Sweetie Pies

Terry Erb

2024-04

…More

Kristin D

2024-01

If you like pie, you need to come here! The Pie Lady is passionate about what she does, and will make sure you leave with something you like, that you will have time to bake to perfection. She discouraged us from getting a whole pie, because we weren’t sure we would be home long enough that evening to bake it properly, suggesting instead several of the small individual pies, and they did indeed take a long time to bake, so we enjoyed them for breakfast - so delicious! They encourage you to call, but even had several varieties of gluten free pie in stock.Dietary restrictions: They had several kinds of whole and small individual gluten free pies available frozen when we stopped in, but offer a larger selection if you call ahead of time.

Tom C (Traveller Tom)

2023-07

Wow, great key lime pie! My wife said it was the best key lime pie she ever tasted and she doesn't normally like key lime. She loves cherry pies which i see from other reviews, are even better!Super fluffy whipped cream, nice key lime filling and crumbly graham crust is absolutely delicious.

Teresa

2023-11

I am a bit of a pie snob and this was one of the best pieces of pie I have ever had! We tried the cherry crumble pie (with homemade vanilla gelato) and the cherry apple pie (with fresh whipped cream) and they were both so good. Fresh, flavorful, not overly sweet, and not even remotely artificial. You can tell they were homemade with fresh ingredients. I would come back here again and again! This is a must-stop when visiting door county.

Vi S

2023-06

Delicious cherry pie. Flaky crust and the filling was packed with tart, yet sweet, cherries. You could taste that it was real fruit. The lady was extremely kind, energetic, and helpful. I would say this is the best place to get cherry pie in door county.

Tasha Elle

2022-05

What can I say about this place? Well, first off, it's the most adorable pie shop I've ever seen. Secondly, the woman who sold us pies personified "sweetie" in this place's name (although her name was Carol). And thirdly, but not one bit least... the pies were amazing!! Perfect sweetness and crust. We got a slice of the chocolate pecan, a slice of blueberry peach, and 3 slices of cherry pie. The only regret is we should've bought more. I'd drive 5 hours again just to go have pie here.

Faith Leon

2022-05

I heard this was the place to get the best Door County Cherry Pie, and guess what it was!! Tart and sweet at the same time. Crust cooked perfectly and not all runny inside, just filled to the top with cherries! All it needed was a scoop or two of vanilla ice cream! (Oops where is the pie?) Tiny bit pricey.

Marek Gerszewski

2023-09

The best cherry pie I ever ate :) Everything fresh and delicious. Very nice and friendly service. I recommend to visit this place.

Radi Johnson

2022-05

Yum! Yum! Sorry I had already taken a few bites of the strawberry rhubarb n cherry crumble!Lots of places to sit in the sun or shade!You can't go wrong with this pie!

SFaye Kachikis

2023-12

Small selection since we got there later in the day. Bakery is pricey. Crumble on top of pies was good, but the crust was tough. Cute shop.Parking: sufficient number of spots

C. Ernest

2020-05

Love, love, love Sweetie Pies! What a great specialty bakery just outside of Fish Creek in, what I would consider, an outlet mall of sorts, for Door County anyway! But the pies! The pies, pies, pies...oh my! Usually only open on the weekends from 10 to 4 and they certainly can sell out of a pie faster than you can say, "pecan pie!" We love the cherry, obviously, but they make a mean pecan and all there berry pies are well worth a taste. Best thing is, you don't have to buy the whole pie! Sweetie's does slices. They even have a bargain on their day old baked goods, which, in my mind, is even better!

Jamie Wilson

2023-08

Walked into the shop and it smelled amazing. Great pie in different sizes and slices. Very friendly service.

Barb Sharbuno

2023-10

Best cherry pie in Door County. 3 lbs of cherries in each pie. Crispy light flakey pie crust. Staff are friendly and know their business. Will definitely be a repeat customer.

Jess Law

2023-09

We tried apple, pumpkin, pecan, and chocolate chess pie - all of them were good but pumpkin was my favorite. I’d love to go back again and try more of the many pies they make! Get there early in the day to have the most options. If you want a whole pie, make sure you call a day or more in advance to make a reservation, otherwise it’s by the slice.

Paula Bray

2023-08

An online article about the best cherry pie in Door County led us to Sweetie Pies, and we are so happy to have found this place! My husband said it was the best cherry pie he ever had. Except for my mom’s, I definitely agree!

Joshua Shirley

2023-09

I'm just going to quick add to the positive reviews here...Stop in, it's a nice setting, we happened in on a Sunday with live music.Those things were just a bonus to what the pie had already given us. We tried a few varieties with the apple crumble being by far the favorite. Really isn't much more to say, stop in for a slice, I'm sure you won't be disappointed.

Teresa Young

2020-05

Delicious pie, and cherry pie is a Door County staple! Sweetie Pies has many options to satisfy your sweet tooth. You can either buy them by the slice or the pie, and they do offer slices á la mode as well. There is seating outside, or you can take it for later if you have patience. 😉 The ladies here are sweet and kind and helpful.

So Thereitis

2024-04

STILL A SOLID 4solid 4-5 stars -the quality is suburb! it would not surprise me if they are rated highly in door county. It is a very small shop with major flavor. of course we tried the cherry pie , they do have others, and it is in my personal top 3 cherry pies from a seller! this place is excellent. i would say that the price would be high if it weren't one of the best pies in the area. i was skeptical because of the price, but it didn't let me down! i recommend it!!!!

Jacob Quigley

2023-10

Very very overpriced. Also if you want a full size pie...you hafta call a day beforehand. Sweetie pies was really great up until about 6 months ago! Don't bother. Go to bea's homemade products instead. Or seaquist.

Dave Mariani

2021-05

Some very good pies... I loved the blueberries..my wife and son loved the tart flavor of the raspberry pie.. While the apple pie had a hint of clove? Maybe? Great pies worth the stop.. Call ahead to get what you want.

Andy Fallon (LT Fallon)

2019-05

Amazing pies and good pricing. Definitely stop here if you are in Door County.

Nea Hahn

2023-11

…More

Brian Filippi

2023-09

One of the best... crusts are great.

RJ Rauen

2023-05

Pie was dry for cherry pie. Crust was good. Expensive at $6 for an average size slice.

Kelly Carney

2023-06

The pies are absolutely delicious with fresh ingredients.

Tim Heyse

2023-05

These are the freshest most delicious pies I have ever eaten. You don't know what great pie is unless you have tried these. I guarantee it will become your favorite.

Luann Christian

2023-05

We stopped at sweetie pies to try a piece of cherry pie. Because we were not allowed to go in and see the pies but only stand on the porch and order, we decided to travel on. Later we stopped at Bayside bar and had a piece of the best cherry pie. To our surprise we found that it came from sweetie pies. It also was $2 more. Next time we will definitely by at sweetie pies.

mc smarto

2018-05

The pies are always fresh. My favorite is the chocolate pecan pie!

Tony Cantore

2023-05

Hey all just wanted to share with my experience on cherry pie shops.. All shops have cherry pies selling for $14.99 to 16.99.. for a whole pie. Their pies are selling for $25.00 * Warning * unfortunately Sweetie Pies are selling for $7 to $10 dollars more than anyone else for a pie in all of Door County. Just a fair heads up folks. Don't be taken for a fool.

Nancy Jo Austin

2023-05

They were nearly closed for the season, but they sold us a frozen cherry pie which we took back to the cabin and baked. It's good pie, if a little sweeter than I like, and nothing beats a good home made crust.