Rutter's #45

Ice Man

2024-05

Friendly people clean parking lotFood is hot and fresh 💪😁

G D

2024-01

Even the Rutters Employees cannot park in a parking space. There is a no parking sign behind the grown over trees. Trucks with trailers park here alot...I've seen delivery trucks..Utility trucks.Notice the yellow arrows...the truck is parked on the one.

Danica Grove

2021-06

If you want burnt food then this is the place to go. How they wouldn't realize it was burnt I don't know. This place does have an up side though. Plenty of gas pump and the cashiers are very nice. I wish the food service was up to the rest of the standards.

Brandy LeBlanc

2021-06

Always a good experience. Employees are wearing a smile, even during our usual late night Rutters runs. Brandon is normally our cashier and he’s great! The pandemic didn’t change our good experience even a bit.

Amanda Nelson

2024-04

I stop at this one occasionally, the Fawn Grove location is my favorite! However staff is always friendly and helpful at this location as well.

Paul Choe

2022-06

5 stars for them staff not management. Overnight team especially jack and Ursula are phenomenal. Being a 5x a week customer i have never had problems with the food or service. Wish they got some help though... I saw 11 orders come in at once and one person having to deal with that along with cleaning and stocking is way too much. Not including rude drunk customers parading inside the store and there's no security. Really shows how the company considers profits over employees.

Jill Miller

2018-06

Just stopped on my way north. Clean, bright, I like their food quality better than other chain gas stations, and I just had the best personal pizza! Exactly right to order, fluffy, crunchy crust, so yummy. All worth it.

Jane Doe

2021-06

So to begin with. I consistently hear snarky comments from the one older lady who works first shift behind the retail desk. I personally feel she needs a refresher on customer service. Because her attitude alone makes me not want to come back to this specific location. My second complaint is to the deli. By no means should there ever only be one employee in the deli area alone during lunch rush. Which has a happened on numerous occasions at store 45. I feel as though management should be calling and asking for other employees to come into work if there short people in the deli area. Rutters food and coffee is bomb, we need our suppliers fully staffed.

Lindsay Fundakowski Feldman

2021-06

Employees are not enforcing mask-wearing at all despite rampant corporate signage, serving folks without masks. When I stopped in to get some Motrin every employee had masks on properly, plastic screens were up at the kitchenette and cashier. Unfortunately clientele make this location a hard pass for me until post-COVID.

Robert Ward

2019-06

I live 4 houses down from here an 6 times out of 10 ten when the old man is working the carry out my order is wrong. Well tonight I got my order an took a bite an it is covered in hot peppers, I mean covered. Well I suffer from stomach ulcers an currently their bleeding an no I shouldn't be eating a diet like this but I didn't order anything that I wouldn't eat at home that would put me into any harm. But as I bit into my sub my mouth caught on fire an felt every inch go downy throat. An started vomiting, they fixed my order with no comment but it should of never been like that. What happens if I was allergic to something they put on it, oh oops sorry. So pissed off with this place tonight!!! Robert Ward

Maddie

2022-06

Provided my MD state ID and would not sell me vuse pods. She scanned my ID and looked at me weird then asked me my birthday. I was thrown off because no one really asked questions? She also asked “have you ever bought these here before?”, I said no bc im new to the area. What do I need to bring my birth certificate?

Justin Martin

2020-06

Absolutely fantastic a great experience instead of giving Sheetz more money for worse food. Ordered the rib basket and it came done just right very tender and unbelievable that gas station can actually produce this quality meal.

Peter Steinberg

2017-06

I've always liked Rutter's; it's a great local chain. I told a co-worker a few weeks ago, "I've been to the Rutter's in Fawn Grove a couple of times and it's amazing." He told me "You know what's even more impressive? The super Rutter's in Stewartstown.""I've driven past there several times and it doesn't look that impressive to me.""No, dude! It's the real deal!""If you say so."So then I was driving into Stewartstown after coming off I-83 at Shrewsbury last week. I decided that I was going to stop by Rutter's just to get gas. So I pull into Rutter's and there are a TON of gas pumps. The gas canopy wraps almost the entire way around the store.So I fill up my tank and then I say "You know what? I'm gonna go into the store for a soda and maybe a bite to eat." Now, there are a number of billboards across south-central PA advertising Rutter's burgers and fries. There's one right below a McDonald's sign on I-83 northbound just south of York. I saw that billboard and I said "Come on! Rutter's can't possibly have better burgers and fries than McDonald's."But then I enter the store of this Rutter's in Stewartstown and there's an assembly of order screens arranged in a circle. Not only are the screens and ordering process much more dynamic and in-depth than those of competing convenience stores like Wawa and Royal Farms, but the selection of food appears to be more expansive as well. It was at that moment that I realized that Rutter's is indeed a very serious competitor with Sheetz, Turkey Hill, Royal Farms, Wawa, et cetera.I like getting quesadillas from Wawa so I decided to try out a Rutter's quesadilla. Then I chose a side of french fries just to mix things up. There's an option to make your order a combo by selecting a fountain beverage, and I was going to get a soda anyway, so I selected my soda size and then indicated that my order was complete. A few minutes later my order was ready and it was given to me in a very nice brown paper bag with handles. The cashier told me to have a nice day and that was the cherry on top.I still think Wawa's quesadillas are better, but this one was acceptable. The fries were much, much better than those from every major fast-food chain. I now feel ready to try a Rutter's burger because I now trust their assertion that Rutter's is worth going to for burgers and fries instead of McDonald's and Burger King. Rutter's slogan is "Why Go Anywhere Else?" and given their overwhelming food and drink selection at the "super Rutter's" in Stewartstown, that slogan is absolutely true.

Azzy Rhea

2024-03

Good ranch And fire pickles🔥🥒 fire

Ben Burch

2022-06

Rude management. Bad employee working conditions!! No breaks allowed!! Miserable employee experience.

GameZGaming HIIMX3 (HIIMX)

2018-06

Everything is good so far except the Qeusadilla. To much cheese. There should be an option to change the amount.

Chris Bigham

2017-06

My breakfast sandwich wasn't too bad. They have bathrooms for the public.

Jackie Boyd

2022-06

Yummy fresh made Breakfast burrito made to my specific menu

E Smith

2021-06

Good service, but the mask requirement is not well enforced.

Nicholas Beerbower

2021-06

Very convenient and sells some good beer

Deb Winemiller

2023-06

Convenient and friendly

Terri “Maiden name, Christopher” Miller

2022-06

Excellent employees

Leo Renze

2016-06

it is a yummy store