Jay-Mar, Inc

4.8 (347)

2130 Jay Mar Rd, Plover, WI 54467
(715) 341-3445
jay-mar.com

Claimed
Pet supply store
Animal feed store

Service options

  • In-store pickup

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

Rebecca M K

2023-05

Friendly service, awesome prices & a wide variety of quality products to meet ALL of your animal’s needs ♥️

wayne berrend

2024-05

Great selection of grain free dog food and dog treats. Friendly and knowledgeable service.

Phillip Hamilton

2024-04

Good people, pricey store but have what I am looking for usually.

Katrina Galvan

2024-04

We got good information about grass seeds I was amazed with their knowledge of all their products

Cindy Bice

2023-06

This was my first time here and I was impressed!This place is filled with things to make your yard pretty....the wind spinners are great and there's so much to see!The people were very helpful and we got a nice Oriole and Humming bird feeder.I will definitely go back.

Clay Tee

2023-06

I can only speak about the bird seed aspects and in that category this place exceeds expectations. Variety, selection and price are all tops in the market. If you live in the area it should be your first choice but I also encourage anyone passing by on I-39/ US51 to get off the Hiway and check it out. You won't be disappointed.

Mark Herron

2023-10

Cool place to purchase pet food as well as animal feed. They have bird food too. We went her to purchase Fromms dog food. It was a good experience.

Chicagomike68 Chicagomike68

2019-05

Very friendly and knowledgeable staff. Will go extra mile to help you. I bought stinging nettle weed killer and a pound of wild flower seed.

Jenny Knutson

2024-03

Such a cool place for gift ideas.

Toni Wanserski

2019-05

Love this store! I could spend hours browsing. Expect to find lots of stuff for your garden & outdoor spaces. Everything from bird seed & feeders to windchimes & decorative yard art. Plus they have a really great selection of greeting cards.

Marie Rohrer

2023-11

Great selection of wild bird supplies at great prices.

Laurel Radomski

2021-05

Very nice store, lots of helpful and friendly staff. So much garden decor, it's hard to choose just one item. They also have Corinthian Wind Chimes, the BEST quality chimes available, in my opinion. Lots of animal and bird food. My only negative would be that the garden decor that is hung up high too often had the price tag way up out of reach and view.

Shelby Makuski (Maximus_Makuski1)

2021-05

We buy most of our pet food here we buy seed for our birds in bulk along with different kinds of bulk nuts for our wild birds and our parrots and 2 rabbits along with buying toys for our bunny's and parrots and dogs and bails of hay and treat sticks for our bunny's and big bones for our 2 rottweilers that last them 1-2 weeks and small organic treats for our 3 small dogs

Amy Barthels

2023-06

Love this store.. Nice selection of pet toys, food, & treats. Friendly, helpful staff!

Myra West

2018-05

Excellent selection of dog toys, food and accessories for your dog. We also purchase a ton of feed for all the wildlife we feed. The staff has been very helpful in making sure all of our wildlife animals survive the harsh Winter. Also love the giftware section. Staff is very helpful and always loads your vehicle with your purchase. Stellar staff!!!

Laurie Jackson

2021-05

Very helpful staff. Brought my dog in to shop and she was welcomed and even got a treat. Really nice gift area, and great bird seed. Nice selection of pet supplies.

Kristine Leitzke

2023-05

I stopped in a week ago and the have a 25% sale going on this month, for the purchase of any home or outside decor! Always helpful there!

Trudy Shampeau

2020-05

Very interesting things. I was picking up bird food at Walmart. 17.00 a bag for my big birds and about the same for my small ones. About every two weeks. I went to jay-mar and spent 60. On one big bag that last 3 months. Nice friendly people.

sarah resch

2020-05

Tons of variety, lots of interesting things for your pets, yard, and gift giving needs! Looking forward to strolling through again! Plus, they foster kitties from the local Humane Society and who can resist kitty pets!? They also had a ton of cool and unique cat trees that aren't the standard tacky carpeted type and are great quality and!

Liz Williams

2020-05

This is such a great place. Not only do they have farm type stuff but fun stuff too. A friend and I spent quite a bit of time just browsing at all the accessories they have. The people who work there are so friendly. And they carry heavy stuff out for you. If you haven't been in the store you must go there.

Marjorie Falkowski

2020-05

I was barely in the store and I was asked if I needed help. Hadn't been there in years since I no longer have pets so I believe that they were treating me as a new customer when the young man approached me. I was picking up something for a friend and the employee walked me over to the variety of that product, assisted me with deciding what to get and then offered to carry the 40# bag directly to my car... stopping at the checkout to tell them what I had purchased for payment purposes. NOW THAT'S WHAT I CALL FABULOUS CUSTOMER SERVICE. The prices are very reasonable,huge variety from which to choose, and they expanded in the last few years their home/garden decor. I will definitely be back to purchase for myself. Oh, BTW, employee took the purchase to my car in pouring rain!!

Susie Gast

2020-05

Love this place for both my dog food and birdseed needs. Also has great items for gift giving that you don’t find other places.Staff is absolutely awesome. Helpful and genuinely friendly. :)

Kate Vogel

2021-05

Nice selection of yard art, chimes and bird baths. The women working there were helpful. If we hadn't been a hurry, I would have liked to explore the rest of the store.

Cash C.

2020-05

Always enjoy going here. The breadth and depth of household, animal, and ag products they sell make it a good place to visit. Their kitty corner, which houses adoptable kittens from PCHS, is a high point for when my wife goes in. I also enjoy the special seminars they host.The people working inside the store are great people always willing to give a hand when needed.In the end , I've never been disappointed after a visit here. Remember that leashed pets are welcome. Another plus!

Laura Ullman

2023-07

Great place for wild bird supplies. Also big variety of chimes and lawn ornaments.

Melissa Anne

2019-05

LOVE this place! I always buy my bird seed and bird feeders here. If you're looking for a unique gift, they have that too. A plus that the staff is super friendly.

Kevin Reaper

2023-05

Great folks! Only place around where you can find baled hay at a decent price. Wife loves the farm shop. Will be back!

Kari E Novacek

2023-07

Stopped for sunflower seeds. Was surprised when they packed up and loaded for us. Great service.

Sandy Loos

2023-06

Helpful and knowledgeable people regarding lawn fertilizer. 👌 A lot of fun items inside this store.

C S (qoder)

2021-05

My son bought a brand new house, and did a budget lawn seeding. It was not doing well. He went to Jay-Mar for their Lawn Ranger program. His yard is now a deep green blanket.So I went here after buying my new home that has its own lawn issues. I took photos of all the different weeds, and troublespots, in my yard. They quickly ID'd the problems, and set me up with a program to get my lawn healthy.The staff is friendly, knowledgeable, and patient. Looking forward to my own lush lawn!

Opening Hours

Monday 8 AM-7 PM
Tuesday 8 AM-7 PM
Wednesday 8 AM-7 PM
Thursday 8 AM-7 PM
Friday 8 AM-7 PM
Saturday 8 AM-5 PM
Sunday 10 AM-4 PM

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet