The Forgotten Treasures Resale Shop

4.3 (54)

1305 W Wisconsin Ave, Oconomowoc, WI 53066
(262) 244-6500
shorehavenliving.org

Claimed
Discount store

Service options

  • In-store shopping

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

Laura Stranc

2023-10

Very cute resale shop! Good prices, and a variety of items. Things were clearly marked, and organized well.

Margaret Namio

2022-05

Fun place to shop! Good variety of quality merchandise neatly displayed and reasonably priced. They have a little bit of everything. This cute picture was just $2!

David Contreras

2023-08

Great variety and prices! Friendly atmosphere;

marty mcfarland

2023-05

Found very nice quality items here on several occasions. Small and easy to navigate.

cass noonan

2022-05

One of the best resale shops ever with the love and support of the community and surrounding neighbors, like Waukesha🌞 Forgotten Treasures in Oconomowoc is always well stocked with beautiful things and happy when you come to visit, browse and find some of your perfect item(s)❣️ You'll want to go back again and again😀

Mary Haislmaier

2020-05

I Love bargain hunting n donating as well. Ya never know what kind of goodies ya can find. The staff is Awesome, friendly, n helpful! ❤😁

jdh272

2022-05

Great store. Reasonable prices and quality items. Friendly and helpful staff.

ME

2019-05

My most favorite little shop in Oconomowoc! Great deals and wonderful staff. I always find something nice there. A must see store!!

P Thompson

2020-05

Fabulous thrift store! Clean and well organized. Nice staff and your dollars spent are supporting a great cause.

Allison Chicorel

2022-05

Cool place! Will probably go back monthly to browse. 😊

Sarah Brunner

2022-05

Walked in my first time here. Said hi to the two women behind the counter and was completely ignored. Tiny selection.

Kelly Coleman

2018-05

The staff is super nice and there's a lot of one-of-a-kind items. Something always follows me home!

Nancy Martin

2020-05

Very happy people, and a great store. Will be going back for sure

Joeleen Drall

2022-05

Very cute and perfect for looking for something you might need.

Heidi Kinsley

2021-05

Delightful ladies work here and always great bargains to be found.💕

bubba kahuna

2022-05

Suprised to find alot of modern clothing in all sizes at very reasonable prices!

Sherrie Pinno

2021-05

It was a very clean store and the ladies were very helpful

N N Mora-Dai

2019-05

Love this place, great finds and the staff are so welcoming!!

Vikki Cooper

2021-05

Smaller for a thrift store, but very clean, well organized and friendly!

JoAnn Adams

2020-05

Very neat place and staff was really nice

cristine crum

2022-05

Cute place find neat stuff there

susan smith

2020-05

Very nice place 2 shop. Ouatily modems.

Mark Adams

2021-05

The workers were very rude. I won’t go back.

nan schroeter

2021-05

We went just to see what they had- dead people's stuff!

Donzetta Towne

2021-05

Lovely place to shop& donate🌟❣

Barbara Berg

2021-05

Nice resale shop. Community supported

liz sasaki

2020-05

Love it, great stuff at a great price!

Yvonne Wilson

2021-05

Clean store. No craft items.

Richard Morrison

2020-05

Lots off old and new

Clare Zimmerman

2019-05

Love this place!

Opening Hours

Monday 10 AM-4:30 PM
Tuesday 10 AM-4:30 PM
Wednesday 10 AM-4:30 PM
Thursday 10 AM-4:30 PM
Friday 10 AM-4:30 PM
Saturday 10 AM-2 PM
Sunday Closed

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet