Fish Creek Market

Blair Alvidrez

2024-04

The store is great. But the cafe upstairs has a sign where you order coffee and food that there would be a 15% gratuity added. After ordering food and coffee I commented I did not want to pay the 15%. The girl taking the order commented there is nothing she can do. I explained, cancel the order. A gratuity is defined as an extra amount of money for services rendered. I don’t give a gratuity until I’m pleased with the food and service. Not before. I think it’s just arrogance to apply a gratuity at the beginning of ordering. I am totally against this trend of stores and restaurants asking for a tip for every purchase. Learn to give good service, then you get a tip. Not before. This place could use some tips from the restaurant down the street, The While Gull Inn. Their service is excellent and worthy of a big tip.Update: I posted my review on the market because I could find the restaurant on Google maps. I found it now and will post my comments on their spot.

Jon Gulbrandson

2023-06

Amazing. Sandwiches. Full stop! Ok, not quite done here.... Not only does this place boast a great selection of locally produced goods, but the sandwiches are on point!!! Its a "build your own" sandwich menu, but they are amazing!! Generous meat portions. Delicious bread. Super crispy fresh lettuce. They should come up with with some signature recipes because i bet they'd be awesome. I dont normally take pictures of my food, but I had to. The staff (owners?) were also very kind and helpful. I highly recommend this place for a quick bite. Head over to the park directly across the street for a perfect picnic with your amazing sandwich.

Taylor Ely

2023-10

This place is beyond amazing! I work close so when I forget to pack a lunch I just walk up the street. I introduced myself to the owners when I was new in town and since then they’ve been nothing but sweethearts! Its the little things like when I walk in I’m immediately greeted with a smile followed up by conversation. Often when I go in Stephen is back making delicious, quick sandwiches and when I say quick I don’t mean he just throws them together- he’s just THAT good. They have little paper slips with SO many different options for the sandwiches alone, but then also throw in 2 sides! They’re literally picture perfect sandwiches… even the way he wraps them! Lol (I thought the slips were just coolest idea ever). I usually see Christina assisting people at the counter, but if she’s not there she’s running around the store re-stocking shelves and keeping the place pretty and put together. They’re both very sweet and hard working people, I love to see the business they put so much effort into succeed! I definitely recommend this place to as many people as I possibly can!! Thank you guys for providing such an amazing market with a vast variety for all.

Carl Thompson

2024-01

Wonderful little market with specialty items. Gluten-free this and small batch that. Non-gmo items plus locally sourced delicacies. Small business charm.

Jack Nolan

2023-05

Fish Creek Market is such a nice store and best for a quick sandwich from the back counter. Incredibly friendly staff!

Bryon Shea

2022-05

Deli sandwiches are fresh and delicious! Great selection of groceries and unique food items.

Jone Kiefer

2024-04

A true gem of a local grocery store! The owners are so friendly and they pay attention to what their customers need and want!

MNtwinsfan4ever

2022-05

Lots of fun stuff to look at and buy! Found some nice sweatshirts to take home. Will definitely visit again. Love the little town too!

George Gogola

2023-11

Small footprint, so a limited selection. Still, everything you need with a quick stop. Parking can require some patience during crowded weekends.

Madeline Johnson

2023-05

This is a great place! Has what you need but also some fun high-end specialty items to try. I found some great Door County items from here that weren’t cheesy like most locations. Great decor, very clean and the staff was helpful and welcoming!

Tim Bailen

2023-06

They have Country Ovens Cherry De-Lite, including the 1.75 pound bags!

Desiree Snyder

2023-05

Came on a bus trip and all area restaurants were full. We ordered sandwiches at the back deli, I ordered the New Yorker. It was delicious. The home made pickles on it made the sandwich. The fella working the deli was awesome. The rainy day was made so much better thanks to his humor and great attitude.

Der Koenig

2022-05

Quaint, local, boutique market, in Fish Creek, Wisconsin I met the owners and they are great people. Also stopped for some lunch. If you need staples and you're in Fish Creek stop by the Market.

Jenn Much

2022-05

Stopped by for the first time to pickup a bottle of wine as a gift. The owner was at the register and was so welcoming and friendly. I asked for help finding a locally made Door County wine that was sweet. He was so helpful in showing me what wines he recommended. We had a wonderful conversation and it just made the whole visit pleasant. Will absolutely be back. There were so many unique items available for purchase, truly a great selection.

L Cullen

2023-05

A wonderful little market with a little bit of everything. The cards and mementos are creative and unique, both the prepackaged and made to order snacks are good and fresh, a nice selection of wines and a welcoming presentation of all of the products throughout the store.The only issue that someone might have is that in bringing the breath of product they have in such a small space, unless you are just browsing or know they have what you were looking for (ie "market") before you head over, you might not find what you are looking for.

Hannah Hinz

2022-05

The new owners of Fish Creek Market are wonderful people and have done an amazing job freshening up the space! So many wonderful offerings; please support this great location business! We love getting the fresh deli sandwiches (seriously, the best you’ll ever have!!! Silly to say about a deli sandwich, I know, just trust me), and were so impressed with the wide variety allergy friendly options. We appreciate all your store has to offer! ❤️

Nell E

2023-05

This shop has some of the most unique items I have ever seen. Myself and each of my friends bought something. You can find all kinds of original handmade crafts. They do have some other things as well like moccasins, socks, and t-shirts. They have pieces of art made from diferent rocks and minerals. They have carved and etched moose antlers. They have hand made leather coin purses and wallets made to look like different animals. They have jewelry and so much more. This really is a beautiful shop you will not regret stopping by. And the photo below is the coin purse I bought. They request no photography of items in the store understandably.

Hannah Wild

2021-05

This is such a good addition to Fish Creek! Owned and operated by the sweetest family, they do an excellent job keeping items in stock and preparing delicious and affordable deli sandwiches and snacks. The sandwiches are generously portioned with meats and cheeses and always well seasoned. I’ve never been disappointed with their goods and services, making it easy to support local small business.

Kristin T

2022-05

Such unique and fun offerings!! Best sandwiches made to order! Eat outside in the park.

Becky Rosazza

2023-08

A must do! They have it all! Incredible selection of wines, fresh produce, and delicious prepared sandwiches to order!

Scott Richard

2023-10

Extremely fast service. Food was good and priced reasonably. Wait staff a real pistol.

M.K. Sung

2021-05

Nice place for groceries with fresh fruits and vegetables.

Nyoka the Jungle Girl

2021-05

Great general store and I appreciate the way they are handling mask requirements. All places should have this system in my opinion.

Kipp R

2021-05

This place is under new ownership and it’s now fantastic. Their sandwiches and salads are good, the store is well-stocked with basically anything you need, their liquor selection is good and not expensive and...most importantly, their service is friendly. So glad they’re making such a success of the market.

Sandy Stansell

2022-05

The new owners are nice and caring people!! They have made so many improvements to the store. If you had a bad experience with the previous owner - give this establishment another chance...we did and are so glad we did! Thanks Christina for making this place a must visit!

Katie U

2020-05

This place has really gone downhill in the last few years. The selection is extremely limited, and it can be tricky to find basic ingredients. They also keep odd hours and close the deli counter at what you would think would be peak sandwich times. The last two times I was year, I left without buying anything because they didn’t have what I needed. Used to really root for this place and love the deli counter for lunch, but I’m sad to say it’s not what it used to be.

hello littmanns

2018-05

We love the deli sandwiches. They have limited space, so they don't have everything, but they do have good options, even if they aren't exactly what you had in mind; quality products.Hubby likes to go in on weekends and talk to distillery reps who are there offering samples.

Claire Erickson

2021-05

Wow! New owners - super nice! And a really rad collection of goods and produce. A very impressive ethnic food section as well! Nice to have the classic Fish Creek market sandwiches back!

Mike

2023-07

Great place to get higher-end foods while in DC. Don't go expecting to find all of the essentials though.

Derek Bickford

2020-05

This grocery store just outside of peninsula state park has just the basic needs. The checkout person was extremely rude. He has customer service burnout that's clear.For a tourist town all of your focuses on customers and good service will bring them back again and again. I won't return to this store.