Tilly's Pies

Amy Schaetz

2024-03

…More

Susan Trapp

2024-03

…More

Rebecca Recks

2022-05

We loved these pies so much we went 3 times this week!!! Bought single slices so we could try several- all delicious!! If I am ever within 100 miles of here again I will definitely add it to our itinerary!!! Best pies ever!!!!

Like2be Fishing

2023-05

A great find! We stopped in for a slice of pie and coffee and left with a full pie as well! Fun to talk to Trudi, the owner on this beautiful fall day.

Jim Mac

2019-05

Great selection of scrumptious pies and drinks served by friendly people. A welcoming place to hang out and enjoy the locals. We found Tilly's during a road trip from California and it turned out to be one of the best stops on our trip. Don't miss it when you are near Cable.

Matt Goodman

2018-05

Amazing hand-made pies: perfect crust and truly deep flavors! Proprietor and pie-making extraordinaire, Trudi Rebsamen, bakes in the spirit of - and in honor of - the late cycling legend Steve Tilford!

Dan Wiersgalla

2023-07

…More

Candice DeBriyn

2023-05

We ordered 2 pies for a birthday recently. I'll admit I thought they were a little pricey BUT I was absolutely blown away with the taste and quality! We could tell they used fresh ingredients and the flavor was amazing! I would order again from them in a heartbeat. If you're thinking of trying them, do! You won't be disappointed!! Thanks Tilly's for helping make occasion very yummy!

thomas teppen

2023-05

I am a pie critic. I think the secret to a good pie is the crust, and Trudy has it figured out. One of the best pies I have ever had, and I have searched far and wide for good pie. 👍

Phil S

2023-09

…More

Shaunna Wissing

2020-05

Stopped in today and ordered a piece of cherry pie to take home. The pie was spectacular and had the most delicious flaky crust i have ever had. The service was great and the building is so cute. I wish I had bought a whole pie. Worth a road trip!

Sheila Holtberg

2023-05

The Raspberry Cream was AMAZING! Thank you, Trudeau! Go in the store! More pies there then what the website has on it! So glad we did! Breads and butters are delightful as well!

Katherine Gilmer

2019-05

Our whole family loves Tilly’s! It’s hard to pick a single favorite flavor—there are so many delicious choices. We’ve had Chocolate Walnut Stout, Apple Struedel, Cherry, 3 Berry, and Key Lime, just to name a few. And the pie crust is phenomenal! A really wonderful addition to Cable!

T Tass

2020-05

Average pies at average to high prices. Nice backyard to eat outside in. Good pizza right next door. Kinda hard to figure out how to order pie if you're there getting pizza.I like the idea of a store devoted to pie!

Rick

2021-05

We bought an apple pie. We have had several pies but this one was not good. It had fewer apples and a lot more crumples even at the bottom of the pie. The apple were only in the center so when you cut it lit looked full. But that was not the case. As you worked to the back of the piece of pie you ran out of apple and had crust and crumbles where apples should have been. I am positive we will not be back. At $28.00 for the pie I would expect apples not crust and crumbles. Disappointed

Carmen W

2019-05

The best Apple Struedel pie I have ever eaten. They make shakes with their day old pie... brilliant!!!! My daughter devoured her slice of key lime without even giving me a taste.

Jim Cossitt

2023-08

Steve Tilford lives on, I met Tilley in 78 and we were on the same team for years.Trudi Rebsamen makes outstanding 👏 👌 🥧 🍰

Michelle L

2022-05

Amazing pies! Do not pass this place by if you are near Cable. The pie shakes are incredible and the owner is so sweet and friendly. We will definitely be back.

Jennifer B

2023-05

The BEST pie crust I have ever had, and that includes family homemade crusts. So delicious. Worth a jaunt to have a taste!

Mandy C

2022-05

Delicious homemade pies. You can buy it by the slice or the whole pie. So many varieties to pick from. Will definitely be a frequent flyer at this little treasure of tastiness

Larry Hudlemeyer

2023-05

Great place to get pie in the Northwoods! Already baked....no fuss, no muss....try more than one piece/flavor, I got 4! Would stop again!

Colin Landers

2020-05

Wonderful pies, ice cream and a combo, pie shakes! Pies were flavorful, slices or full. Ice cream is avail if, they had a good amount of choices, all kid friendly.

Y. S.

2021-05

Stopped in Cable to drop off a letter at post office. Saw Tilly’s Pies. Had to look. Bought a blackberry peach pie. Fantastic! Trudy, you’re a great cook!!!

Hannah Erickson

2019-05

Fantastic blueberry crumble pie! Neat story behind the place and friendly manager.We went in for a couple prices after a ride and ended up purchasing a whole pie. 😋

Christopher Burkley

2023-09

…More

Tim Dietz

2019-05

Great place to get some delicious pies! Its the new place tonstop on during the trip to the cabin. Happy to have such a great pie place in town.

Meadhbh Cleary

2019-05

The pie is incredible and the staff is absolutely phenomenal!! We’ve tried 3 pies and couldn’t pick a favorite - they’re all so good!

Aoife Cleary

2019-05

The best pie ever! Trudy is an angel! Such a blessing for Cable and an amazing addition to the Northwoods!!

Toshia Martin

2022-05

Cherry pie was fantastic! Gluten free pie is avaliable. Love this place.

Patty Vilmann

2022-05

What a surprise! Discovered this by accident. Best homemade pies!. I can’t believe this amazing place isin little Cable!