Tony's Pizza

Mark S

2024-01

Was super excited to try this place again. Had it multiple times in high school and was always happy. What a mistake.Ordered a white pizza well done and a Sicilian pizza. Pizzas were done fast and the parking lot is easy to access.Got home less then 4 minutes later and the white pizza was less done than I would even expect ordering the pizza normally. Very floppy and the base was moist and still very white. My girlfriend described the pizza as “cardboard”. No garlic or cheese taste and the crust wasn’t crusty at all.The Sicilian was not thin crust as described and tasted of less quality than a frozen pizza from the store. The sauce has no flavor and reminds me of a store brand pasta sauce. I’m definitely guessing they freeze their dough before preparing because the crust was airy and dry with no flavor.Very disappointed and will not be returning. I do remember this place being great in the past but after returning I find there is no real appeal.Pricing seems like a big complaint from many but I wouldn’t mind paying that for quality pizza. I was super hungry and only ate 2 slices/cuts because I was so surprised by the lack of quality. Very saddening but I do not suggest this pizza to anyone shopping in this area.

Johnny Midnight

2022-05

Haven't been here forever. Very happy we stopped in. Absolutely huge Stromboli (pepperoni, peppers, onions, ricotta and mozzarella) 😋Personally, we should have ordered it well done. Preferred red onion, instead of white and stick pepperoni. Extremely reasonable.Happy Easter ✝️

Jes Hardt

2023-08

Loving these new(er) owners. I don't know why finding a good pizza place is so hard when you cross the PA boarder...We are very happy here! Just enjoyed a ginormous calzone. My son said his buffalo chicken pizza was the best ever...and the Caesar salad and garlic cheese bread were on point! So happy they deliver! Also find their food to be Much better than places that do not! Definitely check this place out if you haven't! Extra special thanks to the delivery man who went above and beyond apparently our ring isn't working and he actually found us on our back deck. A lot of places would have just left it on the front porch to get cold and leave us wondering why our food wasn't here. Super happy with this experience and our past few experiences. Thank you Tony's of Stockertown!

Matthew Weaver

2023-10

I ordered a grilled chicken salad that they over charged me a $11 for when menu states it's 10 but whatever and when I called for delivery I stated what I would like ECT and I also told them im literally a 3 min walk but couldnt leave that area bc of equipment so they said it be 15-20 but it took them 35 mins and they never gave me a fork bc i clearly stated that i was at my work area. And there excuse was we didn't know you needed that should already be an easy decision that someone at a park working would need a fork to eat a salad so when I called there worker gave me an issue and said we will bring one no apology sorry for the inconvenience nothing. Also with the food where do I start lettuce was all slimy the container that contained the dressing was leaking bc someone prob didn't put lid on right chicken was the worst it taste like I was eating paper best thing was the olives lol never ordering there again 🤢

Amy Dollak

2023-12

…More

Spencer Haywood

2024-02

…More

Mike B

2023-09

…More

John Matera

2022-05

looks like small "out of the way" pizza joint but the food will surprise you. The pizza is as good as any that I've had in rural Pennsylvania. The wings are larger than typical and very good. The antipasto salad was very good too. I would, in good conscience, give this place four stars, but since you get a large pizza, ten excellent wings and a two liter bottle of soda for $23 I'm upping it to 5 stars for value.

Joe

2022-05

Had high hopes for the pizza (slice) especially with the signs they have displayed in the store. The crust was good but you couldn't taste the sauce the slightest bit. Wasn't dry just didn't taste the sauce.

Ruben Montalvo Rivera

2023-10

…More

Wes Ianni

2023-05

Best ‘za in the area. Chewy crust that’s not too bready, savory sauce, good toppings. Classic foldable NY slice.

Walter J. Hutchins

2019-05

Worst tasting pizza I ever had. Celeste frozen pizza is better quality than this and at a much better price this is very overpriced. I had a large pizza with 3 toppings for $18 these people don't even know what Pizza is supposed to taste like, I knew it the minute I bought it in the door of my house and smelled it. The only good thing I could say about it is it was properly baked.

Joshua Young

2016-05

Small town place. Family run business. Slices are big and have a lot of cheese. I liked the pizza. Mozzarella sticks were very good. Marina sauce was also tasty. Prices are a little high.

Chris Burch

2023-05

Had not been here for a few years but stopped last week for a quick bite, pizza was still very good.

Loretta Killian

2018-05

Got delivery in half an hour, 3 large pizzas on time and piping hot!! Very pleasant delivery man. Very nice, clean family run business. We usually eat in their restaurant but we were busy cleaning at home and opted for delivery.

Kevin Nicolello

2023-05

One slice. I just found it annoying that the cheese fell off, taste wasn’t that great and the Diet Coke was room temperature l. Not really the worst I’ve had though.

John Steenland

2021-05

Originally left this review in 2016..My goto for pizza, and mozzarella sticks.. they make their own sauce/marinara, and it shows, and the crust tastes like pretzels kind of.. they know when I call exactly what im going to get every time! Love them!Update9/10/2020 With all the bad in 2020, Tony's pizza in stockertown is good!They are still my go to for pizza/mozz sticks!They are super consistent with everything..

neida morales

2023-06

…More

Lisel Hutchins

2019-05

Overpriced and terrible tasteToppings sparce...I've never seen sausage sliced thin like this. Looked like a small slice of eggplant. 1 slice of green pepper and 1 slice of onion on each slice. $2.25 per topping. Lady glared at me when I gasped at the price$18.00 I will not return

Tommy McGuido

2018-05

If you want pizza it is great. If you want a sub or calzone or anything with lunchmeat don't waste your money. They put almost no meat on anything. And for the price they charge they should have meat and cheese falling out of them. Cheap. Don't let them trick yah n stick with the pizza.

Cindy Larsen

2021-05

Quick delivery and food was excellent. We had Garlic cheese steak and bread was so fresh and steak tender and flavorful. Pizza was fantastic!

James Jandris

2021-05

First off ill start by saying if ypur a garlic lover you will enjoy the garlic knots 10-10. Same goes to the pizza as well 10-10 I defend recommend!

Keri Ramunni

2021-05

Great food. Very affordable. Very quick delivery. The new owners have stepped this place up alot. Entrees are fantastic.

Michael VanderWyden

2017-05

The pizza is great and has its own unique taste, while if your really craving a filling quick bite there subs will fill you up without leaving a dent in your wallet.

Michael Pasquarelli

2022-05

Food is awful since new owners took over. Chicken Parm dinner, the chicken was chewy, and sauce tasted like Ragu.

Alexander Steinberg

2019-05

Love the pies. Nice and thin. Its been years since Ive had a pie as good as thiers.Ive had no problems with timing...haste makes waste.

Nate Jones

2020-05

Hoagie was on point exactly what I was looking for when I enjoyed my lunch there this afternoon nice people and also had their pizza which was good and that from me speaks volumes as I usually only will admit to me enjoying 1 other local place which I'm fairly biased usually I only try to go to the other spot 👍

brandon Buford

2018-05

The right pizza. I need to try more, but these mom and pop shops are the real deal. Good cheese that isn't so oily that you wear the pizza, and everything stays on the slice.

Brandon Best

2021-05

Delivery time wasn't bad. Pizza is really good. Orders come hot and fresh.

Karen Persson

2021-05

Fantastic good. Best pizza around. Great owners.