Johnson Creek Card Shop and Collectibles

Ray Murray

2023-10

I frequent this hobby shop. Wally (the owner) is always there to greet you with a smile on his face. Very knowledgeable on sports and trading card games. The $1 boxes are always my go to. They also carry a variety of collectable supplies and boxes/ packs of cards from every sport to choose from. Highly recommend going there if you are in the area.

RJ Savic

2023-07

Stopped in to check out the shop on one of my many trips between Madison and Milwaukee. Was looking for sealed product and their inventory was pretty much non-existent. Wally (owner I believe) explained to me that he was waiting on a big restock order and that my timing sucked... I said no problem and turned to leave, but before I could Wally was throwing free packs at me just for stopping in. Ended up buying one of the three sealed boxes he had in stock just because Wally was so friendly and honest. Now, the shop will be a must-stop when passing through J.C. Just goes to show how important good service is. I'd rather shop Wally's temporarily empty shelves than somewhere fully stocked and manned by a-holes.

Jeremy Lucas

2024-03

Best card shop I’ve been to in Wisconsin. Not a lot of card shops are into just cards anymore and this has it all!

Travis Peartree

2023-09

Great local card shop. Wally always has a great selection of cards and always giving good deals. Many times I stop in I’m offered a cold soda while I’m browsing the singles boxes. Great selection of card supplies as well. I’d rather drive here then go to overpriced LCC in Oconomowoc.

Erin McCauley

2023-10

Awesome place!!! Owner is super knowledgeable about all the cards. Got some amazing cards and will definitely be coming back here.

Ryan Yort

2023-05

Stopped in for the first time Friday 10/7 and was very pleasantly surprised with the amount of vintage cards and memorabilia of all sports to trading games such as Pokémon. The owner, Wally, was very kind and easy to work with. You can tell he cared about customers from offering beverages to interacting with the children that were there with their parents. I highly recommend giving this gem of Johnson Creek a visit if you’re into cards or just want to talk shop with kind sports enthusiasts! Will definitely be back again!

Alexander B Witt (Alex)

2023-05

I was super impressed by this place. I was researching what to do and where to start with my 25+ year old collection of MJ cards and landed here because of the reviews. I can say, he did not miss the mark. Super informative and welcoming. Keep up the good work.

Paxton

2023-12

10/10 Wally nice guy

Eric Peterson

2023-05

5 stars is not enough. Stars throughout universe. Great store Great products. Kind and Knowledgeable staff.I see more return trips here, in my future👏👏👏👏. Oooo and I would be remiss if I did not salute the security dog.

Camron Monroe

2023-05

We had a great afternoon hanging out with Wally, chatting and learning more about the card collecting hobby. He’s passionate about it, is very knowledgeable, and is really generous to young kids getting into it. Thanks again Wally!

John Kittel

2023-07

Stopped in to buy some Pokémon singles and when I walked in there was no one to greet me and ask what I was looking for like every other card shop usually does. instead the only person there left me wandering around for 5 mins until he finally chose to say something.Even tho Pokemon is clearly displayed as being sold here there is barely anything and is mostly all sports. Very sad and disappointing.Will not be back.

Mike Lanas

2023-05

Wally has a great selection of cards and new boxes for purchase. A fellow Packers guy who loves Favre. Very fair on trades and shoots you straight. Completed a fair trade for both sides and I will surely be back in the future!

Jason Robinette

2023-05

Repeat customer. I give them 100 stars. Great service. Great collection. If they don't have it. They will help you find it.Bought a few complete sets of 1980s baseball cards this past weekend. First time buyer and the man behind the desk was GREAT. Very helpful and knowledge of the card industry. Will definitely do business again. Instead of 5 stars I give them 10 stars.

Griffin Phelps

2023-10

Really fun place really good for kids that aren't going to spend 30+ Dollars on a card and there are $1 bins and my son loved those.

Kaitlyn B

2023-05

Owner was super nice and helpful. Answered all of our questions! Didn't have what we needed yet but let us know when it would ship to the store! We'll definitely be coming back!

Leaf Deavers

2023-05

Wally and Josh are both very nice people and they both know what they are doing. They have given me so many discounts in the past and they have given me free stuff too! They have been very nice every single time I have been in the store and I never go home disappointed! Thanks for everything!!!

Kevin Arnold

2023-12

Wally was a great help. Very friendly and informative.

Brandon Rue

2023-05

Best place around for people who love the hobby!! Wally is a great teacher and even better man! Go check them out.11/10

MonterreyJack3

2022-05

The shop is great. Wally is bery personable and friendly. They have what you need! All the supplies amd great value boxes to dig through. Stop by and say hi. I come from West Allis because of how you are treated, like family.

SG

2020-05

This is basically everything you want in a local card shop:1) Very, very nice people: Wally, the owner, is a friendly, approachable, and immediately likable guy. Small shops with specialized merchandise can often be intimidating; not this place.2) Comfortable atmosphere. Clean, nice display cases, well-organized stock, seating for browsing, etc.3) Fair prices on a good selection of sealed packs and boxes. I also highly recommend the $1 box, which was on sale and which I subsequently picked through for probably an hour.I live a ways out - about 40 minutes - but I'll be going out of my way to make it back.

Just Jeff

2020-05

I almost don’t want to leave a review. I’m worried too many people will be in here when I want to go :). We’re lucky to have good card shops around, but this stands above all the ones I can think of. I’ll drive 30 miles to spend a few bucks more to make sure this store stays. Wally was so helpful and knowledgeable, I wished I could have stayed longer. I’ll plan to stop by whenever I’m able.

Everette T

2023-05

Our first time here, we come from city of mke, it did NOT disappoint!! Wally was very friendly and helpful. We will definitely make a return to buy more collectibles/cards from here!!

Anne Acker

2022-05

My nephew has recently gotten into collecting sports cards. I found this shop on Google and so glad we did! The owner couldn’t have been any nicer or more helpful! My nephew was thrilled with the cards he found and can’t wait to go back! We highly recommend going here!

John Peterson

2021-05

I can not say enough good things about Wally and Johnson Creek Card Shop. We went there for my son's birthday and Wally did everything he could to make it a special occasion for him. His prices are fantastic, he was personable, and they had a very good selection. We will definitely be back!

Joe

2020-05

I was looking to buy some baseball cards on our drive home from Madison to Chicago. What a great store and Wally is amazing!!! Not only did he have what I was looking for (Cubs cards, of course!), but he was sooo patient with our 10 year old son and 8 year old daughter. I highly recommend this place and can’t wait to go back!!

Rebecca Land

2021-05

Made the trip out to this shop today for the first time and did not walk away disappointed. Was greeted immediately and very kindly - had great conversation and came out with some very nice base cards and a competitively priced hobby box. If you're looking for a place to collect cards while feeling at home, highly recommend you stop by!

Caitlin Brunner

2023-10

Absolutely love the kindness of the staff. Will definitely continue to do business in the future!

Broderick Brancato

2021-05

Great experience! First time ever going into the shop and was greeted with pleasantries and was offered a beverage. Wally, the shop owner, was very polite and informative. There was a big selection of base cards, sleeves, top loaders, figurines, and Packers/Brewers collectibles. There was also an assortment of high end Packers/Brewers cards and other high profile player cards. There was an abundance of blaster boxes and hobby boxes of all sports to include Pokémon cards behind the checkout counter. Wally offered a military discount and was very supportive of the military.It was a great experience and I cannot wait to go back. Thanks Wally!

Sean Poudrier

2021-05

This Card store is the best I've been to to this day, The workers are super friendly and very knowledgeable and does not try to get over on you like alot of people would these days. He doesn't hesitate to give advice whether its good for his business or not, it's not all about the buck here with these guys and that's tough to find in this day and age. If I could leave a 10 star rating I wouldn't hesitate. Just an awesome experience here at JC Card shop.

Haley Devenport

2023-08

Great card shop! Super friendly owner. Fairest prices around as well!