Saylorsburg pizza

Amy Richardson-McBride

2023-08

…More

Gregory Pastir

2024-04

Two times in a row now. My pizza has come to me with all the cheese slid off of it. That's strike too. But I'm going to count it as strike three. I'm over it 50 bucks for food and you get it like this.

Dieann63

2024-01

The pizza here has been awesome ♡ I used to not care for the pizza here, I think they lightened up on the seasoning on the cheese pie ♡ Now it's very delicious!!We get pizza here about 2xs a month!

Stan

2023-11

This place has good food. Unfortunately it seems to be one of these businesses that just don't give a hell, and will do whatever they want, when they want, regardless of posted hours. Which makes them super unreliable, and you never know what you're gonna get after a 30, 40, 50 minute drive over to them. I've shown up numerous times well before their official closing time, only to either find the doors locked and lights off, or the entire staff still inside, but the doors will be locked anyway. This past Sat, I showed up at 8:30pm, when their online hours say they're open to 9pm. Entire staff is still inside, but doors are locked. I knocked, guy comes to the door and tells me they're closing (everything was already cleaned up, which means they started closing WELL before 8:30pm, more like 8pm or earlier, at least a full hour before official closing). I ask him what time someone needs to show up to get food, he says "what does it say on the door?", I look and it says "8:30ish PM". I look at my clock, it's 8:33 PM. I have no words...It's a SATURDAY! If your hours are till 9pm, then you start closing at, or after, 9pm. NOT an hour before. After years of eating at this place, their service standards have slipped, little by little. Some of us don't want to eat dinner at 6-7pm, and I don't want to get hot food only for it to sit hours before I'm ready to eat. I'm sooo disappointed, I really liked this place. Where have the standards gone?

Manny Muniz

2024-02

…More

Adam Frederick

2023-10

What can I say, decent pizza when you can get it. Open till 8? They Stop taking orders at 7pm! Trying for to place an order on a random Tuesday? The phone just rings and rings. More than half the time the pizza is cold when it gets to me despite being less than 3 miles from the store. I dunno, I guess they never stole my account number so they got that going for them. Literally the last resort.

Tara McManus

2023-05

Great pizza and they deliver.One thing I dont like is they changed to a cheap boiled ham on their italian subs. So won't get that anymore but the pizza is the best around.

Cheryl Shook

2023-12

…More

Guy Braden

2023-07

…More

Chris Pearce

2023-08

New to the area , moving and stopped in for a quick meal, went in the first night thought it might be a fluke cause they were busy , the calamari was straight outta the frozen food section at a super market , soggy , rubbery , the marinara still had the plastic wrap that you would get from a pre packaged sauce cup on it and it was ripped off sitting inside the sauce , they definitely just microwaved it , second night i ordered a giant garlic knot chicken parm sandwich which I was so enthusiastic about, it came to my table and looked awesome in the middle of the sandwich it was ice cold another microwaved disaster! Not to mention the staff does nothing but argue and fight amongst each other out loud and in front of the customers , BTW when I told them my sandwich was cold they looked at me like it was my fault ,and they still charged me without hesitation , could have had a repeat customer but I will never eat there again I feel grossed out right now , I recommend staying far away from here they only get business cause they are the only thing around it seems ! Ps. Whatever is in that sauce taste weird af and leaves a horrendous taste in your mouth !

Michael Biel III

2023-05

…More

Michael Crumpler

2023-07

…More

Allison Slater

2023-05

We have been regulars for the last year and a half. All around awesome and we are so grateful to have this restaurant in our town. Great pizza place. Delivery always works out great, they have great employees.

Jessica Riley

2023-05

I Picked dinner up for my family on my way home from work one Monday night… pizza, wings and a soda. Super reasonable price! As far as pizza and wings go… it was perfect and delicious! Also extremely helpful and friendly staff. We got dinner here tonight and again was perfect. (other pizza joints in the area are just insanely over priced and have below average food) We found our new pizza spot SAYLORSBURG PIZZA 🍕👍🏻

Patricia Nemeth

2023-05

Our fave pizza place here in Poconos!These folks hustle to present & produce a tasty, substantial product like the double crusted cheesesteak stuffed pizza topped with olive oil and garlic. Add a salad or some veggies and it’s a whole meal.Then bonus: add a dozen or two of the sweet & spicy wings. Just a hot bite or 2, open up the senses and enjoy all they have to offer here in the village.

George Smith

2023-11

…More

Johanna Jorgensen

2023-06

…More

Kathleen Slattery

2023-07

…More

Vincent Barbato Sr.

2023-05

The best local pizza place ever. Fast, friendly, thorough service, and several delicious choices. Stop in to try a warmed up slice and you'll be back often. Huge bottle and can drink selections too. I'm so glad a friend took me there and I really think the place deserves the five star rating.

Richard Van Vliet

2024-03

…More

Zendarius Kincaid

2023-05

I went to this establishment one day on my way to a friends and I was totally blown away with how good the pizza was, it was thin, crispy and light, it was so good that I stopped by on the way back for another slice. The second slice was what I feared and I saw the other pizzas they had out and it was all thick and oily, when I took a bite it felt like I had a mouth full of dough.

Eddie Calle

2023-09

…More

Susan Glasser

2023-06

…More

Robert Murray

2022-05

…More

David Diaz

2020-05

The pizza was tasty, fresh, & hot. The pizza wasn't greasy, the crust had the snap real pizza has, and just enough crunch when bitten.Standard Italian food condiments were readily available, as were napkins. The fountain sodas were crisp & cold. The dining room was clean, and the service was friendly. I'll definitely eat here again whilst I'm in town & when I return.

Melissa Santiago

2022-05

We were out of town looking for a place to stop and eat before the trip home. Great decision stopping here. Friendly employees and delicious pizza and garlic knots. I will make the 2 hour trip just to come back for pizza sometime!

William Erb

2023-11

…More

Ed Smith

2023-05

Easy to order, pickup and pay with Google pay. I wish the crust was crisper as, away from the edge, the pie was quite doughy. They have coolers with a great selection of beers and malts beverages.

Robert Lamb

2023-05

Definitely recommend getting food here. Our order wasn't quite right and they immediately rectified the issue and sent us out new food. Great customer service. We will definitely be back

Mark Esbensen

2021-05

This was our first visit to Saylorsburg pizza and it won't be our last..... My wife & I are pretty picky about the way we like our Pizza and Saylorsburg Pizza knocked it out of the park on the first try...... That's never heard of getting it perfect the first visit....We also had the Bacon Cheese Fries and they were outstanding also!!!Let me tell you, Saylorsburg Pizza doesn't Skimp on the Cheese & Bacon either...... I don't want to forget the Sausage Roll we had on the side. I was actually surprised at how damn good It was.....Outstanding Food and it was piping hot too...... You can't ask for it to go any better for carryout.....