Cillo Antiques & Coins

Aimee Cosimano

2023-12

Excellent business! Was in from out of town, walking the dogs downtown, window shopping and discovered Cillos had my DREAM vintage aluminum tree in the window! Saw it after normal business hours, went in the next day and pricing was fair and we got a great deal on this beauty. We’ll love her for many, many years to come and can’t wait to come back to Williamsport to do further business here! Thanks again!

saige kaczkurkin

2024-04

the guy that works there is so nice and knows a lot about the stuff at his store and he’s always so nice to the people i bring in and even says there welcome anytime and would have stayed open late for me,it’s a beautiful store and has so many interesting things in it! very nice place and very nice and very nice people

Antonino Melia

2023-05

Love this store! Whenever I’m in Williamsport I always stop in to check what’s New in the store. Awesome selection of jewelry and one of a kind pieces! The owner was super helpful with me, as I wanted to see a bunch of different items in his cases etc. I never leave without buying something.

Kris Bergren

2023-12

Great deals as always. I’ve bought a few items here over the years, and keep coming back. Stopped in this weekend, and couldn’t be happier with the experience. Negotiated a fair price for a very high quality, mid century modern piece. I also appreciated the secured entry door. Keep up the good work!

M G

2023-10

We showed up today during business hours--open sign lit up. The sign on the door said back in 20, which was fine.The owner/employee/co-op person said he just put the sign up, but said he'd be longer than 20 minutes. Again, no problem.The guy then stops my wife and I asking, "What do you want?". We tell him we wanted to browse. He kind of chuckled and walked off. We were so turned off from the interaction that we grabbed lunch nearby and just left.From the other reviews, it's obvious that this is the typical experience. The place looked decent from the outside, but the guy and his behavior seemed shady. It certainly didn't seem like the usual antique store experience.Before the seller starts making excuses about people browsing, it's hard to decide if I want to buy something without even seeing what you have.All in all, this place is probably not worth any effort, unless you just happen to be standing right in front of it when the open sign actually means open and you already know which items from their inventory you wish to buy without actually seeing anything.

Autumn Ayers

2024-01

I bought my first treasures from Gov at Cillo’s at the old location back when I was in high school. I always try to come back when I visit home because I’m always pleasantly surprised by what I find! So thrilled that Gov’s son, Dave, is keeping the family tradition alive and happy to continue to support them as a loved part of my home town. Keep up the good work, Dave!

Mike Dewitt

2024-02

I was given a fair price for my old coins, they have some unique articles for sale too. Another great business in Williamsport. Keep up the great work Kyle

Michael Keller

2023-11

Old pawn definitely is a class act! Kyle is an extremely knowledgeable and is constantly striving to grow and develop his entire self. Truly an outstanding individual and an asset to his community,friends, family and definitely doing his friend and predecessor proud. This kid is going places for sure.I am always looking forward to my next experience. I truly appreciate .you#customer4life

Josh Messier

2023-12

Great spot. Period. So many unique and specialty items!! Old things, new things, and things that we never saw before!! My daughter and I were in there far longer than first anticipated!! The owner was very knowledgeable and happy to answer any of our thousand questions!! We will definitely be back to see what's new...

Jorge Jefferds

2023-05

It was never open at three o'clock on this Saturday we came to Williamsport for fun and do some shopping. The store is nice outside. That's why I gave it a star. Also, I heard that the owner died. However, it doesn't mean that the new owners have to leave for 20 minutes as a sign said and never returned.

P.J.S.

2023-10

I stopped in to inquire about selling some broken silver jewelry and was met by Dave who provided excellent customer service. He was polite and courteous, and he took the time to answer all of my questions in detail. I will definitely be recommending Cillo's Antiques to family and friends in the future, even if it's just to stop in to take a look around at all the beautiful merchandise they have in the store.

Morgan Motter

2023-09

I went in with my niece and son and my son wanted a little bat and he gave it to him for free. And then we went to go up and pay for my nieces DVD and he gave it to us. He was very nice and I was very appreciative. He has a lot of nice stuff in his store. I would recommend 10/100! Thank you very much!

Ja'Shon Y

2024-05

Great shop cool stuff. Nice owner

Simon Chan

2023-09

I went there yesterday to look for antiques. The guy rang the security door and asked us what we wanted. Hey, is this an antique store? He then reluctantly opened the door. I asked the owner to show me a coin. He rudely told me to handle the coin properly. He angrily tossed the coin to the floor and snarled at me. Be ware of this racist/psychic ! I ran out the store quickly; I did not want to be shot ! Don't go there ! It is a dangerous place. We were there to look for antiques, not to steal !!! The store owner is mentally ill !!!!! Don't play with your life for shopping there. No wonder the comments are so negative. It was a very bad and sick experience.

Anna Sholtis

2023-07

Came in to sell some of my jewelry and coins. I was hoping to get more out of them, but it was better than what I would’ve gotten trying to sell them on my own. Very interesting little store. The guy was friendly and knowledgeable about what my items were actually worth. I’ll definitely be coming back to see about selling some more of my things!

Anson

2024-04

Pleasure to deal with and negotiate with. Cash buyer for gold coins. Easy transaction.

P. Lutz

2024-02

Wide variety of antiques and coins. You never know what treasures you will find here!Friendly and knowledgeable staff.

Moriah Vige

2024-04

Owner was very helpful, honest, & pleasant. A big variety of different things!

jess Reese

2023-11

We sold a ring here and We liked how honest and upfront the guy was that helped us. He explained why we got what we did. We also scored some power tools! Win for a win!

Michelle Loner

2023-11

I have dealt with them on several occasions and they are always friendly but more importantly have always given me a fair price when buying my scrap gold.

Ciara

2024-04

Very friendly, wide selection of items! (if you want vintage vinyls, this is the place for you!)

Summer Bukeavich

2024-01

Had a pleasant experience selling some old gold and silver here! Fair price in return.

Tim Horning

2023-10

Good guy! He always gives my kids free things and is there with good deals. I trust his judgment on buying and selling. 5 stars!

Rachel Weisz

2024-04

Great products and service! Truly a seller you can trust.

Christine Cowne

2024-04

Very polite, very honest 100% satisfied. Highly recommended

TK

2023-11

Always stop by whenever I get into town. Great place to browse. Has been a family business for generations.

Nikki Smith

2024-02

Great place to stop in and browse!! Very friendly and good prices.

Tammy Pugh

2023-11

I went to cillos, and got just what i was asking for for my merchandise. Owner was very charming. Will go back.

Lori Keeler

2023-05

great experience at the store when looking for 'a sixpence or two to give for luck at a recent wedding (you know, something old, new, borrowed, blue... and a sixpence for your shoe)... although none were segregated I enjoyed the search from a coin box where I came out with several coins at a price that couldn't be beat!!!!I am anxious to get back to the store when I have more time to peruse all the items there... such a wide array of items, pretty sure you never know what you can find!!thanks for giving me reign over the coin box... the bride and groom were touched with the tradition gift!! Thanks & hope to be back again soon!!

Becky

2023-05

The young guy now running this place is ridiculously rude and arrogant. When we asked him for prices he said he had to "think about it" then just looked it up online for prices. Then he acted like it was an inconvenience when we wanted to purchase something. We gave him another chance and went back a 2nd time and had the same experience with him...won't be back.