Brother's Pizza

Marco

2024-04

Awesome service and really good food. Nice , peaceful, no frills atmosphere. Not just pizza either, they serve breakfast on the weekends and it's on of my favs and very reasonably priced. Def good hangover food 😁. Def give it a tryKid-friendliness: Very family oriented environment. I usually go for breakfast on the weekends and there are usually several families with kids and people of all ages.

Bradley Sprecher

2024-02

This is the best pizza place in Waynesboro pa. Food is always fast and tastes great. The workers are very friendly and accommodating. Never had a bad meal from here only two downsides always busy and they do not do coupons anymore in the mail .Parking: Big parking lot but fills up quick. In a strip mall

Michael J. Metzger

2022-05

Consistently good is the phrase that I would use to describe Brothers Pizza of Waynesboro. I take my wife here on lunch dates and I take my kids here when we want to hang out and have a good lunch. The food is always good no matter what you order, the restaurant is always clean and the service is always friendly and fast and that is hard to find in a restaurant that you frequent every time you go. Thanks Brothers for being consistently good its a bigger complement than you know.

Josh Bennett

2024-04

I have eaten at every Brothers around Greencadtle Newville ...and now Waynesboro. I have gotten a sub from greencadtle and newville and it has come with ur basic usual toppings lettuce onions tomato and u can add or take off toppings I call Waynesboro location and pick up my sub and get home and it's only meat and cheese only. I call back and the guy says that's the way he does it and if u want toppings u have to tell them....what in the world. I would assume one Brothers location to be like the others and had no clue the Waynesboro location only offers meats and cheese and u must pay per topping...for lettuce? What the hell $10 and up a sub...awful

Jennifer Deffenbaugh

2024-04

…More

Connor M

2023-05

What a wonderful Pizza shop in the Heart Pennsylvania. After a Visit at the Nerby Antique mall me and my Friends Decided to have a quick stop. We originally thought it would be a generic pizza restaurant but instead it was better then expected. The Staff was wonderful and Pizza was amazing. If you are Looking for a Pizza for a Good Price Brother Pizza is the place for you.

Dr. Stephen Bui

2023-12

…More

Tanner Matthews

2022-05

Good NY style pizza. Prices are appropriate for the area. Specials throughout the week. $1 tacos on Tuesday. The nachos are huge and well worth the price. They also serve breakfast during the week which isn’t very common in the area.

Charles Delzer

2024-01

…More

Dan Hallinan

2024-02

…More

Tracey McCoy

2020-05

Country ham had absolutely no flavor. Toast was texas toast. We have ate multiple times at this restaurant first time food was subpar

Janel Burgan

2023-05

Brothers is the bomb-dot-com! Amazing food, especially BREAKFAST (who would've guessed?), and TACO TUESDAY!!! Sometimes it is difficult to find a booth or table (it is seat yourself) but the waitstaff are wonderful. They are always on the move, attentive, and after a visit or two, they know you and your drink order like you're a regular 😉

Juli Foley

2023-09

…More

Bill R

2023-05

Simple local restaurant with great food and service. Menu is surprisingly large with a nice selection of Italian and American foods. Salads are great as are the subs, sandwiches, pizza, calzone, and Stromboli. Excellent breakfasts, unfortunately only available on Friday, Saturday, and Sunday. Atmosphere is fair but the great food and service easily make up for it.

Richard Long

2024-04

…More

Darcia Welsh

2023-07

…More

Queen Bee

2024-02

…More

A. Burkhead

2023-05

…More

Melissa Wetzel

2023-11

…More

Shannon Allen

2022-05

Not a bad place to eat but is a bit on the pricey side depending on food you order and can take up to 45mins for delivery and a 50/50 chance on getting warm food. Subs aren't bad here nor is the salads. For a slice of pizza isn't terrible for a new york style pizza. It's could use better quality for price asking but isn't to bad.Features: you won't be judged based upon your desire to wear your mask nor being valued as a customer.

Robert Gay

2023-05

…More

Linda Zerkle

2023-05

…More

D P

2022-05

This is one of my favorite restaurants in Waynesboro. The food is delicious and portions are very generous. The staff are always friendly and efficient. They have the very best gyros in town, and pretty much that I've ever had. I definitely recommend.

Elizabeth Mora

2023-06

…More

Debbie Ketterman

2019-05

The abundance of food on each plate makes the price well worth the visit. Servers are friendly and very attentive to your every need. Clean and cozy atmosphere. Would highly recommend. I haven't tried their breakfast yet, but I have heard on good authority that it is very good.

Jennifer Diaz

2023-08

So after all these years they still havent changed. Gave them another chance and now i regret it. The pizza was not what i ordered but of course the gurl heard me wrong. I called and they refuse to make it right. I ate the pizza and it is horrible and dry. NEVER IN MY LIFE. I DON'T LIKE PIZZA HUT BUT THEY WOULD BE BETTER THAN THIS!One of my all time favorite restaurants to eat at, well order take out. Hands down everything I've ate from there is amazing.Well it use to be. The people running it are nice till you have a complaint about not getting what you ordered. Never will I go back there. Good pizza and food but not enough for me to want to order their food and deal with horrible management.

Nigle Fones

2023-05

Haven't been to Brothers in a while, we had a party of five for breakfast. Food took over 40 minutes to arrive at our table, semi cold, asked for more coffee creamer, never received it. Sausage patties tasted like those microwave frozen patties. I ordered the crazy Tracy breakfast entree which states sausage gravy, there was no sausage in the gravy!!!!! Waitress never checked back we needed more Orange juice and attention to our meals. Over priced, bad quality of food and not so good service. We won't be back, not one of us completed our meals. I miss the old Brothers 🤬

cutelilhellion Cutelilhellion

2020-05

I recently moved in the area. My experience with brothers pizza is far from 5 stars 🤨 so it’s one of the last places to try out in my new area. Actually my son insisted lol. I will say this place is wonderful!! I’ve been here many times now & the food is delicious. Not one bad experience!! We’ve eaten in & carried out & it’s all delicious. Tuesday is taco day. They have nice dinner specials & lots of options not just Italian. So if you’ve been to a Brothers & said never again, give this one a try. Friendly staff who welcome you in & fresh delicious food.

Triple D

2021-05

First time I ordered delivery and their cheesesteak sub was excellent. The bread tasted like it was made just hours prior to the delivery. Great flavor and just messy enough to let you know it was a well made sub. As of now, they have my attention and my business. Great job.

Mary Snyder

2024-03

…More