Olde Towne Pizza & Pasta

Mara Jacobs Horner

2024-04

Nothing prepared my soul for the uplifting and intoxicating aroma of garlic and other herbs and spices that welcomed me when I walked into Olde Towne Pizza for the first time. I thought to myself, “We’ve made a great decision to come here.”And that sentiment remained with me for the entire evening! From the minute we were greeted, we were treated graciously by everyone at Olde Towne Pizza, and especially by our server, Zeynep. Her warm, friendly, professional service made our evening superior.We started with a couple of glasses of wine, and I was so pleasantly surprised by how fruit-forward my Chianti was. So much personality for a house wine! My friend enjoyed a refreshing Sauvignon Blanc, and we cheered these selections.Up next, flavorful garlic knots and ooey-gooey mozzarella cheese sticks were served to us, and we feasted like royalty on these well-seasoned, hot and fresh appetizers. Knocked out by the generous portions, we were ecstatic to have some leftovers to take home.Now for the moment you’ve all been waiting for - this place is called Olde Towne Pizza for a reason! My eyes grew wide and my mouth began to water as Zeynep presented to us the most fragrant, most delicious looking pizza that I have set my sights on in years.The Margherita pizza was our choice, and what a fabulous choice it was, complete with a fresh basil chiffonade decorating the entire pie. Oh, the cheese was melted perfectly, and it was not oily or greasy in any way.As for the sauce…oh, the sauce…I am quite picky about my tomato sauces. I don’t prefer them too sweet, and this full-flavor marinara truly complemented the cheese and the basil so well. This sauce made the experience a few notches above the rest!Oh, what about the crust, you ask? It too, was a delight, crispy along the bottom, and it really held up the toppings well. For anyone looking for a true NY style pizza, I dare say that my Virginian self might be right in recommending this one!Overall, this evening out was full of fun, flavor, and a family feel. You can be sure that we’ll be back again soon!

Samantha Drake

2024-04

MY favorite place to get pizza! I always get a combo pizza no sausage extra cheese and cooked well done. And recently have become obsessed with their hot buffalo sauce on my pizza! It is spicy but so flavorful! This is my absolute go to place for a good salad or pizza! I have had their Alfredo before which is also good but I come for the pizza!

Hoot Bahmandeji

2024-02

…More

Lana Weaver

2023-11

Traveling from Ohio. We ordered pizza and garlic knots to our room The food was amazing. We decided 2 days later to go dune in for dinner. We had garlic bread, salads, spaghetti and meat balls and manicotti. Everything was fresh and delicious. There sauce is very good. The manicotti was the best I've ever had. We then had a homemade piece of chocolate cake, cheesecake and a canoli.They were all delicious. The restaurant was very nice and a cozy atmosphere. The staff and our waiter were awesome. Highly recommend and would go back.

Grant Fifield

2023-09

Great price , great location. We ordered a large pizza, garlic knots, and side of fries. We'll definitely be back. My only suggestion is to talk to the building owner to have 2 bathrooms put in as one well kept bathroom is fine but inconvenient to guests especially those with kids. An upgrade with changing station and sharps box would add something if stuck with one room.

Lorie Smith

2023-11

…More

Tara GRANT

2023-05

I absolutely enjoyed Olde Towne Pizza! We were visiting from out of town and decided to pop in. It's a quaint Italian Pizza and Pasta spot. We ordered appetizers and pizza with both being delicious! The pizza sauce is great (I would recommend ordering extra if you like saucy pizza like we do) and the crust had a wonderful crisp. We were very happy with our dinner.

Camaria Samuel

2024-03

I did take out while staying at Great Wolf Lodge and this is hands down the best meal on my trip. I don’t eat meat and the fact that they had great options other than pizza and salad was amazing and the food was so delicious . Mad that I stumbled across this restaurant at my last night but I will be back next month and I know where I will be eating. Check them out you won’t be disappointed

Sophia Park

2024-04

I ordered the spicy calamari linguine and it's seriously the best seafood type pasta I've ever had. It's got quite the kick, but as a Korean, I absolutely loved it. Kinda tasted like 짬뽕, or jjamppong. My kids also enjoyed their cheese and Hawaiian pizza. I wish I had taken a photo of the dishes but we were so hungry and the food took a while to come out even though it wasn't very crowded. But I'll definitely be returning next time I'm in Williamsburg!

MICHAEL SUTER

2023-10

…More

Kelvin Bailey

2023-05

…More

Due Chuenchujit

2022-05

…More

Katelyn Bowery

2024-04

We set outside on their nice patio. The service was fantastic. We ordered the spinach pizza and it was delicious. We can't wait to go back and try more menu items.Dietary restrictions: They do offer gluten free pizzas for those with gluten allergies.

Kristin Jemison

2024-04

My family ate at Olde Town Pizza & Pasta while on vacation in Williamsburg. As a native New Yorker, if you had told me I would find some of the best NY style pizza I've had in Virginia I would have called you crazy. We ordered garlic knots, garlic bread with cheese, and mozzarella sticks. The garlic knots were incredibly fresh and obviously made from the same delicious dough as the pizza. We ordered a large pizza to share-the dough was very tender and the toppings were at just the right ratio. The desserts were good although not the highlight for us. If we return to Williamsburg in the future Olde Town will be on our dinner list again for sure! Highly recommend for a great family-friendly dinner!

Eyyüp Güneş

2023-07

The last time I ate such a delicious pizza in Naples, which is considered the capital of pizza. Pizzas have an addictive taste. Also, you should definitely stop by for the friendly service and delicious food!Parking: SufficientKid-friendliness: Kid-friendly

STEVEN BEARD

2024-02

The food was so delicious!!! We must return again one day and dine in next time! The garlic bread with cheese is just too good! I think i liked the garlic bread more than the pizza to be honest! Will def be back next time I’m in Williamsburg. Very affordable and clean appearance. The staff is very kind and it was an overall great experience.

Andrew Payne

2022-05

We thoroughly enjoyed our lunch at Olde Towne Italian Restaurant. Our server was very friendly and helpful, and our food was served promptly. We ordered the bruschetta appetizer and enjoyed the fresh taste of basil and diced tomatoes. Also, we both ordered chicken and pasta dishes for our main course. Everything was delicious!

Taylor Johnson

2024-03

We drove up from Hampton for a day trip at Riley’s! Needed something to eat and found this gem less than 5 minutes from the auditorium. Great food! Pizza was amazing and staff was very kind. We will certainly be back.Kid-friendliness: Kids were able to use the restroom safe you

Matt Bitner

2022-05

We stumbled onto this place when our top pick was a 50 minute wait on a Friday, I'm really glad we did. The entrées come with bread and sauce which is very good. The chicken parm is a favorite apparently because I heard 4 people talking about it before we were even seated. Someone at our table ordered it and I honestly think the 3 of us could have shared it, at it was very good. I had the meatball sub, which was good, but a little dry. I was able to add some of the extra sauce from our delicious garlic knots to it, problem solved. They also had and awesome $2 beer special on a Friday!

judy auspitz

2023-05

We were visiting Williamsburg and were looking for any restaurants that were open for dinner on Christmas by searching Google. We weren't expecting much but we were so pleasantly surprised. The atmosphere was a nicely decorated family restaurant Tiffany style hanging lamps. The service was excellent and the food was freshly prepared and absolutely delicious. We both ordered the meat lasagna and it was by far the best lasagna we've had.

Tateanna Byrd

2023-05

Ordered a chicken Philly, just onions and cheese it was delivered. I could already tell it was overly greasy and soggy before opening it, you can see it through the paper . I tried to re toast it nothing made it better it was soggy, greasy and horribly put together basically rushed. I ended up throwing it away, very poor job I will not order from here anymore. I’m sure they could tell it was soggy before packaging it all up. Terrible job for not caring enough to make sure my food was decently prepared. If I could give zero stars I would have.

Clint Holland

2021-05

Walked right in and was greeted with smiling faces. Extremely nice hostess and waitstaff. I was looking for some seafood and pasta. Ordered the Spicy Shrimp Marinara over spaghetti. If you leave this place hungry, it's your own fault; see the photos. The shrimp and pasta were so good. The spices were not too hot and full of flavors. The shrimp were not small. Highly recommend!!

Jeff B

2024-03

My wife and I moved down here to Williamsburg about 6 months ago and we've been looking for a good Italian restaurant that served good Italian food and pizza and finally we found the place. We are both picky with our pizza and even in New York there were places that pizza was so-so but we did have our favorite which the crust and toppings were exactly how we liked them. Olde Town Pizza & Pasta has made it on the top of our list for exactly that. The pizza was excellent as far as thin crust, taste, sauce and toppings. I had pepperoni and meatball. My wife loves linguini and clams and she loved her dish also. The clams were fresh and not chewy and the pasta was cooked perfectly and tasted fresh. The service was excellent! Very attentive and friendly. This restaurant has become our go-to place for Italian food and pizza for sure. We look forward to trying all the other items they have on their menu.

Mackenzie Sowder

2024-04

…More

jason Sharp

2024-03

…More

Kyle Haynes

2024-03

…More

Ann S (Sandwmn34)

2023-07

…More

Steve Gladson

2024-04

…More

Gary B Pacheco

2024-04

Went on a family gate away for the weekend to Williamsburg, VA from North Carolina and found this place from it's review. Went the first night and the place was absolutely great! Restaurant was clean, our server was amazing (all 3 of them, we went there every night we were in Williamsburg, Va) and attentive, and the food was great! The food had a homemade feel and taste, great experience overall. I would return to Williamsburg, VA just to get me some of their pasta!

Mae Alva-Baer

2024-03

…More