Carrington

Bryon Shea

2024-03

The staff is incredibly kind and attentive. Asher and Dianna behind the bar are hard working and very kind. The hostess and other server were smiling and hardworking.The Carolina Chicken Sandwich had a nice flavor, was hot and tasted fresh. Nice job, Carrington!

Rich McGee

2023-11

…More

Dan Nelson

2023-09

…More

Paul Steltenpohl

2023-05

Ignore the haters. Likely they are from Illinois and impatient after their long drive from hell to paradise. 5 star cherry BBQ ribs, succulent lobster, fantastic ribeye and the DC new fashioned and DC side car drinks were incredible. Oh, and the service was great. Let the haters hate!

Jessica Sayeski

2023-05

Wonderful service! Randi was super friendly and attentive! Great meal!! Ribs were very good! Can't wait to come back!

Michael Belligan

2020-05

Stopped in for dinner during a stay at Landmark Resort. Great food, great service. Prices were a little higher than other places in town but I was happy to pay it by the time we left - I had the Friday fish fry and my brother had the bbq ribs with the cherry bbq sauce (the bartender said it was the one of their two which wins the most awards). The ribs fell off the bone and the sauce was good. The fish fry was great, plenty of fish and their preparation was fine. We sat at the bar and had EXCELLENT service from the bartender. I will DEFINITELY be back and advise anyone to give it a shot if they feel like staying on site for a meal or a drink. I’d love to come back during warmer months when the patio is open - the view appears to really be something!

Christina Imsland

2022-05

The service was not impressive. After being seated and waiting for several minutes, I ended up going to the bar to order drinks. We must have had an old brochure that advertised "happy hour" from 4-6. We were there at 5:00 and was informed there is no "happy hour". 😟 While we waited for a server, two other patrons received their drinks and placed their orders. We ultimately had to flag down a waitress. The crab cakes were overpriced for the portion size. The main meal (chicken piccatta and fish fry) was okay and hot. In summary, I would try the Carrinington again, hoping for better service.

Andrew Knoblauch

2020-05

We enjoyed the variety of food available for the Sunday buffet brunch, including eggs, waffles, bacon, sausage, omelettes, crepes, potatoes, ribs, and prime rib. Unlimited mimosas were also part of the special.Our server was very attentive even though we were mainly serving ourselves at the buffet.It’s a very short walk to this restaurant if you’re staying at the Landmark Resort. The views of the woods and bay are also a great asset for this place.

michelle gasparek

2023-11

We were really looking forward to dining there. The atmosphere was nice. The service, “Ken” was amazingly bad. Never asked if we wanted water, another drink, dessert,etc. Didn’t bring condiments we had asked for repeatedly, was truly horrible. We were in a great mood, he really didn’t meet our needs. We had reservations for the next night, were excited about the next night, but canceled our reservations based solely on the horrible service on the previous night. Wouldn’t go again.

KHBC K

2020-05

Stopped in on a Saturday night for the all you can eat Asian food. The made-to-order stir fry was definitely the highlight. The burger was perfectly done. We will be back.

Deb Koch

2022-05

The Carrington Door County (previously The Carrington Pub & Grill) has long been a favorite place to dine.They have a good variety of dishes on their menu from the appetizers, to deserts steak, hamburgers, salads, pasta dishes, a great fish fry, (I enjoy the baked haddock) and much more. I've always been very satisfied and filled with their dishes.Their staff in the peak season is fabulous with their professional and attentive service. Off season is a little more laid back, and I'll admit I enjoy the summer help more, but this will always be our go to place of choice.The atmosphere is welcoming with a double sided fireplace as you enter the building and tables on its flipside in the main dining area to enjoy the ambiance and warmth while you dine.There is a full bar and they occasionally have live entertainment and in the winter months karaoke for all you rising stars 🌟They offer inside as well as outside dining that offers a view of the tranquil grounds of the Landmark Resort and of course the lake with spectacular DC sunsets. In cooler months they have the patio heaters throughout the outside dining area.Overall I highly recommend checking out the Carrington Door County.See you next time!

Katrina Bauman

2019-05

Weird way of running a restaurant here. We felt very rushed by the whole set up of 5-9 p.m. Asian Food Night and the guy who was dressed in a dirty t-shirt and jeans kept asking us and everyone else how we were doing and then told us at 8:30 p.m. they wanted to wrap things up eventhough it's listed they serve until 9. They ran out of shrimp before we finished eating as well. Our waiter was great and the food that we got to eat was delicious. The "specialty" drink I ordered sucked. If I wanted a glass of water with cherries in it, I would have ordered that and spent a lot less money. It's not a normal restaurant like I'm used to that is open and welcoming to its customers. The trash talking tables around us didn't help us relax much either. If I'd known it was such a time strict event, I would have got our kids out of the pool earlier to eat here. Eventhough our waiter was sweet, knowledgeable about everything on the menu, and helped as much as he could, I left this place feeling pushed around. Again no fault of our waiter! Will we return? No.

Nancy Kuhlmey

2024-04

…More

jeff goldberg

2023-09

Excellent food although a bit pricey. Their cheese curds are not as good as others in Door County. The service is very good ,but the kitchen is quite slow.The steak was well cooked.Beautiful view of the Lake.Highly recommend.

Patrick Lind

2023-05

Our waiter was amazing, very knowledgeable had the specials memorized, was caring and compassionate. The food was nothing less than spectacular. The drinks were amazing. Very timely on service for a party of 10. Seating and view was amazing as well. 10/10 there was not a single negative about our experience.

Coleen Salome

2023-12

…More

Keith Beste

2023-08

We had a small wedding in Egg Harbor and had our “reception” dinner of 15 people at the Carrington. We wanted a wide variety of options on the menu, a view, and to sit outside. The Carrington checked all those items on our list. The months leading up to our wedding we visited the Carrington numerous times to taste the food while also confirming our outdoor reservations with the host or hostess each time we went. Upon arriving on our wedding day, we were told they could not accommodate reservations greater than 10 people for outside due to “insurance reasons”. Needless to say, we were very upset and disappointed that they did not inform us of that the numerous times prior that we spoke to them. Instead, they set up multiple tables outside and our entire wedding could not sit together. While the wait staff was nice, they did not offer their apologies or find a better solution for us. Ultimately the view was great, but we had a very disappointing wedding reception dinner. We will not be back.

the Riche

2023-05

Food was fantastic. Our waitress was outstanding and the view from our outdoor table was spectacular.

Michael Boroczk

2020-05

The Carrington is located on the Landmark resort. The restaurant is nothing to rave about but the food is very good. Service is prompt. Very nice bar area

D N

2023-10

…More

Stephanie Wanninger

2023-06

What a wonderful surprise! We are on the outdoor patio with beautiful views. The outdoor heaters were an added bonus.Our food was excellent, our servers were very attentive.The cherry bbq salmon was perfectly cooked and so good! Others in our party had steak frites, bbq ribs and surf and turf and we were all so happy with our meals.Don’t leave without getting the cherry crisp a la mode was absolutely amazing! 10/10 would recommend

Lori Sandall

2023-06

The Grilled Cherry BBQ Salmon was delicious. The finagling potatoes and asparagus were done perfectly and completed a delicious meal. The whiskey old fashion was superb. Wait staff was amazing. Beautiful view of the bay. Highly recommended.Parking: Lots of available parking.

Lee Haston

2023-05

Good place, great view from the dining room. Old Fashions were well made. I had the ribs and my wife had the baked haddock both were good. Flourless chocolate torte cake was delicious. Staff was friendly and attentive. Our food was brought out in a reasonable amount of time and was hot. Seen lots of negative reviews on this place but we had nothing but a positive experience. If I had anything negative it was that the food is a little pricey for what you get, but these days what's not? Overall I recommend and would return to try more items on the menu given the chance. We returned in December and had another good experience. The service was good and so was the food. We both did the Mediterranean Caesar Salad. I had flat iron steak added and my wife had shrimp. The salads were fresh and very tasty.

Jane Larson

2023-07

…More

Wendy Gaar

2023-10

…More

Andy Fallon (LT Fallon)

2019-05

Amazing view from this restaurant from your dinner seats of the water and the Sunsets. Pricing is fair and food is delicious.

K O'Keeffe

2023-08

…More

Lauren Carlson

2023-05

We showed up on a Saturday around 645pm without a reservation (party of 4 adults) and were told the wait would be an hour. We were fine with that and got a drink at the bar. The bartender was fantastic. The hostess had a bit of an attitude. We got seated an hour later and ordered our food right away. An hour later our food arrived. It was warm and good but very late. The restaurant was not very busy. We would have gotten dessert but we’re sick of waiting so long we paid and left. Not sure id be back considering how long it took to get the food. Come with the intent of finishing a few good drinks before you arrive or you’ll get bored (and hungry) waiting so long.

christina k (Ckaddy)

2022-05

My husband and I ordered from here because it was the restaurant that was closest to the resort we stayed at and didn't feel like eating out. We ordered for carryout and the Spinach artichoke dip was excellent. I ordered the haddock with was also great and my husband ordered a pasta dish which he really liked. The bartender was very sweet and gave us a suggestion for a winery to try while we were in town. Overall it was great food and great service and we definitely plan to go again on our next stay.

Megan Nelson

2023-09

…More