MyBaitShop.com

5 (3)

8194 Oakwood Ave, Neenah, WI 54956
(833) 289-5873
mybaitshop.com

Claimed

Bait shop

Fishing camp

From the business

Small business

Service options

In-store shopping

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

raphael satanzski

2023-05

I am very happy to have found MYBAITSHOP! What an awesome collection of lures at really good prices. Also Keith and the family work hard to keep their customers satisfied and are super great to work with if there are any issues or questions. I love that I can get old out of production lures here I probably would have trouble finding anywhere else and at a good price, and get a history lesson too. Recycling some old "warrior" lures and catching fish on them is a great feeling. Mybaitshop is proof that the "little guy" can put a lot more care and attention to detail into their business, and it feels like buying from a passionate and kind human who cares rather than from a giant corporate robot who will probably sell your info to data brokers.

Barry Battista

2023-05

After talking with Keith and his vast knowledge of antique and discontinued lures, and manufactures of musky lures, Keith has not only become my go to seller, but a friend! He has always helped me in my pursuit of acquiring new lures for my collections, be it some old vintage lure, or something that's been out of production, and I've never been disappointed! The lures are always as shown on his website. Shipments are super quick, and well packaged to protect the lures and their boxes. Keith takes real pride in what he sells, how he treats his customers, and packs and ships his products. Keith is one of the top sellers I've ever dealt with in every aspect of the transaction. I've been dealing with Keith now for 3 years and you couldn't find a better guy to deal with! Now I just have to find a way up to his shop to trade some fishing stories!

John Holtz

2023-05

MyBaitShop is THE best!!! If you are an angler or collector this place is a must! With the best customer service, knowledgeable staff, and amazing stock! I am a lifelong customer, and you will be too!!!

Opening Hours

Monday	Open 24 hours
Tuesday	Open 24 hours
Wednesday	Open 24 hours
Thursday	Open 24 hours
Friday	Open 24 hours
Saturday	Open 24 hours
Sunday	Open 24 hours

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet