Door County Creamery

Lori

2023-08

…More

Darrin Rogers

2023-08

Very cute shop with fantastic food. The brie turkey sandwich was the best turkey sandwich I've had in my life (my picture does not do it justice) I had to come back later and had the mozzarella - also very good. They have a small but very good selection of gelato, in case you haven't had it: good gelato >> ice cream. We got two larges and that was enough for a family of five to share. It seems expensive but in my opinion it's totally worth it for how delicious the food was. We will be coming back. Skip the roof goats and come here.

Rage Thomas

2023-10

Fun little shop. Awesome that it is open late. We went for the ice cream/gelato ( never specificed) late at night.However, some big draw backs.Our group found every flavor either off putting or way to intense. Zero nuance to any of the flavors. I landed on the raspberry panncotta which was good(very intense raspberry but I love raspberries) and creamy. The salt and olive oil tasted like butter and extra salt. Also it was icy and not creamy. The caramel was so sweet it was inedible. We threw out a full Carmel one because no one in the group could stomach it. The coffee tasted like eating coffee grounds with it's bitterness.When the ice cream server grabbed spoons, she reached in an grab a huge handle after touch other things and not washing hands.Also everything is made in china.However the wine points above the bottles is a nice touch.Fyi, it's all goat milk in their ice cream so it you don't like goat milk, be warned.

Cecile Lindell

2023-11

…More

Sheetal Shedbalkar

2024-04

We grabbed take-out lunch here and got a burrata salad, green veggie wrap and a lamb gyro. The burrata salad and lamb gyro were great, the green wrap was so-so. We also got gelato here, which was amazing! You can try a sample before ordering. Service was quick. They also sell lots of different types of cheeses and condiments. This is a great place to stop if you’re in Door County.

Ben S.

2023-10

My brother and I were in town for the Door County Century bike ride. Every flavor I sampled was very good, but lemon cookie was unbelievably good. Whenever I buy a size that allows for multiple flavors, I always *get* multiple flavors, but the lemon cookie was so good that I only choose that one. Came back the next day to bring home a pint. The gift shop had some cute stuff, too. I bought something for my partner. We went here after eating at Al Johnson's for breakfast. There was plenty of seating outside. The employees were very patient to let us try numerous flavors. Also the servings were generously overflowing, as you can see from my photo. Will definitely return if I'm town again.

Casey M

2023-06

My happy place! I’ve been going to Door County Creamery for years. I loved it when they opened and it just keeps getting better. The mozzarella sandwich is perfect balanced and delicious. The gelato is creamy and flavorful. They’ve got a great little shop, too.

Bill S.

2023-09

I've had ice cream here before but never eaten. I had the meatball sandwich and it was awesome. Toasted bun/bread, fresh jalapeno, lettuce, cheese and a great Pesto, Aioli, Arugula sauce. Meatballs had a light amount of marinara so it wasn't overpowering. Not at all what you'd expect with a meatball sandwich but it was awesome! So good.

Kate Swisher

2023-05

An absolute gem! The reason: in my experience, Door County is not the best area for creative vegetarian options. If you’re sick of yet another bean burger or salad, I highly recommend coming here and getting the beet batarde sandwich or the veggie wrap. Both are legitimately great, original and flavorful. There is a nice outdoor seating area, restrooms out back, and you can finish off your meal with some delicious gelato. We took home a baguette and cherry goat cheese for the next morning, and they were also excellent. A+!(Didn’t see any goats, though.)

Brittney G

2023-08

…More

The Accidental Hero

2023-08

…More

Liu

2023-11

…More

Neal Silbert

2019-05

An amazing gourmet cafe, ice cream shop, gourmet cheese shop filled with tasty artisan treats. Comfortable outdoor seating is availableThe gelato was delicious as were the salads and sandwiches. Parking is conveniently available adjacent to the store - which is very handy since street parking is seldom available. They are well known for their goat farm and sell cheese and even gelato made from goat milk.The sweet German mustard is amazing and worth taking home.We didn’t experience a wait, but this restaurant is popular and become busy. The gelato line can have a ten minute wait.The service staff were very polite, the restaurant and the restrooms were clean.Look out for posters offering tours of the goat farm to learn how their products are made.They seemed pet friendly.

Kelli M

2019-05

Yumm! I loved my Beet salad, the cheese platter was amazing and the frozen yogurt was delish. So many cute little gifts, shirts and cookbooks too. Everyone really enjoyed their food.

Emily Ahern

2023-11

…More

Stephanie Tsouloufis

2023-11

…More

Jude Rake

2023-07

…More

Stacy A

2023-10

Goat milk ice cream is a big “no” from me. Unpleasant flavors and after-taste. I made the mistake of not sampling before buying a scoop.Cute shop of goat-related items but every item was made in China. Please support local artists.Kid-friendliness: Lots of kids on the patio and running around the store.

Jeanine Elizabeth

2020-05

Found this place last year and while it took a while to convince to me try “goat cheese” anything I am so glad I did!In addition to blocks of goat cheese they also offer a nice selection of goat cheese spreads and ice cream along with goat milk soaps and lotions, apparel and wine.They also partner with a local farm for goat yoga which I definitely want to try next time! Only downfall is the crazy small chairs all the places seem to have here...not hip/butt friendly. Otherwise fabulous shop and a must see!

Amy Workman

2020-05

We took the farm tour with our almost 2-yr-old (who is pretty chill, I don't know that we would have liked it with a more active/mover/runner kid) and had the best time. Only regret is that we didn't have more cash on us to tip the tour guide, so stop at an atm on your way. The farm is a quick few minute shuttle ride from the store/creamery and we had the best gelato on the way. The farm is gorgeous. The person who gave the tour does the milking and was extremely knowledgeable and passionate about all aspects of the animal raising and cheese making. The goats are friendly definitely one of the cleaner farm animals. After the tour, but still on the farm, we tasted the best cheeses I've ever had (which is A LOT of fancy cheese). Then back at the restaurant we had an absolutely delicious elegant lunch. We were given a 10% coupon on any purchases, so I stocked up on their own cheeses (you can try them all at the store and the chevre freezes well), crackers, cookies (holy yum), a cookbook, goat's milk caramel, and gifts. If you like goats and cheese, do it. If you don't have time for the tour, at least go for food, cheese, and gelato. You will not be disappointed.

Vib Mehrotra

2022-05

When at sisters Bay you have to eat at Door County Creamery. They don't have too many selection of ice creams but the flavors they have taste great. We hadVarious ice creams but really liked Door County Cheery and Ultimate Oreo. However if you can have just one then you have get Chocolate Raspberry Truffle. This is the best flavor they have.

Jonathan Morrell

2019-05

Everything here was excellent. So many of the restaurants in the area serve fried, greasy food so this place provides a great contrast with farm fresh cheese and green leafy veggies. The employees working here are kind and helpful, and they will allow you to sample just about anything. Their sandwich special was a turkey and brie (homemade) croissant sandwich with lingonberry jam...needless to say, it was delicious.

Deb Christian

2023-11

Little country store. Have a wonderful selection of goat and sheep cheeses. Only place around that someone with a milk allergy can enjoy a charcuterie board and a bottle of good wine on the deck on a sunny fall day!! Love it❤️ They also have an awesome selection of goat milk ice creams. Seriously worth tasting 😋Dietary restrictions: So happy to find a place that made me feel normal! I actually had choices 😅 🤣

Ben Bartelt

2023-11

…More

Kristin D

2023-11

No trip to Door County is complete without stopping here, for a sandwich and scoop of delicious goat’s milk gelato, and a cooler full of fresh goat cheese to take home. It freezes beautifully, so I can get my fill until they open again. 😅I can’t eat most dairy, even most commercial goat’s milk products, but I find that I’m able to eat this with no problems, maybe because it’s straight from the farm and minimally processed. Love their farm tour too!

Noah Smith

2023-08

…More

Jeannine

2023-07

…More

William Schaeffer

2019-05

Charming gem here! Fantastic cheese! Good and fun wine selection. The meat and charcuterie platter is where it's at. Staff was friendly and accommodating. I will most definitely be returning.

Jackie Sholes

2023-11

To be fair, we only tried the ice cream, but it was 3 days in a row, because it was so amazing!! The best ice cream we have ever had. It's literally life changing. I can't explain it. Literally so fresh or something. Our favorites were the lemon cookie and raspberry panna cotta, but every flavor we tried was fantastic. I loved that they had their flavors clearly marked gluten free, so we knew what my son could eat. I wish we would have discovered it on the first day of our visit to Door County, so we could have had it every single day. Perfect little place, perfect spot, perfect atmosphere, perfect ice cream.

Caley S

2023-07

…More