America's Heritage Antiques & Collectibles

James Aderman

2023-11

America's Heritage Antiques is a higher-end antique shop. The owners have collected beautiful pieces, many of which have been lovingly restored. It is spacious and well-lit. Note: the store is open from sprung through late October.

Anne Holland

2022-05

This lovely store on Main Street in Hayward, Wi is a treasure for anyone that enters! I was new in town last year and literally stumbled upon this wonderful store. The owners are thoughtful and kind and are very knowledgeable about each item in the store. I realized how special this place was in the first 5 minutes and have purchased treasures there for my home that I absolutely love. James and Suzanne know so much about each piece in the store and can tell you anything you want to know about it...type of wood, what part of the country it came from, the year it was likely produced based on hardware, carvings, etc. If you want something special in your home, please go to America's Heritage Antiques and Collectibles! The owners will welcome you in and you will see for yourself what a special place this is! In addition, if there is something you are looking for that is not in the store, the owners will do their best to find it for you. I feel blessed to have found these wonderful people!

Brooky “Indi” Conchita

2023-09

THE best antique store yet! Such a nice and open building with a beautiful, vintage ambience, along with magnificent pieces... might I say the French accented desks, mirrors, etc. I love this place, and the hospitality from the cashier.

Peggy Skinner

2022-05

Just a gem of a store. Items are well curated and clean, and many/all are unique items in great condition. We purchased a few original pastels in gorgeous old frames and a small desk from 1830’s New York. Owners have knowledge of all the pieces - and update regularly. It’s a stop we make whenever in the area (and sometimes it’s our primary reason for going to Hayward!)

Rachel Hartz

2023-09

Our absolute favorite antique store! The owners are incredibly nice and are always open to helping you find anything you’re looking for. We make sure to stop in every time we’re in town, and always come out with a new piece of history to add to our collection!

Kaitlin Burns

2023-10

The owner thanked me for not bringing my children in the store. I won't give my business to anyone that doesn't support me shopping with my children. My children are respectful and have gone to many antique/thrift stores with me and I have never had an owner comment on my children. Very disappointed as I was looking forward on browsing their store while on vacation.

Cris S

2023-05

This was a very nice antique shop in the downtown area with a lot of high quality products! It is definitely pricier than most of the antique shops in Hayward but the quality matches the prices imo. Me and my boyfriend had actually been looking for uranium glass and the woman working (I wish I remembered her name!) read my mind and showed us all of the uranium glass and we ended up getting a very cute uranium glass kitty statue and a tiny greyhound glass sculpture. We were just there on vacation but will definitely check it out again whenever we're in town!

Ashley Geyer

2023-07

Love, love this place! The pieces were absolutely beautiful! The owners Susan and James were so kind and welcoming! Will definitely be going back to purchase some dream come true antiques!

Monse Evans

2023-05

James, Suzanne and company were so nice and welcoming. Chatting with them, asked what I was into and all the said old fountain pens at the moment. In a minute Mr. James was getting some from the back and of course purchased some. I LOVE my pens and mechanical pencils puchases. I will definetly go back to this store time and time and again. I definetly appreciate an antique store with space to enjoy and admire every piece without looking like rummage sale with at least room to walk around comfortably and clean . So intrigued by the amazing furniture pieces and even old books... will be a stop for sure on my trips to Hayward.

Sierra Waite

2023-05

Such a great store! So much to look and and find. Even if antiques aren’t your thing, or you don’t have the budget to buy anything, this store is still worth the stop. There’s so much to look at, from paintings, furniture, books, nicknacks, and so much more. You will not be bored just taking a look around. The owner is such a kind women!

Michael Jakobsen

2022-05

We found this wonderful antique store in Hayward, Wisconsin. We asked if they had milk glass because good friends of ours had lost all of their amazing antiques in the fire in Paradise, California. Not only did the have some, but they mailed it for us. They contacted us twice later with pictures of milk glass that they had in, and were able to send this to our friends. That is going above and beyond ! We so appreciated their efforts! And our friends loved the pieces, which were now added to a new collection.

Debbie Eyman

2021-05

Beautiful store, full of thoughtful displays of everything from fine china and small collectibles to architectural salvage.I am a huge fan of taxidermy and was able to take home a couple of really nice pieces for a very reasonable price.The owners, James and Suz, were very knowledgeable and friendly. James is a local Hayward history buff. It was inspiring to hear his passion and learn more about my favorite Northwood town. My husband and I really enjoyed talking with them and have stayed in touch.We can’t wait to go back next season!

Gregory Eisinger

2021-05

I’ve been purchasing from this store for about two years now, and I can’t recommend it enough! The selection is phenomenal. The quality of the antiques is exceptional. Suz and James are wonderful to work with! Definitely make it a must stop if you’re in Hayward, Wisconsin looking for something fabulous.

Dulcie Majetich

2022-05

I love this store! They have an amazing selection of one of a kind antique items. Suzanne is so kind and helpful. I took my parents with me to shop here last weekend and they had as much fun chatting with Suzanne as they did shopping! We will definitely be back!

Adam Johnson

2022-05

We enjoyed stopping in this store! It has little bit of everything, from smaller items, coins & jewelry, to furniture and everything in between. The quality is great and the staff was super helpful and found a few specific items for our collection. We’ll definitely be back.

Susan “Susieinc” Lawton

2021-05

What a great pleasure it was to find such a wonderful and tasteful Antique & Collectibles shop located right on Main Street in Hayward WI. Something for everyone, including me! The owners are absolutely delightful and extremely knowledgeable. I look forward to shopping there every summer. They have such a variety of many unique items.

Nancy Slow

2021-05

This shop has quality antiques for all tastes and a variety of prices. The owners are so friendly and knowledgeable and each time I was in, the inventory had been updated. It was a pleasure to shop in such a clean and organized store. Looking forward to visiting the shop next summer

Amy Woodington

2022-05

This is a beautiful shop! I was amazed at the selection and display. Even if you’re not into antiques, the shop has something for almost anyone! We purchased a gorgeous Christmas ornament and the customer service was great. They wrapped it carefully!!

Jeff Cutler

2022-05

We visit the store whenever we are in town and always find great additions for our home. The collection is high quality and the owners are very helpful and informative. The store has become one of our main reasons to go to Hayward!

Josie Slater

2021-05

Wonderful owners, and beautiful items. Fun, low pressure environment. I've bought multiple items from them, and always look forward to going to their store. I wish I could go more often!

John Kelly

2022-05

I’ve been shopping with them since they have opened and are great folks with a fine selection of items for every taste. They also go out of their way to find items my wife and I are interested in buying. Looking forward to next year’s new items.

Mo Barsema

2022-05

A great find for quality antiques. Unique pieces in beautiful condition, owned and run by caring individuals who want to keep the past alive and forever appreciated. A must see store!!!

Maxwell Ackman

2023-05

Excellent store with some very cool hidden gems! I loved all of the animal-based pieces of art! Very clean and welcoming store

Shelly Smith

2022-05

Very disappointed 😞 beautiful store but I walked the whole building and was never greeted. Conversations were taking place with friends and arrangements to go shopping. I finished seeing front to back and No one said a word. I will think twice about ever stepping foot in there again!

Todd Somers

2023-05

Great folks and a great store, always a stop on our trips up north. A great mix of unique and high end pieces.

Joyce Woychik

2021-05

Beautiful inventory....well maintained shop with wonderful, personable owners.