Old Barn Creamery

Robert Bartholomew

2024-05

…More

j s

2023-12

Love getting their ice cream, it may be more expensive than store bought--but I'm okay paying for quality! I enjoy their soft pretzels and I just tried a breakfast wrap this morning, it was amazing. It's so nice having a store like this out in our area :) My family also enjoys their baked goods and the pop corn and seasoned pretzels they sell. Keep up the good work Old Barn!

Maurielle C

2023-07

Lovely shop with many homemade goodies! From ice cream, to soda, soft drinks, baked goods, etc., you are bound to find something! The employee that served us was pleasant and helpful. Ice cream is rich and flavorful! Very enjoyable experience and a nice picnic bench outside for a peaceful summer day. Would recommend if you’re near the area or passing by!

Travis Jones

2024-04

…More

Steve Spencer

2024-01

…More

James Slaton

2024-04

…More

Judy Keller

2023-08

Good ice cream here. Tucked in the countryside of Lancaster County. Hand dipped ice cream 🍨 Baked Goods on Friday and Saturday. Open at 6 am until dusk

Jillian Preniczky

2024-04

…More

Ms Wiss

2023-05

They are currently open M-F 9 -Dusk and Saturdays 8:30 am - 6 pm, Closed on Sundays (google doesn't give the option of "DUSK"). It is an Amish family owned and operated business, so their hours may fluctuate. They take baked good and ice cream orders for holidays and special occasions. Everything is delicious at Old Barn Creamery & Bakery! They just started making French Rhubarb pie-- it is amazing! I highly recommend stopping in and supporting this local business! Clean & friendly operation!

John LeFevre

2023-07

Ice Cream tasted good but quantity was a joke. $7.10 for two single scoops and they weren’t even as big as a kiddie scoop elsewhere. Will Definitely NOT go back. Not worth the drive or effort. Pine View Dairy puts them to shame for serving portion size! Would give them less than one star if l could!! Feel ripped off and am ashamed I even paid for it!!

Gary Thorne Sr.

2023-05

Absolutely charming store! A wonderful variety of delicious homemade baked goods, ice cream, and other dairy delights that Lancaster County is known for. And their prices are very reasonable too! By the way, their Whole Wheat Bread is the best! It's made with organic whole wheat flour, and has no preservatives. It's my favorite bread!

Melissa Mutzabaugh

2024-04

It's nice to have a close neighborhood place to go get a icecream cone. They have the most awesome soft pretzels too !! 👍

Brandi Shearer

2023-06

I was dog & horse sitting for my friend who lives in Holtwood PA & was looking for some ice cream when this came up on google maps. The ice cream was very good & I saw people leaving with strawberry pie. I went back today to get one & got the last one. Had a piece when I got back to the house. IT WAS DELICIOUS!! It will not go to waste. I also got some homemade chocolate chip cookies & can't wait to taste them too. If you are in the area you need to check out this store.

Sean Jennings

2023-05

Excellent experience! Staff was very friendly. I purchased a milkshake for my son, which he said was delicious. I purchased popcorn along with a homemade root beer which were both great. Looking forward to coming back again!

Christine Seel

2023-07

Very clean, fresh ice cream and reasonable prices. Beautiful setting looking over the valley as we savored our treats. Friendly service too!

Cindy M.

2023-10

Good ice cream. Some unique flavors. Recommend coffee chip and salted caramel together.

no one

2023-12

…More

john p

2023-05

Newly opened Amish owned creamery/bakery. Rich creamy ice cream, milk products, and delicious homemade pies, cookies, whoopie pies, etc.Delicious, all of it!

Wendy M

2023-05

Great workers and great milk and ice cream! Awesome bake goods!! Small business support them!!

Sean Willison

2023-06

Great ice cream and other treats. It's all local from there own farm.

Kathleen M

2023-05

The ice cream tastes AMAZING! This place is very clean. The staff are helpful and polite!

Eric Fisher

2023-10

Awesome breakfast sandwiches! I stop anytime I drive by, and sometimes make a detour.

Steven B.

2023-05

Great fresh products at reasonable prices.Staff is very friendly and the Creamery is spotlessly clean. Recommended.

Paula Webb

2023-08

Excellent milkshakes. Their ice cream is delicious

D Yoder

2023-08

Absolutely delicious ice cream and whoopie pies!

Joyce Wood

2023-06

Their iced coffee and iced cinnamon rolls are wonderful!

Fannie Ruth King

2023-10

Great place to get milk and yogurt.

Kristan Kanyuch

2023-10

The ice cream was heavenly!

Rennie Mccoll

2023-11

Great local ice cream

Jim Walko

2023-11

Amazing breakfast wraps!!