Second Hand Sue's

3.8 (19)

10744 N Bay Shore Dr, Sister Bay, WI 54234
(920) 854-3310
m.facebook.com

Claim this business

Thrift store

Service options

  • In-store shopping

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

Elizabeth Marsh

2022-05

Second Hand Sue's winter hours are Friday & Saturday 10-5. I've added a photo that shows the big sign in their window displaying the hours. I hope this information is helpful. It's the information I would have liked to see before I went there. This is accurate as of early April 2022.

sherry hellekson

2023-05

Very polite cashier, very busy, extremely clean place to shop. Had lots of fun buying and prices were very in line as well. Wish they were closer to where I live so I could visit more frequently. A+ customer service

Jodi Rathunde

2015-05

Had a very "interesting" visit there... And I will Never be going back...Purchased an item and paid for it... due to weather and me not having an enclosed vehicle to haul the item home, I asked the store to hold it... Which they did. The next day I went to pick up the item and I was told that the sales clerk from the day before sold me the item at the wrong sale price and that to take the item home I would have to pay an additional $25. (Very rudely I might add) I was very taken back that the owner would not honor the price that the sales clerk charged me for. What business owner does not honor their own employee errors??? I was not paying an additional $25 for the item. I was however promptly refunded my money.

Nicholas

2022-05

Cool store. Stopped in while I was visiting Sisters Bay for the day. A little bit off the path from all the restaurants and such but it was worth the walk. They had a full storefront as well as an additional floor space out back in their garage. All kinds of cool items there.

Rhonda Fischer

2021-05

Surprised by customer service level. As I entered the store, I said Hello to two associates behind counter whom never responded back. I was in the store for 15 minutes (only customer) and was never spoken to.Selection of items was okay but prices seem high .

Momma K's Cafe

2023-05

A great resource for second hand items for decor, kitchen, small and outdoor furniture, shoes, and clothing. There is even a men's section of tools and fishing items. Closed Mondays, cash and check only.

Judy B

2023-08

I’ve been there several times. In my years of thrifting experience they are way overpriced for the quality of items. Very ordinary.

Suzanne Giaimo

2015-05

This store is always fun to visit. Their inventory changes continuously, the folks there are friendly, and they have very interesting sales! We will continue to visit there as often as we can.

P A

2022-05

Disappointed a hour drive north to visit ! Door lock sign says openGoggle say open also!!!! Will not returnHow hard is to go on line and post closed for the day??? Don’t understand

Johanna P

2022-05

The garage in the back had some interesting things but no one was in the store

Opening Hours

Monday Closed
Tuesday 10 AM-5 PM
Wednesday 10 AM-5 PM
Thursday 10 AM-5 PM
Friday 10 AM-5 PM
Saturday 10 AM-5 PM
Sunday Closed

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet