Kelley Country Creamery

Ryan Mackman, MBA, MHA

2024-04

If you're stopping at Kelly's Farmstead don't miss out on Kelley's Country Creamery next door. They make their ice cream themselves. It's excellent, and everyone is super friendly. It's the perfect way for the family to cap off a day of visiting with all the animals. Plenty of flavors to choose from, so there's something for everyone.Parking: Parking was incredibly easy.Kid-friendliness: Kids love ice cream and this store loves kids. Match made in heaven.

Chris Goggin

2024-04

Made it back to our “ice cream” happy place! While it’s a little detour on the trip between Green Bay and Milwaukee - it’s definitely a must do! 12 plus flavors, sundaes and shakes, and the pre-made selections look yummy too. Plus, in the summer you can sit outside near the farmer’s fields and cows who helped to create the ice cream. Definitely make the trip!

Tomo Stojakovic

2024-04

Best place to get amazing tasting ice cream. Service was quick and friendly, big servings, plenty of flavors to choose from. You can either dine in. Or sit outside in a rocking chair to enjoy the country setting. I highly recommend stopping in for a cool treat. And if you have dogs. They even have pup treats so they can enjoy something cool with you.

Melissa Rose

2023-09

I love going here. There are so many ice cream flavors to pick from. I always add hot fudge to mine cause why not! It wasn't overly busy today on a Monday. Plenty of parking and not long of a wait time as can happen on weekends. Seating both inside and outside. They have cakes, cheese, and pop too. I most definitely recommend going here.

Jess Marie

2024-04

We've been here many many times. Service is hit or miss. I get the same sundae every time, however it's rarely made the same. Since business has gotten "bigger " things aren't as personable, the younger adults and teens working aren't always friendly and have a know it all attitude. If I'm paying $6 for a sundae, I'd like it made pretty much the same every time. Sometimes, when they are less busy or we get someone who has worked there for a while, the sundae is made how it should be. However my kids enjoy the ice cream cones and different flavor options each time we go.Today I had an issue with my sundae, I asked the young man if he could fix it. With an attitude he took it, put a small swirl of topping and slid it across the counter and walked away. I was going to let it go, went out to my car, but I wasn't going to waste $6 on another sundae I'm not going to eat. So I went back in and spoke with another young lady who asked the "manager" to help me. The young lady put my sundae in the freezer, with ice cream that they'd be serving to others, not knowing where I just was with my sundae (this is a huge food safety/sanitation violation). I told the manager I'd rather just get my money back because I was no longer in the mood to have ice cream. She got a bit of an attitude and said "I'm not giving you a sundae and your money back." I said that wasn't what I was asking, and even told her the other girl was starting to make another sundae when she didn't need to. She refunded my money. After today's transaction, it will be a long while before me and my family come back, as I was already on the fence due to previous visits.

Mike Cathey

2024-04

What kind of place doesn't let you try the ice cream? More than 6 bucks in the trash. Right in front of the kid. Said it was eclaire or Boston cream pie...OK. I like both of those anyway. Worst ice cream I ever tasted. If I had only known what it tasted like, I could've chosen another flavor. No tasting? Well, if my first experience there is an indication of their policy. You can keep it.

Jason Shepherd

2023-09

Always friendly and delicious. They also have great banana splits. You really can't go wrong with anything on the menu though.

Sandi Landowski

2023-10

How can you possibly decide what to get when everything looks and sounds delicious? Ready packed ice cream in lots of flavors, specialty sundaes, build your own sundaes, cookie sandwiches, and so much more! You HAVE to come here!

Jennifer Wunrow

2024-03

…More

Amanda Hugenkess

2024-04

…More

Michael Hammock

2023-05

This is a PHENOMENAL ice cream shoppe -- the kind that has sundaes that are big enough to almost be classified as a meal. Their turtles are heavenly ( smothered with chocolate fudge, caramel and pecans ) and their ice cream flavors-of-the-day are definitely worth checking out. Do yourself a favor and give this place a try...trust me when I say that you'll be glad you did !!P.S. -- My wife and I visit here with some regularity, the last time being for our anniversary in early September. I had the usual, which for me is a Slow Moving Vehicle ( i.e. -- a Turtle Sundae ). Absolute heaven-on-earth. I've added several more pictures that I took on this visit, including several of both the inside and the outside as well as one of the sign near the road as well as my sundae.

Kelly NorthLee

2023-09

We love going to Kelley’s! They always have great service and delicious ice cream. Clearly they’re well loved, because there’s almost always a line out the door! It moves quick though and the service is excellent. We tend to try out different sundaes-they never disappoint!

Heather E

2022-05

Believe the hype! This shop is amazing! From the varieties of daily ice cream flavors to choose from, to the take home freezer items, there is something for everyone. The cookie sandwiches are amazing - and specialty flavor changes monthly. It's best to follow their Facebook page to know the flavors of the month - both ice cream and sandwiches. You can take these items home or enjoy them there either indoors or on their outdoor picnic tables or rocking chairs, enjoying their amazing country setting. The cows grazing next door are actually the ones they use to make the ice cream.They even have a jar of dog treats - our dogs smell them as soon as we walk into the door. Be sure to get their punch cards to earn your self a free scoop or free specialty sundae after so many purchases!

Danielle B

2023-09

Sooo good! Had a s'more sundae and 4 flavor sample with strawberry banana, blueberry cheesecake, coffee toffee, and carrot cake. Amazing ice cream!

Amy Remigio

2023-05

All I can say is you have to go here. The icecream is amazing, I have a hard time finding Blueberry Cheesecake icecream and they have it here!! Check their website as the flavors change daily or weekly? Such a cute place out in the country. You can sit outside and eat your icecream on rocking chairs. They sell ice cream qts to go along with homemade cheese curds. Just get in your car and drive here! Highly recommend!!

Isaiah Quintana

2023-12

…More

Mz Castellano

2023-05

First Time Out Here...Heard About This Kewl Country Place From Church Friends in West Bend...Im New To the Campbellsport Area so they Said Gotta Come to Eden and Get Some of That Good Good Ice Cream..!! I Had the Buter Pecan Big Ol Single Scoop Waffle Cone That was Melting on me in the Very Windy 93 degree Weather Faster than I Could Eat it...lol..I Will Bring My Hubby out Next Time Most Def !! Great Place to Build Memories and I personally Loved & Used one of those old Fashioned Rocking Chairs with the Beautiful Scenery Outside...Thank You & GOD BLESS..P.S..GIRLS ARE VERY POLITE AND HELPFUL

Ross Kaiko

2024-04

…More

Steve Brooks

2024-04

…More

Caleb Pausma

2024-05

…More