Tilly's Homemade Ice Cream

David T

2023-12

…More

Megan Dougherty

2022-05

Small ice cream shop located in Ferry farm. Decided to try it based off of other people's reviews. They have a variety of toppings and flavors and they're decently priced for portion sizes. My group ordered multiple items. The brownie sundae was okay. The brownie was pretty good however the vanilla ice cream was bland and I expected more flavor from it. The strawberry ice cream was nothing special either. The cotton candy does have good flavor if you want to add that to your ice cream.I felt like they took a LONG time to prepare the ice cream and they forgot my order. They have a few tables inside for you as well as chairs outside. I think that if you have small children this might not be the best place to go unless you're planning on eating in the car. (Maybe they'll figure out how to add more side tables outside to help.)

The Real Crazies

2024-03

…More

Claire Harrison

2023-05

Tilly’s was great! I will definitely be back. It is a classic ice cream shop vibe when you walk in. They have their flavors written on chalkboard sign posted on their walls. I got 1 scoops of nutter butter ice cream in a waffle cone. It was amazing. The peanut butter flavor was extremely present in the ice cream and the chunks of nutter butters were giant. Great shop. I know I will be back.

Lily

2023-07

So cute, friendly employees, and endless options for flavors and toppings! Vegan flavors were clearly marked, when i went the options were vanilla, chocolate cherry, and chocolate hazelnut. Prices were very reasonable for what was offered. Definitely plan on returning.

MK Thick-fil-a

2023-06

Our FIRST time here and we got the banana pudding icecream... WE WILL BE BACK TO TRY EVERY FLAVOR‼️ EXCELLENT 💯🍨🍧🍦 Very clean place too closed Monday opens @2pm-9pm Tue-Sun

Warren McGrath

2023-05

The wife and I stopped in last Sunday after having dinner at Brocks and touring A S Bowman Distillery. Boy that is one cool ice cream shop that has some interesting flavors. They do over some Vegan and Gluten Free options as well. I imagine that place is popular during the warm weather months. Its a small shop so get there early.

Melissa Colombo

2022-05

First time here today and it was super yum! I got a pup cup for the birthday pup (14 y/o,) an apple cider float for myself and a two scoop chocolate java chip in a chocolate dipped waffle cone for the man. So delicious! Good prices and wonderful staff. We shall return soon!

Zachery Rizik

2023-05

Fun local ice cream shop. The ice cream is some of the best in the area. Very high-quality ingredients. They have plenty of options, flavors, and toppings. Brownies, pies, etc. Highly recommend it if you are in the area.

Hasan Kazmi

2024-01

…More

Nicci Konstantinou

2023-06

I love this place!I got the Reeses PB Sundae and just wow!Employees are so nice!You definitely have to go!

Sarah Ortega

2023-05

This is by far the best ice cream I've ever had. My husband and I have been visiting Tilly's since it opened. The owner (and her ice cream ) feel like family to us. Nathan is one of our favorite people, too, and always brings a smile to our faces whenever we come in.If you love ice cream, you'll love Tilly's! Also, try the homemade Brownies and chocolate chip (M&M) cookies when they're offered. Best. Things. Ever.

Collins Wetzel

2023-10

Best ice cream in FXG. Family owned and operated. They named it after their dog I mean come on! Flavors are amazing! And rotation of flavors is great. Floats, Sundays, and special orders. Don't miss this place!

Sandra Holtzem

2023-06

Searched for a local ice cream shop as a treat and stumbled upon this "sweet" little shop. Big flavor and fair prices. I'll be back!

Diane “Dianimall” Krassner

2023-07

I greatly enjoyed the experience of eating ice cream again even though I'm unable to digest moo anymore. The vegan peanut butter chocolate was wonderful on a sugar cone. I can't wait to come back and try it with some fun toppings! I enjoyed my first visit to Tilly's with my new little family.

Los

2023-10

Great ice cream place but when you paid with CC and the cashier decides to add more tip to the tip you just gave him. Come on, you are just giving us the ice cream that we just bought!! ridiculous... and is not a matter of giving a tip!! The issue is that they change the tip...Note - if you pay with a credit card, you might not be paying what you actually agreed... Good luck!

Megan Brown

2023-05

Great local ice-cream shop! They have a huge variety of flavors and always keep a bunch of new creations on rotation,so you never get bored. Nathan was very helpful explaining the flavors and didn't get irritated once; no matter how many flavors we asked to try. I definitely recommend this place!

Erica Parrish

2023-08

When we walked in, there was a tall man there and he wasn't friendly at all. He just looked at us like we weren't welcome there. He didn't even say Hi. My husband's ice cream flavors were good but my flavor didn't taste like what I ordered, and my sundae was missing its whipped cream and cherry. Overall, I'm just disappointed and wished I didn't tip.

Kirsten Yates

2022-05

Sooo good. Friendly service. Very cute decor. Some tables inside, and chairs outside, to enjoy your treat. We will be returning regularly. Best praline and cream I've had ever.

Kenneth Krassner

2023-05

Very friendly, ice cream is very delicious.I mean look at the picture below. Yum!Cinnamon bun ice cream...yum

Wil Jones

2022-05

Best ice cream around. The flavors change often enough that you could have something different everytime and never run out of new options.

Paul Frields

2023-05

Tilly's is small inside, but bursting with incredible flavors. Their handmade ice cream is thick and rich, and agreeably chunky for those flavors that include extras. They scoop generously, so while the price is definitely more than an average ice cream shop, you will know exactly where your money went and you'll be satisfied when you finish! I have quite an appetite for ice cream but I can't finish a double scoop cone by myself. If you're not into cones they also offer cups in both edible and non-edible formats -- and all edible formats have chocolate dipped options! Tilly's banana pudding is LEGENDARY and so many of the others are great too, like mint chocolate chip, raspberry chip, and of course rocky road. You simply can't go wrong here. I'm going to miss Tilly's when they shutter temporarily for the winter!

Miss Chella

2024-04

…More

MikeandPam McGee

2023-05

Great ice cream place...a little pricey. Nice selection of flavors and loads of toppings. The service was fast and efficient. We enjoyed watching people eat various sizes and types of ice cream cones and sundaes. Do not miss this spot...well worth taking time to go. Enjoy!

Jonathan Benitez

2023-08

I am a huge ice cream lover and Tillies is my go to spot for to go Quarts to enjoy at home.Their Oreo flavor is my favorite. FYI Tillie's beats Blue Cow any day 😉

Joell Shaw

2022-05

We had a wonderful experience at Tilly's Homemade Ice Cream shop today! I tried the mint chocolate chip, the chocolate chips were surprisingly big as well as the scoops!!! My husband and son had vanilla while my other sun had strawberry which they all enjoyed. The shop was nicely set up and had a nice variety of options from cones, cups, sundaes and floats with lots of topping options. The staff was friendly, service was quick and with a smile. We highly recommend Tilly's! The location is great, store front is facing Kings Hwy in Ferry Farm.

Burrous Snellings

2023-05

I was disappointed with the flavor of the peach ice cream. Good size single scoop but they could put a little in the cone and not just on top.

John Trammell

2023-05

Best ice cream in town. Yep, even compared to Carls. Huge portions and so good. The word is out on Tilly's so it can get a bit crowded - but worth the wait. Not any worse than waiting in line at Carls..

James T

2022-05

We visited Tilly's Ice Cream simply because we saw the sign while passing through. The idea of trying homemade ice cream on one of the few warm days we had in March was a too tempting. We entered the store which is the end unit of a small single story strip mall in front of a much larger one across the parking lot behind it.When we entered the store there where a few other people waiting for their orders in a small store with a few tables in the area near the door for those who would like to eat their treats inside.At the other end of the store on the wall is a larger board with the ice cream flavors and ice cream treats they have available. Once you've made your selection you order your items at a counter nearby.I had the butter pecan ice cream and it was amazing! The ice cream was not too sweet and very smooth and creamy with a very nice texture. I will definitely be going back very soon.

Tom Mukunnemkeril

2023-05

Been going here for the last couple of months and the ice cream is very good. Today (11/20/22) I tried the cinnamon bun ice cream. The very first bite of it I got all the flavors of cinnamon bun. This is probably my favorite non chocolate ice cream.