PJ's Deli

4.3 (243)

1992 Valley Rd, Pomeroy, PA 19367
(610) 857-5728
orderpjsdeli.com

Claimed
Deli
Takeout Restaurant
Sandwich shop

Service options

  • Delivery

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

Kimberly Emel

2022-05

So we have been getting PJs for years but I have to say this is the second time I have been disappointed. We ordered three American hoagie salads and one steak in a box. All three salads had no meat at all!!! Just lettuce onion tomato and pickles! What a huge disappointment. That being said I am not sure we were even charged correctly because the order seemed inexpensive so who knows. But to top off the order the steak in a box had a stick in it!!!! What the heck!!!! Not sure how or why it got there but I have lost all confidence in their food. Food was ordered 10/19/21 at around 5pm. So not sure who was on duty but there may be a problem. Don’t know if I will go back. Took us 6+months to go back from our last bad experience with hoagies. Pictures are shown below. So I guess maybe check your orders before you leave??? Don’t know what the answer is.

Dea Mayange

2022-05

Didnt much care for the taste of the cheesesteaks. Pizza was not good at all; couldn’t eat it. It was dry, stale- seemed old, stiff cheese and crust. Definitely was burnt. Two stars because the fries were okay, and the bread for the cheesesteaks was soft.

Jason Gill

2023-07

I can't explain it. For all intents and purposes, most sandwich shops are identical... But I continue to return here. There's no place to sit and eat inside. But that's how I want it. Order, pay, and go.Attached is a very creepy Santa mannequin that stares at you when you wait for your food. BONUS - hidden behind that cheeky Claus is a photo of PJ's owner (I think) with pink hair.

Anita Gordon-Palmer

2024-02

…More

Phoenix Williams

2020-05

Fast delivery, don't think this sad breaded Chicken sandwich was worth $8. They charged $3 extra for bacon and extra for cheese and used this depressing little chicken patty. I also ordered mozzarella sticks which weren't too terrible but $5.25 for the mozzarella sticks. Plus the cost of delivery and tip. So no, this meal was not worth $20.

Angela Ward

2024-03

…More

Robert Parramore

2023-05

Hands down best Philly cheesesteak. The sweet sauce just adds to the deliciousness of their sandwich.

William Miller

2023-11

…More

Lisa Grubb

2023-05

(Jus moved to the immediate area )I have only one complaint ! I can't order more often because I am disabled I can't drive and they don't deliver. The cheese steak rolls are my grown son's favorites! (They go to Pjs for lunch when working in the area)They order as many as they can sometimes because they are always sold out. Last night I ordered a cheese steak stromboli with 2 orders of cheese steak rolls ...30 min bfor closing . Without hesitation they took our order and made it to perfection. The stromboli was my best ever in 30 yrs of living in pa . It had me wanting more . ...the quality A+ the quantity for the price A+ the professionalism of the person/people working A+. We will be return regulars !!!! If your local and your haven't tried Pjs cheese steak rolls or stromboli your missing out !

Connor Roche

2023-05

From out of town and stopped by for lunch during work. Talk about a great mom and pop shop! Food was great and so was the couple that served me!! I just wish it was closer to home!

J London

2021-05

I got wings from them and barely any sauce on them. After waiting 30 - 40 mins to receive 24 wings. Dont think I'll be returning to order any wings from them again.

Bill G

2022-05

Great place with a wide variety of subs, sandwiches, fried items and pizza. We had a few different sandwiches and they were all prepared exactly as ordered and great. The fries were great as well. Also had a nice selection of Herr’s chips and snacks along with bottled coca-cola products. We saw a few DoorDash drivers picking up food for delivery while there.

Ashley W.

2023-05

The food is always excellent but I'm giving them a 3 because the staff always appear miserable when we pick up food. There are no greetings or smiles, just glares, particularly from the older lady at the register.

Victoria Kefer

2022-05

Tonight was the first time in over 15 years since having food from PJs. We had subs, cheesesteaks and pizza from there all through the 1990s when we lived just a couple of miles away. I had to drive past today and had the whim to order something. It was so hard to wait until I got home to find out if they were still as good! I was not disappointed! The only small observation is that the meat to roll ratio was not quite as good. They used to be very stuffed, but this being 2021, costs are different, supply chains, overhead, etc. However, the flavor, the moisture (I do not like dry cheesesteaks,) the soft roll were all still great! Will always be my favorite cheesesteak!

Moto's Danger Zone!

2021-05

Used to have the best cheese steaks I ever had but once it burnt down and they rebuild nothing taste the same not sure about pizza but like almost all deli's they moved to cheaper product and quality definitely shows. I'd much rather return to their before fire ways and up prices for the best cheese steaks they used to have!

Claire Lang

2018-05

The food is delicious and the prices are reasonable. We go out of our way to order from here! Their pizza is exceptional. Their sauce tastes like my Italian grandmother made it. So good! I've tried many menu items and I've been impressed every single time. Family owned and operated. The time and care they put into every order shows!

Elizabeth Blevins

2023-05

The cheese steaks were good but the American sub didn't have any bologna or onions ,lettuce, tomatoes. It ha 3 pieces of meat the rest was cheese.

Dave the Author

2022-05

Never ordering here again. We ordered a Buffalo chicken cheesesteak and a regular cheesesteak with fried onions. And instead of those two separate items, we got a single Buffalo chicken cheesesteak with fried onions on it. But of course we were charged for both. Do yourself a favor and avoid this place.

Rosemary Cialini

2023-05

No matter how long l have been away from the area l make it a point to get my pjs cheesesteak when l’m back. It’s a little slice of nostalgia and the food is soooo delicious 😋

Ashley Weaver

2014-05

I go for the wings! They are tops! Those of you who order cheese steaks gotta tip for ya. Order your sweet sauce separately then your sandwich won't get soggy. You can't top the food and service is great and friendly staff. Will be going for lunch again soon!

David Pilz

2022-05

Food is priced well and most items are tasty. The only item I won't order again are the cheese steaks. Sandwiches are good and filling. Pizza is good, but can be a little under cooked. Staff is friendly.

pudgie amway

2023-05

I order a Lg pizza with extra cheese and pepperoni i got 5 pep n the pizza was so thin. dont waste your money for their pizza are frozen go to the dollar store n you can get a nice Digiulio pizza for 5 bucks

Walter Been III

2018-05

You get what you pay for and then some! This place is great! And with the remodeling after the first one burned down, they did a remarkable job with it! The staff are alright! You tell them what you want and they make it for you! Let's just put it that way! As much as the hospitality is so great in this place, I don't mind ordering my food when I get there and watching them as they make it! Highly recommend this place for anyone who loves a good hoagie or cheesesteak!

Frugal Sista'

2019-05

Busy with shopping, that's a great reason to order out any night. The wings and onion rings are my favorite. But they have great Cheesesteaks Hoagies and more. Also they have lunch special. If your getting a Cheesesteak don't forget their FAMOUS sweet sauce. Yum. It's the best.

Al Lamartine

2020-05

Friendly people. Went there with my uncle. He recommended the cheese steak or stromboli. I'm from Philly so of coarse I tried the cheese steak. It was neither good nor bad. It was just so so. My uncle got the stromboli and seemed to like it a lot. They forgot the fries but fortunately I always check my orders when picking up from a place so I don't have to drive back to a place two times to pick up one meal. Next time I visit and we eat there I will have to order a stromboli.

D W

2021-05

Not the PJs I remember! Sandwiches only had mayo on half of the roll. Very thin waterey tomato slices, severely lacking a proper amount of meat WAY too many onion's! It's a shame because this place used to be really good! Prices are good and the people were friendly but unfortunately I will not be going back unless they step it up!

Delores Hines

2020-05

The food is very tasty but the sanitation can use improvement. I've seen workers stand outside talk to people and go back inside and start serving food with out gloves or handwashing. Also, handling food and money are basic sanitation facts. Would like to see them improve in this area.

Mary Jane

2023-05

Bought a pizza steak with mushrooms. Terrible. Tablespoon of sauce, meat as dry as the dessert and it wasnt baked. Never again.EDIT...changing my 1 star review to 5. Decided to give them another try. I had cheesesteak and bought a turkey hoagie. Both were delicious. Steqk was heavy and full of meat. Hoagie was full also and had the extras I ordered bread was delicious.

Eric Williams

2019-05

Awesome! Easy 5 Stars. Had an Italian sub and an Italian wrap. The wrap was enormous! Great value. Good selection of Herr’s and soda. Very friendly service over the phone and in person. Love this place!

Michael Shoulson

2021-05

Thought I'd try PJ's again after a few years. My cheese steak was pretty flavorless and dry. More importantly is that nobody had a mask on (during covid19) and only the lady who rung me up was wearing gloves which is against state mandate. I didn't think about it until later. Hopefully they didn't infect my sandwich

Opening Hours

Monday Closed
Tuesday 11 AM-8 PM
Wednesday 11 AM-8 PM
Thursday 11 AM-8 PM
Friday 11 AM-9 PM
Saturday 11 AM-9 PM
Sunday 11 AM-7 PM

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet