Jersey Mike's Subs

4.6 (199)

4017 WI-28, Sheboygan Falls, WI 53085
(920) 802-1003
jerseymikes.com

Claimed
Sandwich shop
Caterer
Deli
Fast food restaurant
Takeout Restaurant
New Jersey–based counter-serve sandwich chain serving jumbo subs filled with cold cuts & toppings.

Service options

  • Curbside pickup

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

Tiffany Haggerty

2023-11

I was extremely & pleasantly surprised how the young man managing this location was so efficient, friendly, & leading his team of 2 other young men. Even though a small line started to form he was greeting every guest & asking them how their day was. Quality & delicious bread & ingredients. Definitely recommend for a good sub! I got my sub to go but I did look around to see if there were high chairs to bring my 1 yo in the future but couldn't see any. That would be my only disappointment.

Nicholas R. Nigrelli (Crazy Diamond)

2023-12

Sub Sandwich joints are seemingly popping up all over with a wide variety of sandwiches whatever you budget. Now if haven't already discovered Jersey Mike's at Deer Trace mall they make a most incredible Philly cheesesteak the Big kahuna my personal favourite with the grilled caramelized onions and peppers it is a sandwich extravaganza of incredible deliciousnessParking: Plenty of room for parking even if your riding a 18 wheeler.

MistahZ

2023-05

First time trying Jersey Mike's and it was not too bad! The building itself is a little cramped but nice and clean and easy to move around in. Service was attentive and on point with everything! The food was very good, I had no problems with any of it. Though not the best in the area, I thought Jersey Mike's was a good little sandwich shop and if someone was in the mood for it, I'd understand why.Pictures are the best I could take of the inside and outside of the building, and food I got!Vegetarian options: Many non meat options available!Dietary restrictions: Menu is clear with what it has in regards to nutritional and ingredient based details.Parking: Expansive and not hard to find!Kid-friendliness: Seems like a good place for kids!Wheelchair accessibility: Easy access to doors for wheelchair bound folks!

Tom B

2024-01

…More

Travis

2021-05

I would recommend this place. Delicious subs. Clean but it should be since it’s new. And hey if you need to get dog food it’s right next to Petsmart. Probably was a store room back in the day.

Jessica Maldonado

2023-12

…More

Michelle Wildman

2022-05

Best subs I've ever had... Greatest cuts of meat between the best soft Buns ever 😋 Perfection in my mouth!!!

Porche Patton

2023-11

…More

Terry Terrell

2024-01

Awesome food. Serive was great. I have an onion allergy. They made sure to change their gloves and wipe everything down. Grea t subs.Dietary restrictions: They make sure your needs are meet.

Michelle Brown

2024-03

…More

Ted Keneklis

2024-04

…More

William Fale

2023-11

…More

Eric The Red

2023-10

…More

Seth S

2023-11

…More

Karen Doubet

2023-11

…More

E C

2023-09

Great Location!!!! I travel for work frequently and see a lot of different JM locations and this one has been the best so far.Very clean.Great atmosphere.

Craig Sepstead

2024-04

…More

Margaret Hahn

2023-09

Just left Jersey Mike's and had delicious sandwiches. They were SLAMMED. ALL the staff remained calm, friendly, working hard-also while dealing with an extremely rude and loud customer. It was impressive! Thank you for another great experience!Dietary restrictions: Love all of tge gluten free options!

Speedy Captain

2023-09

…More

Kim T

2023-07

Good place to grab lunch! Very fresh ingredients with good flavor. Would make it a 5 star if had better bread choices.Parking: Next to a Home Depot so great parking even if you have a bigger vehicle.

Ross Kirschner

2024-04

…More

Dakota Steinhaus (STAY HUMBLE)

2024-03

…More

jason erdmann

2024-02

…More

Vanity Eiland

2023-05

Today was my first time trying their subs and it was so delicious I would highly recommend them if you want lunch 🙂Best subs I've ever tried in my life

Vaj Kuam Xyooj

2023-05

It was my first time trying out this place. The food was good, but they messed up my order. I told them no onion and add shredded lettuce. At least they got the no onion right, but it was missing the lettuce.

Andy Schmidley

2023-11

…More

Nicole Mariani

2023-07

…More

Becky Luedtke

2021-05

We went during a very busy time and still had an excellent experience. First time ever eating there and food was amazing. Excellent service, lots of workers present, managed well! We will definitely go back.

Dana Hill

2022-05

Have been here twice. Ordered it online to be picked up. Both times I have payed for extra meat, and in the comment section I have specified that I wanted extra of a particular kind of meat, but not the other. The first one I ordered was the Italian--asked for extra salami but not extra ham. I ONLY got ham on my sub. The next one I ordered i asked for extra Peperoni, but not extra of the top round. It appears as if I only got extra of the top round. If I was not paying extra each time to have my sandwich the way I like, that would be one thing. But it appears im paying extra to have it exactly how i don't want it. Don't get me wrong, the subs are tasty. Just don't do a special order, as it appears they have no tolerance for them.

A K

2023-07

…More

Opening Hours

Monday 10 AM-9 PM
Tuesday 10 AM-9 PM
Wednesday 10 AM-9 PM
Thursday 10 AM-9 PM
Friday 10 AM-9 PM
Saturday 10 AM-9 PM
Sunday 10 AM-9 PM

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet