Cattlemen's Market

4.8 (102)

538 E Nelson St, Lexington, VA 24450
(540) 463-2333
potterfamilyfarm.com

Claimed
Meat products store
Grocery store
Restaurant

Service options

  • In-store shopping

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

Susan Chapman

2024-04

Walked in to grab some beef bones for my dog. As a long time vegan, I was completely lost but as soon as Charlie saw me, he pointed me in the right direction and gave me a lot of tips for how to provide them the right way for my dog. My puppy LOVES it and it has been great for her teething. Very reasonable prices and really pretty shop. Even though im vegan, I cant wait to go back and visit Charlie and get my puppy some premium food again.

Tony Petryszyn

2024-03

Great spot to stop for food! Friendly staff a delicious food. Easily one of my favorites!

Krista Creech

2024-01

Absolute amazing food that's ready to pick up for dinner. Picked up smoked beef BBQ, Cole slaw, pimento cheese, chips, and chocolate chess pie for dessert. Better than what we could have gotten at any local restaurant. I'll be back soon!

Judith A (jadzzia06)

2023-12

The only place I've been able to find unsalted Virginia peanuts. So happy. My sister purchased banana ice cream and peanut butter ice cream. Delicious. The chance to sample sweet butters at the register are a great idea.The attendant was super nice and helpful.

Dawn Shiarappa

2024-04

Great food eat here once a week wraps and sandwiches made to order are great!!!

John Colyer

2023-07

Fantastic local butcher shop! I get my favorite locally fermented hot sauce from here, along with cold subs, hot sandwiches, spice mixes, and delicious meats from their own farm. The owner also let me try their slices of pizza that will be on the menu soon and it was easily the best in town. Highly recommend!

Douglas Crabb

2023-10

It would be a 5 the atmosphere was great the food was amazing the problem is I am terrified of amphibians, deathly afraid and I walked in and a customer had a bearded dragon on their shoulder. I think for a place that sells food, fresh food and pre packaged food they should have not allowed that in the building. It was very large and scary so that is the only reason it gets 3 stars. For anyone not terrified of creepy crawlers it is a 5. Food is amazing and variety is off the charts.

Jennifer Eagle

2023-05

We just finished eating the sandwiches I brought home from Cattleman’s and they were delicious! Store was busy at the time I visited- lunchtime on a Monday but everyone was super nice and helpful as it was my first time visiting. I will be back! Prices were a bit on the high side but it’s what I would expect and prefer to “Organic but not really and product of the USA but not really” meat from your chain grocery store. If you’re looking to buy local- this is the place to go!

Jill Whitley

2024-04

Went for Nightingale Ice Cream sandwiches. They are so good!!

JCRA

2022-05

I have had burgers in 40 states and 16 different countries. This place has the BEST burger by far. The meat is juicy, fresh, and everything is stacked perfectly. The cook is super friendly and you can fully customize it to your liking.Everything about this shop is excellent, the meat is top quality. I highly recommend this place.10/10

James Lambert

2023-05

What a great little place. Their lunch burger is phenomenal, as is their service. I am pretty sure this is the best burger in town, and I guess it would have to be with its locally sourced beef from their own ranch. 5 stars!

Steve Beck

2023-05

Cattleman's is a great place to get prime cuts of meat and poultry. Any time I have family in the area and I am grilling or cooking it's likely that I got the food from them. Their bacon is great too!

James King

2023-09

Very clean and well organized store. A great surprise is to try one of their lunch sandwiches, off the hook good.

Damodhar “Dam” Mallya

2019-05

Lunch from about 11am-2pm is incredible! Best local cheese brisket steak and fried chicken sandwich around. The fries are good, got the chicken nuggets for my son even! The chicken salad sandwich special was tasty too. Also, you can get local meat, jam, coffee, ice cream, you name it!

Edward Via

2022-05

Great friendly people. I watched the man cut me 6 New York strip , and 2 Ribeye steak's with a butchers knife. And the color and the texture of the meat beautiful. The best steak's I've ever had ! Highly recommend! I'm going back 👍.

Deb Price

2018-05

Everything we've ever purchased here has been outstanding! Beef, Chicken, Bacon, Turkey, gravy, etc. The staff is knowledgeable and helpful. The kitchen staff has amazing talent. Takeout pre-prepared items are soooo good.Make this business a regular stop.

Quinn Cavanaugh

2020-05

Awesome spot with good local items ranging from meats and cheese, to wines and cider. It is a bit expensive though, so if you are trying to spend less than $10, it may not be your best bet. If you're looking for good quality local foods however, that's probably not your primary concern. Prices are fair for what you get.

Alyssa Gauntt

2023-05

You won’t find a better shop anywhere! Charlie cares and it is visible in every inch of his store. Best meat in all of Virginia hands down!

Samuel Campbell

2024-04

Great food and Fast!

Bill Lyle

2019-05

Great selection of fresh meats and local goods. Big selection of sandwiches made while you wait. If you're traveling on 81/64 stop here and get something fresh and homemade for lunch instead of fast food.

Rebecca Smith

2021-05

I've been a customer for 10 years. Excellent meat, milk, and ice cream. And, the locally grown CBD products are the best I have ever found.

Summer P

2023-12

Clean store with a large selection. Friendly staff

Tim Braddick

2020-05

By far the best chicken in town. Only place in town to stock a wide variety of beef cuts (skirt, chuck, sirloin, etc.). Great selection of sausage.

Hyla Cohen

2018-05

Retail location for Buffalo Creek Beef. Get incomparable local beef, pork and chicken here. Prepared food (chicken salad, chili, lasagna, beef stroganoff, shepherd's pie), local cheese and Homestead Dairy products too!.

Erick Resek

2021-05

Amazing top quality meat (and this is coming from an Argentine) the owner even drove me up to the butchery when i asked him for sweetbreads, had them cut off the cow and packaged them for me fresh.

Laura Parsons

2020-05

Cattleman's has made my life much more delicious, from its fresh-frozen shrimp, scallops, and fish to the fantastic bacon to the wonderful regional products it carries.

Laura Watson

2022-05

Yes yes yes and yes. We’ve never gotten anything from Cattleman’s that wasn’t amazing. Best steak I’ve ever had in my life!

Dave Hoffmann

2021-05

Great locally owned store with local products! Beef jerky is incredible, the meat was impeccable.

Mary Modesitt

2019-05

Always have a great selection of meats and other products. We have never been disappointed.

Barbara Claytor

2019-05

The best meat in town... plus many other good things... great lunch place too.

Opening Hours

Monday 9 AM-6 PM
Tuesday 9 AM-6 PM
Wednesday 9 AM-6 PM
Thursday 9 AM-6 PM
Friday 9 AM-6 PM
Saturday 9 AM-4 PM
Sunday Closed

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet