Pizza Mill

Courtney Fellers

2024-05

Amazing pizza! Fresh tasting ingredients with generous toppings. The crust is fantastic!! Casual and not tons of indoor seating, but carry-out is also available.Fast and friendly service!

andy gray

2024-05

I was hungry after a long day of hiking and traveling so I decided to stop here for a bite to eat. Ordered a personal size pepperoni and Canadian bacon.Pizza came out is about 10 minutes or so piping hot and loaded with gooey cheese. Crust was nice and thin, sauce was good, toppings were perfect for the size of the pizza.The gal working the counter was very nice and made sure to check in on me a couple times. Nice little seating area, great atmosphere.All in all zero complaints. Great food and service. If I visit Custer again I'll be sure to stop in again.

Tracy McCarthy

2023-08

Cute spot to get some pizza. They have house specialty, or you can build your own. The pizza is thin crust but not crispy. It makes it hard to eat the pizza without a fork and knife. The crust is too thin for the toppings. The flavor of the pizza was still very good. My only complaint is how many flies were inside the restaurant. It made it an unpleasant eating experience.

Stacy Birdwell

2024-04

…More

Phil R

2023-08

…More

Changes to your name will be reflected across

2024-03

…More

Mary Pence

2023-08

When you are from Chicago, you get spoiled when it comes to pizza. The complaint here is a combination of really weird crust, and very little topping. They charge an extra $2.50 per topping and I swear there was only 1 sliced mushroom on the pizza. very little sausage as well. The thick round edges of the crust weren't filled with cheese like you expect, they were filled with undercooked pizza dough. The only 2 sizes were medium and extra large. We got the medium, which was only 12" and set us back almost $30!

S Friedman

2023-06

…More

Debi Chavez

2024-02

Didn’t feel like cooking so ordered Pizza Mill. We ordered Chicken Alfredo and a Reuben Sandwich with onion rings and a side salad. Delicious!!! The salad was fresh, my husband really enjoyed the Reuben and the Alfredo was extremely good. In the past we’ve also had their pizzas, the Towering Timber was delicious!!The service was also great.Debi

Jack Sayers

2023-07

Spent $25 for a mostly crust, small Hearty Logger pizza. It was BLACK- BURNT on the bottom. They couldn’t figure out how to give me a receipt for the refund I asked for so I asked for them to write something out. They acted inconvenienced by my request for a refund and proof that it was refunded. I had already waited 20 minutes, drove down the road 10 minutes. Just happened to decide to eat a piece when I tasted the burnt crust. It was VERY inconvenient for me, yet no apology or offer to discount a future pizza. I’ve learned my lesson. Too bad they couldn’t be even the least bit empathetic.

David Alan

2024-05

…More

Brittany Heglin

2023-05

Umm yes just stop here !! The pizza is delicious 🤤!!! We chose gyro 🥙 & Philly!!! We almost ate the entire pizza before we got back to the cabin!!! They were so nice and stayed late for us ! We had no idea they closed @ 8. Aleah was very helpful & sweet!!!! 10 out of 10!They have inside & outside seating ! Something on the menu for everyone!I just want to add everything on this pizza was FRESH !! Hard to find ! Thank you

Jetlover X

2018-05

When you go to this place and stand in front of it you may think that this can't be it. Then you walk in and think again you may be wrong. But when you taste the pizza you know you are in heaven or at least at the right spot! The pizzas are truly amazing, they taste delicious and their crust is a bit thicker but really good. The staff is reserved (no big chatting) but very polite and friendly. The pizzas served are not the usual ones (you can build them if you want) but they have some own creations which are fantastic like the GYRO or the CHICKEN RANCH. Seating is for aproximately 15 persons inside plus 15 outside. This place is highly recommended!

Julie Moe

2023-12

Stopped in for lunch and we each ordered a personal pan pizza. This was by far the best pizza I have ever had. That crust is perfectly cooked and hand made with quality ingredients for the toppings. I had the ponderosa and it had just the right kick of flavors. The personal pan is quite big but I ate it all just because it was that good. Highly Recommend!!!!

Tim Jackson

2023-05

Amazing place, if you enjoy pizza you will love what they have to offer. They are super nice, their building is super clean and lovely, and their prices are great for what they serve. Definitely a must visit if you are in town, you won't regret it.

Nancy Suelflow

2024-04

…More

Willis

2023-07

Pizza was soggy and limp and had very little cheese.All the photos on reviews are very misleading compared to what we were served.Crust was so thin and soggy we had to eat the pizza with a fork.

Cheflily O

2023-05

We just randomly stopped without doing research just so we could feed our four hungry wolves, and so glad we did! The pizza was excellent; it was super duper clean and cozy, and everyone was very friendly. I'm gluten free, and it was the best gluten free pizza I've had. Kiddos had a regular cheese pizza, and it was also kid and husband approved, very cheesy 👌 Pictured is the gluten free pizza.

Sho Shimote

2023-12

…More

Victoria Rickart

2023-05

Delicious, great service, and clean! Indoor and outdoor seating available. This was the best food we had in Custer. I would definitely recommend and go back. YUM!

Chiminea

2023-05

The owner was incredibly rude when I said the pizza was burnt and asked to have another made. Her excuse was because I was an hour late picking it up.Then said it’s made in a brick oven and wasn’t going to make another. After saying previous orders weren’t charred top and bottom, the response she gave was, “ I’ll go ahead and refund your money and we’ll part ways.”Seriously? Part ways? It was a pizza, not a date gone bad!Very very rude.

Ashley Wheeler

2023-05

This place was AMAZING. Their pizza is phenomenal. My family and I will definitely be back. You will not be sorry about this being your lunch or dinner option!🍕

Aimee Anderson

2024-03

…More

Eric Forsberg

2020-05

We had a great pizza. Honey on the table to go with the delicious crust. The pizza was delivered faster than I expected, but was not undercooked. It’s a small establishment, so if you have a large group considering ordering out. Great service! We will definitely go back next time we are in town.

Kyle Veatch

2022-05

Came here for dinner while visiting from out of town. The pizza was great, some of the best pizza I have had anywhere. The inside is a little small, but it looks great inside, they have a soda fountain, and they take tap to pay.

Melody Ford

2021-05

We camped at Custer State Park this week and decided to try this place out. It was incredibly delicious! The staff is so nice and our food was ready in about fifteen minutes. The crust is soft and flavorful and the ingredients are crisp and fresh. We can’t wait to go back!

She Gathers

2022-05

We were out of town from Portland visiting Mt Rushmore and happened to be driving by Pizza Mill on the way back to our campsite. Wow were we ever pleased! Incredible pizza you guys, and it is *Kosher* friendly. We ordered the Chicken Bacon Ranch without the bacon and I don’t know what magic they put in the sauce, possibly pesto or something, but it was amazing. We have never had such amazing pizza and (Darci, per the receipt) was incredibly friendly and patient w us as we were trying to figure it all out!

Jasmine B

2021-05

Seriously good pizza! We were in Custer for 5 days and this was one of our favorite restaurants that we stopped at! We got a brisket pizza, a Philly pizza & cheese bread - all three were great!

Eric

2023-10

Some of the best pizza we've ever had, and we're from New York!

Tammy McDonald

2018-05

I'm going by votes from my fellow Yelpers on pizza tonight, don't let me down!Ok, thank you fellow Yelpers!We ordered our pizzas for take out, even though this is one of only a few restaurants open on Sunday evening, we wanted to relax at the hotel. After ordering we walked to Dakotamart for a few items then returned to Pizza Mill. We had to fix our bike rake before getting our pizza and as we were the young woman (late teens!?) from inside bright out the pizza and wings!Then we asked for napkins, plates and forks which she obliged by getting for us.Parking is limited and tables inside even more so, only 5 tables! They do have some seating outside but like I said we took it to the hotel.Now for the food! We ordered a 12 inch with various meats. What can I say but delicious! The crust was good but could have been fantastic if it had cheese in it (after all it's think enough). We also ordered 8 wings. They simply come fried, to golden perfection I might add, and you get sauces to go with it. I got the bbg which had a delicious, smokey flavor.Overall they had a very friendly staff person, sorry I didn't get her name, and delicious food. Be sure to stop here if you're in the mood for some yummy pizza and wings!