Ice Cream Cottage

4.5 (169)

21413 PA-198, Saegertown, PA 16433
(814) 783-0288
facebook.com

Claimed
Ice cream shop

Service options

  • Takeout

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

Jonathan Southwick

2024-05

Stopped here in the midst of a 42 mile open road mountain bike ride. This was my first time here. Plenty of outside seating which I enjoyed. I got a mocha shake which was just a tad bit runny and the price was a bit high. I'd like to come back sometime and try their hot food.Parking: I rode in on my mountain bike but there was a lot of space for customers to find a place to park.

Valerie Lynn

2024-04

I LOVE that they open early, so I can get My Boba 😁🙂Parking: Lots of parking, except when they get really busy!Kid-friendliness: What kid doesn't like ice cream or Boba?!Wheelchair accessibility: Lots of parking, but can't get up to the window to order, so you'll have to ask them to come out to you, to take and deliver your order!

Heidi Ho

2024-04

…More

The Dj DiZaster

2024-05

…More

Dave “Dj DiZaster” Hagmaier Jr

2024-05

…More

Valerie Lynn

2024-05

Wonderful place to get my boba and inspired me to make my own creations 😉🔥 Parking: You just need to get there when they aren't crazy busy!Kid-friendliness: What kid doesn't like ice cream?!🍦🍨Wheelchair accessibility: The window for orders is out of reach to those in wheelchairs, but calling your order in ahead is always helpful, too 😁! Perhaps a ramp can be built in to the current structure?!

Taylor Johnson

2023-11

Their homemade ranch is fire! Glad we stopped in! Owner was very friendly and helpful in explaining their menu items! Many choices to choose from. Good portions for the price!

L Chuma

2023-10

I really wanted to love this place because it is close to my house, but sadly I went away disappointed. The peanut butter cup in my flurry was quite possibly the waxiest, worst tasting ever! Reese's PBC for real if you want repeat business. We ordered a banana split ...no 🍓...was it in error, or were they out. I don't know. However, the fries were hot, fresh, and delicious!

Mike Hiltabidel

2020-05

Way overpriced. Paid six dollars for a Greek burger which is fine but it did not come with sauce as the menu clearly states. When I brought it up that I just got a hamburger basically ,which is only 3 dollars, they said it's a Greek seasoning. Whatever that is. So I then stated that you are legitimately charging people 3 extra dollars for a sprinkle of seasoning. And I also ordered a kids cheeseburger which came out as a hamburger. My wife got a pulled pork with not even half the meat to fill the bun. Paid around 32 dollars for all this and really only got 10 dollars worth of food. Not to mention the time before this misadventure we ordered food and they forgot to make it. Waited over an hour. Never going back again. Tried to give it a second chance and it was by far one of the worst experiences I ever had. And I've been a cook for many many years. Ive seen a lot.

Michael Charlton

2023-08

ICE CREAM COTTAGE IS BACK! This is what summer tastes like!!! Kids of all ages love it! 😛🍦🍦🍦

Ken Ingraham

2024-05

…More

Jamie D'Amico

2023-11

…More

Lora Phillips

2023-08

Terrible. New owners son flipped off me and my family. We were sitting at the picnic tables and he drove by and flipped us off. When I asked about it... the girls said that was the owners son and didn't even apologize. Nor did the new owners.....wow new owners must mean new terrible service. 😕

Frank Marzano

2023-08

So glad this place reopened! Food is great (and the portions are huge). Employees are efficient and friendly.

René Benoit

2020-05

I had no idea that they sold so much more than just ice cream here. I had a rainbow sprinkle twist for a good price, but I can't wait to come back and try the other food on the menu. Not many places in the area offer vegetarian options, but they have a veggie burger here that I look forward to trying. So many food options, can't wait to try it all out. There are nice picnic tables outside to eat in the shade.

Kayla Jaggi

2018-05

Awesome ice cream, & food is very good as well, I always love it when they open up in the Spring after the long winter, gives the customers something to look forward to, & keep it local. Great Job, love your ice cream after a long walk on the Woodcock dam.

Jodi Ann

2021-05

Lucky Charm TwisterCereal in icee cream? Yes please!!🙋‍♀️

Proud Pennsylvanian

2023-10

Ice cream is fine but it is definitely the most expensive ice cream place around.

Aaron Coldren

2019-05

The ice cream is good and so is the food. The food is a bit pricey but well worth it. I also don't mind spending a bit more to help a small business. Will continue to go back for the foreseeable future.

Fred Tritt

2015-05

About a minute after spending $14 on 4 ice cream cones I had to buy a 5th cone because my 7 year old didn't like the flavor he chose, I was charged an extra fee of 50 cents because I was paying with a bank card and this additional purchase was under $5. Then about half way thru her ice cream cone my wife found a chunk of thick paper about the size if a quarter inside her cone. Bringing this to the attention of the girl at the counter her response was "ok thanks, I'll look for that"- not concerned at all.We come to this area seasonally and this place used to be good, but their customer service tonight was seriously lacking.

Ivan Troyer

2021-05

Love this place. The hot food is good but I wouldn't say its anything outstanding, but their ice cream is amazing!!

Kyle Hall

2017-05

This is a great dairy isle to sit down for a meal. Excellent hot food options and tons of ice cream. It has a deck with multiple tables. The only thing missing is soft serve frozen yogurt.

Dustan D

2019-05

Had a twist cone was a small but was huge like 7 inches tall. Very good decent prices. Nice outdoor seating area.

Allison Jackson

2018-05

So many ice cream options! Very yummy! We go here every year while camping down the road and I always look forward to it.

Caroline Dobay

2019-05

I absolutely love the icecream and their hot food, in fact we are always anxious for the shop to open and sad when they close. O choose the Ice cream cottage iver DQ anytime. 😊💖💖😊

Cynthia Rhoads

2022-05

The food is always great and the ice cream is even better. Ice Cream Cottage has been a family favorite for more than 10 years!

Jesse Master

2022-05

Last year I went here in 2019 technically 2 years ago their prices were stupid high with very little to show but now I think they are under new management and now you pay little for high quantities are they are a amazing . Complete turn around I HIGHLY recommend this place now.

Bruce Keller

2022-05

We had a great experience there. Ice cream was fabulous and the servers were great as well

Denise Devore

2022-05

Plenty of outside dining area and parking. Good menu and prices. Thank you foe having a restroom available!

Garrett Mccool

2019-05

Ive always loved this place ever since I was a little kid. Its changed owners acpuple times in the last few years but its stayed relatively the same which is good!

Opening Hours

Monday 11 AM-8 PM
Tuesday Closed
Wednesday 11 AM-8 PM
Thursday 11 AM-8 PM
Friday 11 AM-8 PM
Saturday 11 AM-8 PM
Sunday 11 AM-8 PM

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet