Costa's Super Market Inc.

Aaron Peterson (apariesram35)

2022-05

Posting a few things that I like about Costas Supermarket 👌 They have Amish Made Noodles ❤️ Fish fry Friday ❤️ Love the soup mixes to give me Ideas on betting my own diet ❤️ Very friendly and knowledgeable employees 👍 And of course the produce Isles are legit 👌 Deli Subs and Pizza are So Delicious but I myself can't eat very much Gluten 😕 Everything always looks delicious in the Deli Cases & I highly recommend the Fish Fry on Fridays 😁

greg macer

2021-05

Stop here for lunch most days I’m out in Smethport for work. Fast good food (lots of fried stuff), as well as a deli with some banging sub action. They have catered for our work events and have been very reasonably priced which is also very banging. And they have also been wonderful for the community in general!

Brian Bailey

2024-02

They started carrying a really, really awesome and affordable brand called That's Smart.I'm very pleased with my interactions.

Francis Auriemmo (Auriemmo)

2024-03

Great place to shop nice selection of meats all the time

Dave Rich

2024-03

Girls working there were a great help with the photo machine!

Natalie Goff

2024-05

Very friendly people. The subs were great

Gloria R

2023-05

My 85 year old mother was in shopping yesterday. The check out girl was on her cell phone and stood there picking her nails while my mom had to load her own groceries. What happened to customer service? Someone who didn't even work for the store took her groceries out to her car and unloaded them. I hope her next visit is better.

Sister Shaker

2022-05

Their meat bonanzas are great deals, clean store, friendly staff, overall good experience every time. Big plus is they have "bag boys" who take your groceries to your car and load it for you. Very nice young men.

Melissa Austin

2023-10

Love there meat specials! Really good prices on most stuff

Walter Bazella

2023-07

It's a very nice store. Prices are higher, like all small town grocery stores.

Michele Kreckel

2022-05

As with any small town privately owned store I've had both good and bad experiences. They have a fairly decent selection. Products can tend to be over priced in comparison to say Walmart. Save a lot or aaldis. However your also paying for the convenience of not having to drive any distance.Their meats aren't priced badly.Today i looked at fruit to purchase. My mother loves grapes. Almost $4 a pound, 3 bags with more than a few spoiled in them. Needless to say, I didnt purchase any.On a plus note, the Philly steak and cheese pizza I purchased was awsome! Thank you deli workers!

Sandy McGarvey

2019-05

Fantastic, have been going there as a kid with my parents, even when we went to their house on main Street. The stores are great and the service people have been all so polite. My dad Alvin Walker and Margaret went to school in Conrad.

Robert Lane

2022-05

Prices are a little high, I paid $15 for 3 small pre made Salisbury steaks and mashed potatoes, that frankly weren't very good at all. Was going to buy a small jar of hellmans mayonnaise but they wanted $9 for a small jar, so I decided to purchase the same jar at dollar general for $3.95 just like small cans of V-8 juice, they want $6 for a six pack and I buy it at dollar general for $3.95 a six pack. You can tell its the only grocery store in town by their price gouging prices

Jordan Vangorder

2023-09

Great grocery store, there are a lot of verity of thing you may find.

Rachel Esch

2023-07

They have delicious subs and the bakery makes maple walnut cookies that are to die for!!!

Jason Sawh

2018-05

Costas is well stocked for a little supermarket, they carry a bit of everything and the prices are decent. Their deli food is also very good and in my opinion they have one of the better fish fry dinners around. Their wings and subs are also very good. Lots of parking, quiet atmosphere and friendly staff makes this a worthwhile stop for me anytime I am in Smethport.

Shawn Mitchell

2023-08

Little pricey but to be expected. Being a small town store cashiers very friendly store was clean

Joe Hinchey

2023-08

Clean and well stocked. Friendly staff but a bit expensive.

Kurt Covert

2020-05

It's an ok store if you need something quick. If I need more than 2 or 3 items, it actually saves me money to drive the 20 miles to Bradford to get those items. As for the deli in the back....no thank you.

brandi rounsville

2022-05

Well prices are horrid and took a hike, not a gradual one either, per example, 12 doughnuts used to cost $ 4.00 before the pandemic, then all a sudden during the first few months of the 2020 pandemic, they went to $8.99, bread $1.50 to $2.89, then handful of the staff are down right ignorant (not knowing)

Jodi Walker

2022-05

Love the store and very nice people but really need some good help in the deli in the evenings have not had good experience with take out in the deli

Shane Locke

2018-05

Great little small town grocery store. Some complain the prices are higher than big department stores. The prices can be higher but that is to be expected with a little local grocery store that is convenient to get to in a minute in town. It's a nice place to have around.

Patricia A Rapp

2019-05

Enjoy shopping at this store! Nice selection of products, good bakery items, excellent meat section and nice deli with fresh made foods. Staff is very friendly 😁

E Siekierka

2023-09

Our Smethport store of choice. Great prices, friendly atmosphere and employees

Laurie Nelson

2018-05

Ok. Most employees were very helpful. However, one young man seems very put out both times I asked for assistance. Trust me, I won't ask again. I don't live here and am not familiar with the store, my apologies for disturbing you.

Cynthia Wilkinson

2020-05

This was the cutest little grocery store. And they had absolutely everything that we needed. It was so clean & organized too. We won't forget this little store when we visit this area again.

Joshua Bell

2023-06

Everything is jacked up in price, better off spending a little extra gas and go somewhere els.

Dale Shackleford

2022-05

Good place. Not great. But good. The old school "out of touch" owner (paul costa)needs to retire so this place can finally flourish. Lot of potential just waiting to break free.

Jenna June

2020-05

Nice locally owned grocery store with a good selection of items for a small town. Wish it wasn't going to be closed soon so a monster Sheetz can take over.

tina howard

2023-05

Always friendly assistants when needed clean place to shop meat bonanza is great for our community