O'Donnell's Sports Supplies

Ben Cornibe

2024-04

Great selection of fishing tackle from rods and reels. Lots of good advice and tips what to use and when. Outfitted myself and boy with all new gear for trout season. Always stop in when in the area.

Bob

2024-05

Great bait selection, wonderful owners.

Jake Outdoors

2023-05

The staff is always friendly and helpful. It is a little bit out of the way for me but they have items I can't find anywhere else. This place is definitely worth visiting! If your passing the New Castle exit on 79 you can be at O'Donnell's in about 5 min.

Michael Sparks

2023-08

Very friendly staff, very helpful. Helped me pick out the right size minnows for my bucket. Great prices, n very good quality.

rowanda thystlemeijer

2023-07

A lot of fishing stuff. Hooks, line, bait, bobbers, minnows, tackle boxes, night crawlers, stringer line, rods, reels, hooks, nets, licenses, Sunscreen, bug spray, bows, arrows, some firearms, some targets. Just off Rt 422 on Rt 19 in Portersville PAMon closed, Tues 9:30-2:30, Wed, Thur, Fri 8-6, Sat 7-6, Sun 7-4

chad hair

2023-05

Hade the worst customer serviceShe was very rude n u could tell she didn't want be there n sure didn't help when I asked her a simple question about bulk orders for upcoming trout season stuff I can say I will never come back. Definitely go to steiners out door n more located in East Brady. There caring n helping something this lady hade none off

Wayne McCort

2019-05

Awesome place, not for the novice unless you just need bait, very warm people.

Michael J Strutt Sr.

2022-05

These places are sadly a dying breed.Awesome family owned sporting goods store.Reminds me of the stores I grew up with.Excellent selection of bait, fishing rods, lures and other equipment not to mention hunting supplies.Very cool store with a lot of different stuff.I'll definitely be back.

Garry Staph

2023-06

It's a great place for all your fishing needs, and the owner was very pleasant to talk to and deal with. I'll go back there again.

Cole

2023-07

Lots of good stuff. Everything you need for fishing is in there with great prices. I love the place.

Zack Shaeffer

2022-05

The older woman there was cool. Came from Grove City to get fathead minnows. They sell them by the baker's dozen for about $3 I believe. They seemed to have a ton of fishing stuff even though she's said their stock was low. Great business to support.

Preston Scott

2023-05

Just bought my new St Croix rod here best bait shop around fair pricing great selection of lures will be buying my fishing equipment from them from now on

Tiffany Smith (Tiff)

2023-07

Great little place! So glad we found this we can stop here on our way to camp and get fishing wormsand minnows!

Xtopher

2022-05

They have a nice selection of bait, lures, rods and reels. They even stayed open late to help my sister in law from Switerland get her tourist fishing license when the state website wasn't allowing her to do so. A+

Soulzrmine Beast

2023-05

Very nice people and great prices. One of the last bait stores around Moraine. Stop in and help out a local business

Michael Kent

2022-05

They are very friendly and have anything you need for your fishing trip and best place to get minnows or shinners and never disappoints you will tell you when there getting more in if there low and best night crawlers you can get big as hell

John Barton

2020-05

Great Bait and tackle shop that also carries a full line of hunting equipment. Family owned and operated. Not to many of these around anymore. Their bait is always well stocked and fresh.

Brian Thomas

2019-05

Very knowledgeable staff, and very helpful! Live bait, and not out of a machine either. Fair pricing, and everything fishing, hunting, tapping, and in between. Close to moraine (lake Arthur) which makes it very convenient for buying minnows

Dalton Freed

2023-07

I have been going here since I was a kid for at least 25 years now. The best place to get bait

Blaise Wheeler

2019-05

Great bait selection and services offered. They will respool a reel and they also offer a wide selection in lures and jigheads. Definitely the best bait shop in the surronding area. I will go out of my way just to stop here for bait.

Luigi Civitarese

2021-05

I was running late one time and they were about to close so I called and they stayed open an extra 15 minutes so we could grab bait (Which is always live and healthy). Greatly appreciated and an overall wonderful bait shop!

Christina Wirl

2023-05

Love the older gentleman. He is too cute. They have any and everything you'd need. A little more expensive BUT I'd rather support local.

kelly weber

2023-08

Very nice place. Great selection. Very nice people

Trevor Pennington

2023-05

Great place friendly people. Best bait shop around for lake arthur

Cody Gross

2023-08

Nice guy good prices what more can you ask for.

Jon Blanchard

2023-05

One of the better selections of st croix rods in the area and excellent customer service!!!!

Jayme Davis

2018-05

Been coming here for years! Always fresh lovely bait and good prices. Love small businesses with friendly educated staff!

J

2020-05

This spot has been my go to for hunting and fishing since my grandfather introduced me to him over 40 years ago. The place hasn't changed at all and it's a wealth of information.

David Beggs

2023-05

Best place around for ALL things fishing! Good selection and prices.

Rusty Barnes

2022-05

Do most of my fishing and hunting supply shopping at this little shop. Always support the little business and the staff here is friendly and knowledgeable as well.