Hostetler Country Market

Lynnette Walter

2024-05

My turkey bacon wrap was OH SO DELICIOUS! Worth the $7.?? I paid for it. The prices for grocery items are on the pricey side. But the deli foods are okay. Their fresh made foods a very good and not bad as far as the prices go. I've not tried the ice cream shop part of the store. But I'm sure it will be good also.

shannon berry

2023-09

One of the best soft pretzels! They have original and cinnamon sugar. They are huge and their prices are so fair! Lots of other great food choices too!

Shelly Damiano

2022-05

Small local country store that sells Reedsville milk in glass bottles. Deli counter. Makes fresh sandwiches. An outside table & chairs for enjoying your sandwich. Recently expanded and remodeled.

Taryn Daly

2023-12

Excellent assortment of fresh made bakery and deli items, and local goods. They’re made to order sandwiches are amazing!!

Brenda Adams

2023-11

Such a quaint little market. Stopped for lunch. Had a ham and cheese stuffed pretzel fresh out of the oven and pumpkin coffee. Lots of home baked goodies and snacks.

Ken Nowicki

2023-11

While this is not a very big store that have a nice little selection of food items. Did buy a few things there that I could not find in other stores in the area. Or some that the items were cheaper.

Terry Wenker

2023-05

Super great! Awesome home cooked meals and food and breakfast served all day! Very friendly and helpful staff as always. This place was recommended to me and I just had to stop for my brunch in the middle of my day. At that time I can't say enough about how good the food is. The quality and the service you get here for them for the money you spend great place to stop. If you're in the area, it won't waste your time. You'll be happy by my recommendations on food

Matthew Shaub

2023-05

Love this place! It's small but has a lot to offer. We ate here twice while visiting Mifflin County. Lunch food was delicious. Choose from sandwiches, salads, soups, even quesadillas. Hot dogs and cheeseburgers are available too. Portions are large and the price is right. Deli meats are available to go, and there is a small store inside that offers local bakery items as well as chips and snacks. Indoor and outdoor seating. Fresh ice cream served by a walk-up window inside and outside. Plenty of off-street parking, and a farmer's market is held here seasonally.

L West

2023-05

Thrilled to find a market that offers from-scratch cakes. Woman I spoke with was extremely helpful and accommodating in making suggestions for our gathering. So pleased to find a business like this with so many homemade items.

Steven Molek

2023-08

Fresh items all the time. They have a good little ice cream shop too. Definitely worth stopping by when looking for something to eat.

Jeremy Kerstetter

2022-05

Great place to stop and get a sandwich. Friendly service, good prices and several extras to choose from. First time here, it's nothing fancy but I would drive past Sheetz to get my sandwich here. Fresh cut lunch meat from the deli and good specials.

Sandra Sandy Myers McNeal

2024-04

Lots of goodies. Had pies, cakes, whoppie pies, salads, etc.

Kyle Haines

2023-06

Absolutely love this place. Great food! And most of their bottled drinks they sell are from PA local companies

Tanya Wilson

2021-05

On Friday, July 17, 2020 my husband & I, decided to have a morning breakfast together. I picked this place and we both ordered differently from the wide variety menu. Oh my goodness, was it EVER DELISH!!! Staff was great, clean store & top notch service. It’s definitely, our new favorite place to continue having our few times a month togetherness! P.S. we ate out on the picnic table !!!

R B

2023-05

The hoagie was huge and delicious. Definitely stopping back when I’m in the area.The chicken noodle soup was homemade and very flavorful.Friendly service, nice little store.

Kimberly Peachey

2021-05

A very nice place to get a delicious sandwich or wrap! Sarah's Crispy Wrap is my favorite!!! Nice friendly staff!! I would really recommend this store! Good atmosphere!!! They also sell hand dipped Penn State ice cream. And Reedsville Creamery ice cream and milk.

Melissa K

2020-05

Lovely little deli. Fresh deli meats and delicious sandwiches. They sell Reedsville Creamery milk, ice cream, cheese, fresh baked goods and other items. Nice little patio sets outside to enjoy the weather, while eating one of their delicious sandwiches!

Dane Collins

2019-05

Great place to get local products, Great Hoagies and Soup of the day! Always have a good selection of baked goods.

Amy Porter

2023-05

Good food...just be careful about being overcharged! Has happened to us several times and when you question it....then oh, I'm sorry and they correct it. So is the cashier keeping the difference of money??

Ken Nugent

2023-05

Great lunch deli, subs and soups. Chips, baked goods and salads. Priced right. Ice cream and coffee shop attached to the main deli.

Deanna Weyant

2023-05

Excellent food and friendly staff. The sandwiches are delicious and they don't skimp on the meat!

Ryan Reed

2022-05

Awesome small sandwich store. Plus local milk and baked goods. Great breakfast sandwiches. Polite friendly staff. When visiting Big Valley, I always stop here.

Debra Sedok

2022-05

It's a very nice place. Fresh made subs, wraps, breakfast sandwiches, and daily specials. The staff are all very courteous and friendly.

Don Anderson

2020-05

It's a nice little store. The sandwiches are very good. If you are ever in the area, it is a place you need to stop in at for breakfast or lunch.

Ivy Wagner

2023-05

We got sandwiches, they were absolutely delicious! I got a caramel iced latte, it was delicious as well.

Darren Kauffman

2020-05

Everything about this place is "Home." The food, the , the hospitality and service with a smile! Telling everyone I know about you guys! Everything is FRESH!!! It's so awesome that this store is around our area!

James Buchanan

2021-05

Nice little deli. It use to be run with white top Amish and I called it the Amish deli. The new owner remodeled it. They did a good job

R MP

2020-05

Great subs, sandwiches and soups. Lots of goodness packed into a small market. It's become a once a week (at least) stop for us.

Jean Berrier

2023-06

Fresh baked goodies, fresh sliced meat and cheese ,great little store, stop in

Mindy Lucas

2023-05

Awesome little market. Has subs, lunch meat and ice cream. What more could be better?