Newman's Pour and Pies

Rachelle Jeppesen

2024-04

…More

Aaron schwartz

2024-04

…More

patrick murphy

2024-05

Food was excellent and the staff is 5 star.The only thing that was tacky was the plastic silverware.Have you ever tried to eat a breakfast burrito with a cheap plastic fork? If you're going to dine in, bring your own silverware.For a $30 breakfast for two, I'd expect a little more class.

Emily Benjamin

2023-06

I've been there three or four times now, and always had a good experience! Before I saw their portion sizes, I felt like prices were maybe a little high, but they're so generous with portions that it's definitely a good deal! Even the lightweight size sandwich for about $10 is easily 2 meals - I ate less than half - and I noticed later that there's an option for featherweight size, so I'll get that next time! The honeymoon sandwich (pictured - and that's their lightweight!) was really awesome, although my favorite so far is the Sutton, turkey and avocado. The key lime pie slice came in a giant, shareable size and was absolutely delicious. The biscuits and gravy (if you're sensing a theme, you're right), well, I'll order the smaller size next time, because the regular size comes as 2 open face biscuits so large it's like having 4 biscuits! 😅

Giulia Watier

2024-04

…More

Travis Williams

2024-04

…More

Dianna Lynn

2022-05

Amazing sandwiches that are absolutely thiccc with meats! Beers are super tasty and poured to perfection. Staff are very welcoming, sweet, and helpful. I'm so happy they're here!!! Can't wait to get my hands on some pies!!!Update: banana cream pie was excellent! The coconut cream pie has been the BEST coconut cream pie I'd EVER had!!!!! Shown is the banana 😁 hard to tell but believe me, it's huge!

Oliver Lawrence

2023-05

Nice little place off the beaten path. The sandwiches are huge and delicious. My photo does not do it justice. I need a bigger mouth. Service is down home friendly. Glad they opened their doors and looking forward to my next visit.

Matthew Culnane

2024-04

…More

Cody Sager

2024-01

…More

Sandy Roth

2024-02

…More

Joe Grieshaber

2023-09

…More

Delaney Olmstead

2023-09

…More

kevin pinkler

2024-04

…More

L Simpson

2022-05

Cute place! Great service, fast. HUGE sandwiches !!! Husband and I split a large "Honeymoon" sandwich. Super yum!!! We'll definitely be back !

Jessica Johnson

2023-05

There sandwiches are huge and delicious! My husband and I spilt a large and could barley finish it. The breakfast bagel sandwiches are loaded and very good as well! Love the small town feel . Newman lake NEEDED a place like this ! The owner is also a sweetheart . I will definitely continue to recommend this place to my friends and family.Thank you !

Lauren Lovelady-Cooper

2023-05

…More

Erin

2024-03

…More

Melissa Walters

2023-05

First, the sandwiches!The large size is beyond huge! Wow oh wow.Then, large is great but flavor is there too. Soft bread, juicy tomatoes, and the perfect meat.We couldn't finish because it was all too much.Next, I'm all about service-It was great too both gals working really made us feel welcome and our leftovers were packed for us in a little bag.Stop by this gem for yourself!

J

2023-05

Great customer service and very speedy making our sandwich, the sandwich itself was a big portion and tasted absolutely amazing. Might be the best sandwich I've ever had. Highly recommend supporting this local business. A++

Daniel Rhine

2023-05

…More

Trixey D

2023-05

Such amazing sandwiches! They’re HUGE, tasty and enough to share! Love to try the specials, local brews, breakfast foods! Local family owned and operated♥️

Allyn Ankerbrand

2023-05

I had "The Shadow" sandwich for lunch and a pomegranate iced tea. It was huge and tasty! I ordered the large and it is 2x as big as a regular sandwich. The roast beef, creamy horseradish, provolone cheese, shredded lettuce and tomato slices on thick Sourdough bread all went perfectly together.I have picked up whole pies from here through the drive thru. They are also very good. I will be back soon!!!!!

D- Man

2023-05

Huge awesome sandwiches!They tend to panic when it's even slightly busy at lunchtime.Don't be trying to talk me out of a particular drink I ordered and paid for because you can't handle 4 customers.Otherwise, clean, friendly, and VERY delicious.

David Russell

2023-05

Stopped in for a lunch sandwich, the Best Turkey sandwich I’ve had in a long time. And trust me, ITS HUGE !! Lots of brews to chose from also. Coffee, soda, wine. Definitely going again.

Amy Foxley

2022-05

Amazing sandwiches! We ordered ahead of time and picked up through the drive-thru. We ordered two Newman's and they are huge. I could barely make it through half of mine. Best sandwich I have had. The garlic dill mayo sends it over the top! Will definitely be a regular stop for take out.

Simon Feist

2023-10

…More

Sarah Mitchell

2024-04

…More

Amanda Pritchett

2022-05

My husband has been desperate to try this place for several weeks now. We finally decided to order a pie for take out, and while I was there today picking up the pie I also decided to order a few small sandwiches for my kids and I for a late lunch. Holy moly! The "small" sandwich is still a very generous serving size! My kids each shared a half of a sandwich, and as we're eating, my youngest goes, "this is 100% yummy!" 8-year-old approved! To be determined on the pie, as we won't be digging into that until after dinner, but it sure looks incredible! The service was also wonderful. There's just something about a small town eatery. Will definitely return. ☺

J

2023-05

So glad they are in the neighborhood! Excellent sandwiches, my favorite so far is the Newman. Great pies, if you like lemon, I highly recommend the lemon meringue. And great latte's too.