McCullough's Ice Cream Shop

Crysta Bonekovic

2023-07

The best!I love the pistachios ice cream.Chili dogs are amazing l.Did not like the texture of the chicken strips in the chicken basket- avoid those- they need better quality-I was disappointed with chicken & deep fried cauliflower…avoid!All the ice cream is awesome & some unique flavors to choose from. Here are some of my favoritesBanana coconutPistachioBirthday CakeMint chocolateGreat people work here!Love the one girl that works here she is so upbeat and always knows my husband will want a brownie sundae before he orders and she asks him first- love that personal touch

James Chase

2023-05

Delicious home made ice cream with unique flavors and great food. Service is always friendly and gets orders out in a timely manner.

Brenda Wiehagen

2023-05

Nice place to get ice cream but for food you better plan on a wait or call ahead.Ordered a chicken salad with fries.30min or so later no fries on the salad even though they were asked for 3-4 times when ordering. When I said something the girl was like no he only asked what was on it but I can put an order in. I already waited to long just for the salad didn't want to wait any longer.Then it was a weird semi breaded merinaded piece of chicken in a fry basket. Not sure if we will be back.

M H

2022-05

My family loves stopping in for a huge cone! I’ve never tried it, not being able to have dairy, but they all say it’s the best! Great selection of flavors…might take a long time for little ones to decide 😀

Amanda Rae

2020-05

Overall a great place to stop and get a quick bite to eat however tonight me and my boyfriend stopped and ended up paying for over $65 worth of food just to go home,a the way in Mercer, and find that the french fries were hardly cooked and we had no condiments whatsoever (no cheese on our sandwiches no ranch dressing no cocktail sauce to go with the shrimp basket or with any of the food and appetizers that we ordered)

Etta Miller

2022-05

1st visit to McCullough's Ice Cream. The servings are huge and delicious. Want to go back and try their food. It smelled great.

Judy Woods

2018-05

Don't order the Tiramisu flavor you only get vanilla they claimed when asked they only lightly flavored it but if it ever had any connection to coffee it's the cup of coffee they were sipping when they made it

T W

2018-05

Wish they would learn to how to do a true twist ice cream. I don’t care for a vanilla chocolate split! The whole meaning behind a twist is to get both flavors at once. This is a disappointment every trip

Kardel H

2023-05

Good pnut butter shakes, and SanderBrownDog loves their vanilla in a bowlYummy homemade scoops of butter pecan and black walnut ice cream for mama, vanilla in a bowl for a special girl Marmie.Can't beat McCulloughs!

Sherry Poole

2019-05

Food is great homemade hard scoop Ice cream in several flavors. Lactose free and sugar free flavors. Soft serve also available.

Mary Lynn

2023-05

Love their ice cream. Was passing by and stopped and got a small ice cream cone and got my dog a dish of ice cream for a treat.

Barb Dye

2018-05

Ordered food and ice cream to go. They were busy but wait time was reasonable and when we got it home it was all according to the way we ordered It! And it was good !

Kathy Dell

2021-05

The best homemade ice cream around I had teaberry and butter pecan and young people love hot cinnamon they also have sandwiches and hot food 😋😍👌

Maggie Prasky

2019-05

Everyone is pleasant. The hot food and the ice cream treats are always made your way. Everything tastes good!

Jim Milano

2021-05

Great ice cream. .horrible service. ...person who waited us not pleasant..made us seem like we were bothering her.

Lilith Krynesh

2021-05

I have been going here for years, my family is all over the area, and it is always amazing food and ice cream! I currently drive an hour just to get it whenever I can!

Jennifer Willey

2017-05

When I visit I always stop here during summer. Wonderful, real ice cream. Lots of flavor options.

Cindy Elledge

2021-05

I love this place! Good food, chili is good and love their ice cream. Look at the size of that cone 😊

Jessica Clark

2023-05

Great home town ice cream! So many flavors!

Dana Sohngen

2018-05

The ice cream is really good. Just not as many different flavors as they use to have.

Joel D. Alfonsi

2021-05

They have a great selection of different types of icecream. Yes, it was good...

Dan Miller

2019-05

Great ice cream and great service. Always the best!

don hefferman

2022-05

Ok... it wasn't bad... wasn't great... It is a place a would go back to... I had a steak hoagie and fries... it was all ok... good ... not bad...

Roger Weatherby

2020-05

Great food and service people are very friendly and the best ice cream it's addicting

Most Wanted Fine Art

2019-05

McCullough has the best ice cream and I appreciate their dedication to the local Lakeview residents! What a wonderful place!

Bobby McChesney

2020-05

The ice cream is great plus good food

Michael Mccracken

2021-05

Great ice cream and better food!

Matthew the Fisherman

2020-05

It is great there burgers are the best I have ever had and the ice cream is so good the best

j. anthony Bancroft

2019-05

Very fair prices. Food quality pretty decent, too. No credit/debit cards accepted. Always been satisfied here.

Just Me

2023-07

Ice cream was good, waiting area was filthy