Wholly Cow Frozen Custard

4.6 (158)

637 Main St, Delafield, WI 53018
(262) 646-2555
whollycowcustard.com

Claimed
Ice cream shop

Service options

  • In-store pickup

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

Greta DeCaluwe

2023-06

Such a wonderfully unexpected spot in downtown Delafield! The decor is cute and cow themed, they have a little gift shop as well. The food was absolutely delicious, the toasted bun was a great touch, and the toppings were do it yourself and fresh. Loved fries and the hamburgers, and cannot wait to go back to try more homemade options. Lots of sundae options to choose from. Looking forward to stopping back at this summer spot.

Michele Krause

2023-10

My heart goes out to thank the family for 30 plus lovely years of providing the community a charming ice cream parlor in Downtown Delafield. The owners just retired in Sept 2023. We will miss them. Maybe someone else will keep up the tradition! Many times I had a Golden Calf Sunday. Carmel cashew!

J Truelove

2023-07

Cute, charming. Sweet kids running the place. Frozen custard is excellent and stuff off the grill is good too. Recommended. Sit outside under the table umbrella and enjoy the summer.

William Soderberg

2023-09

Very charming ice cream and food stop. It’s sad that it will be closing in September due to owners retiring. Hopefully it will be sold to someone that wants to continue the legacy.

Angela D

2023-05

If you are in downtown Delafield then you must stop here. Delicious ice cream and sundaes. The folks are kind, and there is a little gift shop selling some local gems or WI souvenirs. You can sit outside at a picnic table, or inside. They also serve some food items.

Oliver Pugh

2023-07

Probably my favorite ice cream place. Very kid friendly. The staff are wonderful and the ice cream choices are great.

Jill Lockerman

2022-05

This is a great little place to grab a burger or sandwich, maybe find a little trinket in the gift shop, eat inside or out, and oh yes, enjoy an ice cream. Even single cones are huge, (you can get a cone with sprinkles!) and the staff is very friendly.

Kathleen Krause

2020-05

It's a local family that has been in the area for 30 years running an ice cream and custard shop. Literally perfect. Clean, friendly, and delicious. The ONLY downside is I'm getting a little husky, luckily winter is coming so get those sweaters out. But really, custard and customer service are totally wonderful here. Yummm

Jeannie Collins

2021-05

The burgers are delicious and big. Also enjoy the sundaes. FYI it's a small place so it takes a little time to get your order. They also have the dining area inside but it's closed -instead you can sit outside at a table. Order at one window and follow the arrows to pick up your order around the corner. Lastly they are seasonal open Spring to Early Fall.

Susan Munyon

2022-05

We had burgers, fries, cheese curds and soda and then after eating we got ice cream! Chocoholic and Mackinac Island fudge flavors on a waffle cone and my husband had lemon bar in a waffle cone! Everything was so good and everyone is so friendly! Small shopping for gift items available too!

Lauren McDonald

2023-05

Custard texture was top notch. But the custard alone has mild flavor, be sure to put some toppings on or get a sundae. Cute place!

Krista Broaddrick

2019-05

Food was kind of overpriced for what you get, which is saying something because it's super cheap. Inside was hot and smelly and playing music that was not kid friendly (I love Rage Against the Machine, but at least use the radio edits when you're not at home) in the middle of the day on Saturday. Chocolate shake was good, decor was fun, but I won't be back.

Sara Staszak

2015-05

A really great little shop. The frozen custard is wonderful! They don't have a lot of space, but make up for it in charm. Both indoor and outdoor seating available. Charming find in Delafield

Brent Mortensen

2022-05

Great frozen custard sundaes with lots of ootions for toppings, including choose-your-own. Burgers are also great with a topping/condiment bar.

Matthew Dufek

2019-05

Great local family owned custard shop. Cute inside with small shop for kids. Very nostalgic and my kids favorite. There no reason to go to culver's when something this good is only a few miles away

Roger Heindl

2023-07

Delicious burgers & ice cream!

D Wink

2019-05

We drove to Delafield to try this place based on Fodors great review. We tried so hard to like it but Fodor got it wrong. Kopps and Leon's are unquestionably better. Holy Cow's custard had the consistency of ice cream and poor taste. We ended up throwing it away. If you live here, it's a place to go for mediocre ice cream. If not, don't waste your time and money.

Andrew Loizzo

2017-05

Cow-themed Wisconsin custard and ice cream shop that you'll want to check out. Outdoor seating in summer and lots of indoor seating. Can't go wrong with the ice cream in a waffle cone!

Scot Muehlmeier

2019-05

Try the burgers as well! Just the right amt. of protein & bread. Super cool small town and always clean and managed with true care of the customer.Wi. custard is a treat.

Susie Thompson

2018-05

Historic Downtown Delafield location is fun and convenient to everything! Olde fashioned Ice Cream Shoppe atmosphere, with fabulous food and yummy ice cream for dessert or afternoon treats!

Bill Kulterman

2023-05

Always a treat. The custard is fabulous and the people working there are very nice. Whenever I am in Delafield I make sure I stop here.

Andrew Nothem

2023-06

Best chocolate malt I have had in a long time. Reminds me of the ones my dad and grandpa used to make!

Steve Karolek

2018-05

Delicious frozen custard served by friendly folks. Shop for creative jewelry and other trinkets while you're enjoying your treat!

Amy Roehl

2020-05

The custard was good, but to put it mildly, the musty smell in the dining area was enough to ruin your appetite. It was our first visit and not a good first impression.

Jennifer Svedin

2023-05

Delicious custard and friendly staff! Get the peanut butter dream Sunday. You won't regret it.

Juliet Rogers

2023-05

Best place ever! Vegan shakes, sundaes, burgers & best cheese curds in lake country!

April D

2020-05

Wonderful place to eat and great burgers and sundaes! Definitely a place you want to visit in Delafield. Service and staff were so fun. Thank you!!

Karen Shuff

2023-05

Great burgers and, of course, ice cream! The staff is always friendly and helpful.

Paul Guenther

2021-05

WOW!! Creamiest Frozen Custard I have ever had

Zach Nelson

2022-05

Great milk shake , terrible portions on the food , had around 5-6 small cheese curds for an order , very very very overpriced , nothing special about them either

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet