Carbon and Steel Sporting Goods

4.8 (209)

4375 W Market St, York, PA 17408
(717) 792-4667
carbonandsteelsporting.com

Claimed
Gun shop

From the business

  • Identifies as veteran-owned

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

David

2024-04

I stop here at least once a week. Between the consignment shelf in the back, the great prices, and friendly staff it's always worth a trip. I put a gun on consignment recently and they advised me to list it even higher than I was thinking because they knew their clientele and market. It sold within two weeks and took care of everything. Great shop and knowledgeable staff.

Scott Kling

2024-02

Great staff that is easy to work with. Consigned my gun here and it couldn't have been easier. They took the time to research prices and talk me through the current market to help me set the right price. I'd definitely recommend C&S to anyone who wants to buy or sell a gun with people who are professional, knowledgeable and respectful!

Dave Redshaw

2024-04

Very knowledgeable owner & his minions. Unfortunately, Rebel is no longer with us. If all dogs go to Heaven, Rebel is leading the parade.I love the cheap tables & shelves of used and/or consignment stuff. Always something I could use.

Brittany Reider

2024-03

Wonderful experience as soon as you walk in the door. Plus, there’s a dog! That was literally the best part, the dog!! I was in and out and well under an hour! So overall, I had a wonderful first time experience purchasing everything I purchased.

Allen Braun

2024-02

Went there to get my RMR taking off and new battery put in (screws needed heated and separated from plate) while they were extremely busy. Instead of making me come all the way back they fixed it up and told me no charge. Amazing staff and selection. Ended up buying some self defense ammo.. would 100% come back

Kean Quinton

2024-01

There picking up an order and the staff immediately helpful, pleasant and fun tbh. It was such a relaxed atmosphere that is indicative of their staff.

Matty B.

2023-12

New to the area and after purchasing one gun here I decided to return for a second.Me: I'm looking for a shotgun, pump action with the safety uptop.Big guy: What's it for?Me: Home defense. I'm looking for something for my wife. She's not too into shooting, but it'll be in the house in the event it's needed.Big guy: "can I give you some advice??"Me: sure"You wouldn't buy dancing shoes for your wife if she didn't want dancing lessons would you??Me: ..well once it's purchased, it's already in the house.-Big guy: Can I give you some advice??....sure"You should bring her in and have her test what she likes holding"Me: she is NOT into shooting. My plan is to bring it home and say you have a no return policy and we're stuck with it. I'll deal with the repercussions. I want a shotgun because there is no mistaking that noise and it 100% puts the fear of God into people without needing to aim.Big guy: Can I give you some advice....."For home defense you want an AR-15. Pretend I'm an intruder (points gun fingers at me) Go ahead and make your shotgun noise"At this point I'm just astounded instead of assisting me he would rather criticize my choice.Me: Ok sir, I am sure you get people in here that need or seek advice, and an AR-15 is your personal perference for home defense. I know what I'm looking for. I'm retired Army, Ranger Battalion, ran with Special Forces, sniper, been there and got t-shirts. I just want a shotgun. I'm not going to teach my wife to grab one of my M4s, ensure she's familiar with EOtech, AND make sure she grabs hearing protection before she starts shooting up the place.-Big guy loses his mind and wants to show me his PP is bigger than mine: "WELL I WAS LAW ENFORCEMENT FOR 30 YEARS AND AN EMT! M4 IS THE weapon of choice for home defense!! Let me ask you something SIR!? Have you been deployed?!"Me: what?!Big guy: "Did you wear hearing protection in combat?!"I wanted to lose my mind, instead, they lost my business.

Amrit Johal

2023-11

Keith and the team here are exceptional; Very knowledgeable, patient and personable. Highly recommended!

Mad Matt

2023-05

Stopped in today because I was in the area. Decent looking building.. selection was nice.. but the guys at the sales counter put it all together.. really nice conversation. Attentive. Even with the phone ringing.. I had a really nice interaction with the sales staff.. they explained their used gun consignment process. I ended up buying a revolver and a pump 22 rifle. Ill be back again!

mike cusimano

2024-04

Great group of guys! Helpful and very knowledgeable

Micah Roth

2024-01

Bruce was great to work with. Very funny and knowledgeable.

Keith Whittaker

2023-12

Great customer service and staff is very knowledgeable.

J B

2023-05

I do all my transfers here. Their prices are solid and the employees are always good for conversation and information. Pretty knowledgeable and capable staff. Much better experience than you would get at a big box store like bass pro. Would say the retail space is on the smaller side though. They keep a good stock of the popular conceal carry pistols and hunting rifles/shotguns and some ar/ar parts but if you’re looking for a particular gun you probably will have to order it. Ammo selection is also not huge they have the common calibers but stock usually doesn’t last long. Better than the past few years though

Patrick Bresnan

2023-05

Bought a used Draco NAK9 from carbon and steel (fire arms operates beautifully and was surprisingly clean and in really good shape) I got a sling and was at the range when the read sling bracket broke off, I brought it back in to get looked at and they fixed it for free! Definitely recommend!

Eric Kissinger

2022-05

First impression was great. Was greeted immediately when I walked in. I had a few questions on consignment products along with archery questions. And they were both answered without me thinking I was bothering them. I really like the place and will be my new favorite gun store. Pictures to come soon.

Matthew Rosario

2020-05

I only recently started coming back here after the change in ownership and could not be happier with the place. The owner and the staff are all very friendly and knowledgeable people. They have a solid selection of guns and the ammo stock is picking up. The store dog is the absolute sweetest. I'm happy to support a local business and will continue to look here first before ordering online. Prices range from low to middle of the road, definitely nothing overpriced here. Also, as a young person I'm happy to say the older staff are not rude or dismissive as they are in MANY other stores like this. Please stop in and check them out, we don't have enough local shops like this anymore!

Skunkworx Fabrication

2022-05

Best prices on new and used!! The state took over an HOUR to complete our backgrounds and these guys were so much fun, we didn't mind at all... Pet the dog, she's super nice.

Matthew Mahone

2018-05

Very skilled and they communicate well!! The Bow-Tech Dallas, Craig, and the other employees. Great customer service and very affordable. They took the time and got my Bow tuned in really good! I am a very Happy customer. If I have any issues or questions Carbon and Steel Sporting Goods is where I am going.

Darren Lawrence

2021-05

Great staff very knowledgeable. Did a ffl transfer process was very easy

John O

2020-05

BEST GUN SHOP AROUND! Very friendly knowledgeable staff. I personally would not even look elsewhere for a better price on a firearm. Very reasonable prices. If your a dog lover, stop in and see Rebel, he's a good boy and asset to the shop. Thanks Carbon Steel.

James Douglas

2023-05

Shopped around a bit and found Carbon and steal. Great little shop with awesome staff. The firearm I wanted was 100 bucks cheaper at carbon and steal than the other to gunshops I went too.

Steven Johnson

2018-05

These guys are real, honest and quite knowledgeable of the product they sell. Craig has treated me very well in the transactions I have had there. Dallas is quite helpful with the archery items, actually he just ordered me a new PSE, which they are the only dealer locally that carries them. Thumbs up to the whole crew there.

Cody Cosgrove

2017-05

This is definitely the best gun shop around my area. Great selection, great prices and most of all great guys working there. Really couldn't ask for a nicer group of people to help with your firearm needs. They also give the most fair prices on trades out of the shops iv ever been at. Would highly recommend this shop to anyone who loves Firearms and sporting goods. Words do not justify this shop, go check these guys out for yourself you won't be disappointed!

scott smith

2023-05

Excellent prices, excellent staff. All members were very friendly and helpful. The only dealer I’ll give my business to in this area.

D

2023-05

Fantastic firearm and repair shop ! Fishing equipment too.New and used firearms, optics, fishing, permits etc. You also may use their consignment shop to sell your stuff.Everyone in this shop can advise and suggest what may be best for you.Four- five guys are always there :-). It’s nice, you kinda get to know them.I think there may be one other time I’ve given my thoughts about a ‘place’ when I’ve had so many positive things to say.Simply great place.I’m not getting a discount or anything for this !! :-(. Lol. I should though…lol

Joanne Day

2023-05

Had a great first time experience! The older gentleman was kind and had me laughing! Simple in an out process! I got what I wanted!!

Matt Norris

2021-05

Handguns are in extraordinarily high demand these days, and yet Carbon and Steel had exactly what I was looking for and gave me a great deal on it! They didn’t jack up the price even though they certainly could have. Craig took the time to show me the tricks to taking it down and the lubrication points. Dallas was helpful and friendly with the paperwork and transaction. C&S certainly earned my repeat business. They earned my highest recommendation.

Melissa Laramy

2021-05

It feels like walking into a hunting camp. Everyone standing around talking about guns, hunting. I feel completely comfortable instantly. The know their business. Craig is very knowledgeable (once again, thank you for your service Sir) Carbon and Steel will have all our future business hands down. Love this place and Rebel makes it perfect!

Milford Zeiders

2021-05

First visit to this sporting goods store. Staffed with knowledgeable and friendly salesmen. Gun inventory is low as a result of the rioting all over our country. Very willing to answer questions and spend time with me. Invited me to stop by anytime. Wish they had what I was looking for. Even though I didn't buy anything, it was a pleasant experience.

Greg Teufel

2021-05

Message about reloading powder, told to call when they are open (message was sent after hours, didn't expect a reply until they were open anyways). Called to ask about reloading powder when they were open and informed that "I have too many customers in front of me how about you just stop in?". Well given the business hours that is hard to do. If I knew you had what I want I would have made the time. Instead I will find another local gun store to use. In today's business world most customers call or shop you online before going to the store. Not good business guys.

Opening Hours

Monday Closed
Tuesday 9 AM-6 PM
Wednesday 9 AM-6 PM
Thursday 9 AM-6 PM
Friday 9 AM-6 PM
Saturday 9 AM-2 PM
Sunday Closed

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet