mistake of accepting an 8:00 dinner reservation and we were seated next to the bar. Very loud and hard to have a conversation. The Pistachio Shrimp Ravioli was delicious. Don't let the Pistachio decide against ordering this dish.

Caren Mull

2021-05

Truly excellent service! It seamlessly flowed. The staff thought of what we needed before we knew we would want it. I had the pork shank, which was good, but it was missing some sort of *pop* of ingredient. However, my boyfriend had the char crusted filet which was easily the winning dish. It was stuffed with a 4 cheese blend in addition to a crispy exterior and perfect medium-rare made it hit the palate in a wonderful sense of flavor combinations! The house salad to start the experience was also well mixed flavors.

juan garcia

2023-09

…More

Stephen Oleszkowicz

2020-05

An amazing delicious meal. There is nothing can think of that would have improved our meal here! Everything was unique, tasty, and served in perfect portion sizes! All that and an extremely fair price! Don't forget to get the cast iron chocolate chip sundae! Boy was that yummy!

Fernando Bernardo

2021-05

We came here to visit the Apostle Islands for a weekend and this was the best restaurant in the area. Highly recommend! The food was delicious and cocktails well done.

Kae Brown

2023-11

Got a chance to visit tonight and I am so glad we did! Starters we're the mussels and we devoured them, with the boy having the majority! I really enjoyed the Thai Curry Shrimp, hubby had the Moraccan Chicken and the boy the Friday Fish fry. We finished the evening with the most amazing dark chocolate mousse with a fruit compote and whipped cream.Overall a very enjoyable experience. Would definitely go back and recommend!

Hellen Yi

2022-05

I would go out of my way just to eat here! The food is absolutely amazing and the staff are so friendly! We had the char grilled ribeye and the almond crusted white fish and 10/10 would recommend

Angelika

2023-05

…More

Kay Buchanan

2023-07

Great meal! Three of us had an evening meal here and absolutely loved everything about it! Two of us have been dining here every summer for years. We noted the new ownership and wondered how that change would affect our experience this year. It turned out we loved it! New menu items and some of the great “regular” staff servingus. Two of us had the Red Curry with Shrimp and found it to be excellent. I had the pistachio-crusted whitefish and it was excellent. The presentation of the meals was wonderful. And you could taste the high-quality ingredients. We highly recommend Good Thyme. It is a gourmet-level dining experience up in northern Wisconsin.

Dan Pfister

2021-05

This is our favorite spot to spend date night. Their food is amazing and never ceases to amaze us how the flavors all come together to make the best food we have had anywhere.

Emily Wiseman

2023-08

I absolutely love this spot. I think it’s some of the best food you can find in NW Wisconsin and Northern MN. There’s a reason they’ve been in business for so long! We started with the duck wontons which were lovely and generous in portion size. I had the pistachio encrusted whitefish and that was cooked perfectly. The dish itself was so well balanced and delightful - I recommend that dish! Even the side salad was delicious! My husband ordered the trout and also loved it. My son ordered the cheeseburger from the kids menu - I sampled a bite and let me tell you, it made me want to come back again and order the double smash burger. They excelled at a kids cheeseburger - that means something, y’all! Overall a great experience - don’t be afraid to take the kids!

Gina Wedekind

2023-05

Make reservations! We did not know they were needed. Luckily there was 2 openings left at the bar. Waitstaff was super friendly. Food was killer good. Pork Shanks were stellar!

Travis Hatfield

2023-09

We were in the area for about 5 days and was recommended this place from howl brewery. We decided to give it a try. We ended up going two nights in a row. 0 complaints. Food is top notch and drinks are made to perfection. I had the ribeye both nights and the wife had salmon and whitefish. Amazing place. Definitely the best in the area by A LOT. Order an old fashioned and a ribeye. You won't be disappointed unless you don't like those to begin with

Roger Aiken

2023-10

…More

Robert Coles

2023-10

…More

T-roy Sierra

2023-10

…More

Jeff Machkovich

2023-09

I do recommend this place. Customer Service is top-notch spectacular. Our food was very good.Make sure you eat inside! We did not have reservations and chose to eat on the deck. There is nothing special about the view, but the flies were unbelievably persistent. We spent most of our dinner swatting flies. That was too bad as it harmed what would have been a great dining experience.We will be going back, only inside dining though.