The Old Timey Shop Antique Mall

Wendy Herr

2024-05

This wonderful place is full of goodies. Everything is clean and very neatly organized. The proprietor is very helpful and kind. And Waldo the shop dog added the icing on the cake. Stop here and have a wonderful experience.

N M

2024-05

A truly magical place. So many beautiful items and great prices. Customer service is outstanding.

Aaron Berkenwald

2023-09

Just happened to come across this amazing treasure of a store while on vacation. We have visited many Antique Malls and stores in a number of different states and there is not a single one that can compare! Besides finding an amazing selection of glassware items you can find knowledgeable staff with great personality and charm. Found many great items at very fair prices. We only wish that this store was close to home. Without a doubt a reason for us to return to West VA. Thanks for a great experience! Looking forward to seeing you again in the future.

Tammy Estep

2023-08

Soooo many gorgeous pieces of glass. I bought a couple of things . Staff was friendly, good location and easy parking.

Calie M.

2022-05

What a great shop!! Lots of variety, lots of stuff to see. This shop is so much bigger than I thought it would be, which is so much fun when you think you make it to the end, and oh! there is another room! The lady working there was super friendly and the prices were very reasonable! We will definitely be stopping by there again!

Matthew Early

2022-05

I absolutely love this place. The store is MUCH bigger on the inside than it appears from outside, and I highly recommend browsing the entire store. I picked up a few beer steins that were made in West Germany in the 1950's, and a few cooking utensils that I have not seen anywhere else. Please visit this store.

Teeny Hobo

2021-05

June 8th was my first time going to the store. It was such a lovely experience. The kind lady that was working there was so helpful and nice to us. I felt so good while visiting. I’m just so glad to have found this store! I recommend it to any antique lover! You won’t be disappointed! The selection is nice! As well as the staff!Blessings to the store staff for making my visit to Milton special and something to remember!I will definitely be a returning costumer!

Gabby P

2021-05

Super nice shop! Friendly and helpful person working at the front desk.Found a number of treasures and will definitely be back. Great prices and lots of choices. Place is clean and is bigger than it looks from the outside.

Mairead Hannigan

2019-05

Great deals...and friendly service - thanks from Canada!!

Angie Reed

2021-05

The best antique mall around. I was worried when I walked through the door and saw a lot of Blenko glass. I thought that there was not going to be much variety. As I walked around I was pleasantly surprised. I bought an awesome McCoy cookie jar and several other treasures. The cashier was really nice. Great experience.

Priscilla Donohew (Cis)

2020-05

Our favorite place to go in Milton. We live in Charleston but it's worth it. Love the lady behind the desk but everybody is extremely friendly and helpful. So much to see and new items always coming in. Well worth a visit. They know us as Willys parents because of a antique doll we bought there ( long story lol). Please visit here, you won't be disappointed.

Robin McDerment

2020-05

We found an enamel bucket we liked. It was in very good condition. For the most part, the store consisted of mostly glassware and dishes, not a fan of those things. This was our first visit, but I am sure it won't be the last. You gotta muddle through the useless stuff to find a gem, like we did yesterday.

April Woodyard

2023-05

They have a lot of nice glass. Most of it's really high though. Even the glass that was half off wasn't reasonably priced.

Chris Arvesen

2020-05

I come here about every other Saturday after my trip to the flea market to look around. Sometimes I have a glass piece to sell to raise money for grocery for my family. The lady at the counter is always a sweetheart and makes me a very nice deal I've never had any complaints

Linda Shipley

2023-05

We stopped by on our recent road trip through the area. A great variety and number of antiques - which was slightly less after we left.

Paul Law

2019-05

Excellent experience. Found many Fenton items and other old items for my collections. The ladies were very friendly, courteous, truthful and helpful. Would highly recommend to anyone interested in antique items.

Shelby Lynn

2018-05

WARNING everything is GLASS!!! Hand blown colorful GLASS. Yes there is some furniture, magazines, small figures here and there. Friendly people. Be careful, certain areas you can trip if you don't watch the stair s. GLASS!!!😣

Mltch Newman

2023-08

Nice antique shop, plenty of pretty glassware & friendly staff.

James Eaton

2023-05

The ladies that work here are super nice and fun to chat with. Great bargains. Beautiful selections.

Phil Whitmore

2022-05

Great store with very nice items. Very organized and does not have much craft or flea market items. Staff was very friendly.

Drema Mayes

2023-05

Great customer service very clean shop has unique items some of them one of a kind😉

Darryl

2024-02

Nice place nice owners

Corey Portalatin-Berrien

2021-05

Lots of glass but the service was terrible. No greeting or acknowledgement. The person at the counter did not even bother to look up when I had a question.

Julia Branard

2022-05

So much variety. I loved this place and looking forward to my next visit.

Katie Neese

2023-05

If you like glass this is the place to go, they have to much Fenton glass .

CHARLES SMITH

2021-05

Very nice staff. Lots of reminders of the past. The best part was spending time with my daughter.

Russ Duker

2017-05

Lots of unique items, worth exploring. If you like antique glass items, they have the largest selection I've seen in an antique store.

James Byers

2015-05

it is a very nice shop. I had a very nice time there and we plan on going back some time

Linda May

2019-05

Enjoyed my visit...lots of items to buy...nice and clean displays.

Diana Hughes

2018-05

Wonderful clean place. Bigger than I ever thought. Everyone very nice and helpful.