Katie's Cookie Jar

Tracy Rudzinski

2024-03

I drove an hour away just for the amazing sugar cookies made here! Beautiful desserts, but the best part is the TASTE. Affordable, adorable desserts. Don't miss out on the sugar cookies!!!Wheelchair accessibility: No stairs- seems to me to be wheelchair accessible.

Jenna Aldom

2023-05

I order from Katie's Cookie Jar regularly. My family gets donuts almost every weekend. The pepperoni rolls are amazing, and they have regular plus a pepper jack one that is perfect if you want a little kick. She has made beautiful birthday cakes/cupcakes for my family that not only look amazing, but taste amazing! Everyone is always asking for more. The cookies are so unique and she is so talented as an artist and baker. You won't be disappointed!

Kelcie Christopher

2023-05

Get cookies for your party from here! Although the cupcakes were delicious, everyone raved over the cookies at my daughters first birthday. Not only were they adorable, everyone commented on how delicious the cookie tasted. They were such a hit, that I did not even get a chance to try one before everyone scooped them up.

A A Ron

2023-05

Great place for all your goodies. The shop was extremely clean and everything was in order. The lady that put my order together was super duper nice! My wife sent me with a list but wasn't specific on certain things so I had to text her to find out what exactly she wanted. Most people would probably get annoyed waiting on me to double check on what my wife wanted but this lady was Awesome. She never got upset and just kept carrying on a conversation even after we got my order figured out and paid for. She said the owners start baking as early as midnight for the following morning. About the only fresh donuts I've ever had. Also got a birthday cake from here and it was absolutely delicious! It's not too sweet and the decorating was perfect. They close a little early but if they are starting their day at midnight I don't blame them. You just have to plan your order.

Caraline Reinecker

2023-08

My favorite bakery!! Katie is so sweet along with her family. Her cakes are amazing and you can tell she put a lot of love into them!

Brittany Ober

2023-05

The best!!!! Ever since I was recommended to her in 2020, that’s the only place I will go. Her prices are very reasonable, and she does exactly what you want. It’s also very good!

Haylie Helinski

2022-05

Highly recommend! I ordered cut out cookies and a cake for my daughter’s first birthday and everything looked and tasted amazing! She responded quickly and was so easy to work with, I couldn’t be happier!

Kara Nahar

2023-08

We have used Katie’s Cookie Jar for many of our events and I wouldn’t want anyone else to make our cakes, they make a the whole event! ❤️

Brianna Kassouf

2024-02

…More

Dewane Shultz

2023-11

She did an amazing job on the cookies we ordered for a baby shower. They went above and beyond, also made the whole thing super simple. We got so many compliments on how beautiful and tasty they were.

Jodi Valdiserri

2022-05

When we made an appointment with them to order for our baby shower, they made a fresh batch of buttercream icing that we wanted to order and the buttercream icing is delicious. Great price. Cupcakes were decorated as we ordered. Highly recommend and will definitely order there again.

Lauren Snyder

2023-05

Absolutely beautiful cookies!! And the chocolate chip and peanut butter blossoms were so yummy!

Sarah McQuade

2023-05

HIGHLY recommend!! The best deserts and such pretty designs. We ordered buckeyes/cookies and cupcakes for our wedding and wow so delicious! Caitlyn recommend the perfect amount and let us pick up early!

MIKE SIANO

2020-05

Today was the Grand Opening of Katie’s Cookie Jar. We tried the buckeyes and chocolate chip cookies plus sampled the ladyfingers and all three were sooo good! We can’t wait to go back and try some different varieties of cookies and some freshly baked bread. Everyone was really nice. They also have tables to sit down and enjoy your cookies if you choose. I highly recommend this new business.

Katey Andaloro

2021-05

My favorite bakery!! They do everything, including dog birthday cupcakes, and can honestly say everything tastes Fantastic!!! (My pups devoured the cupcakes and I have a bad habit of devouring the sweets from here!) Can create any idea thrown at them, and at very reasonable prices! Can't say enough great things about this place!!!

Margo Rita

2024-04

…More

Keith Frankenfield

2024-03

…More

Cody Martin

2023-05

Katie’s Cookie Jar is a great hidden Gem in the little town of Perryopolis! Great doughnuts and cookie selection. Everything is fresh and homemade! A+

J W

2022-05

Thank you Katie’s cookie jar for making the cake and cookies for my mothers 60th birthday . They looked and tasted great as always! Everyone one was asking, we are sending them your way !

Marty Cummins

2023-05

She made a cake we told her what it was like and it was delicious. Everything she makes is great and my wife can’t wait till you open

deaths hand

2023-05

Absolutely beautiful cake! Once againthey knocked it out of the park. Our son was so excited he got a Charmander over pokeball colors

Bob Conti

2021-05

They made us customized cookies shaped and designed like red brick houses and keys for a house warming party; they turned out perfectly and very tasty. This place is a gem that we will return to.

Travis Leone

2021-05

They have the very best doughnuts. Also the pepperoni rolls are amazing! Highly recommend them for your baked good needs.

michelle horan

2021-05

Everything here is delicious but I called the last week of September to order a cake they told me they were booked until end of October???? Get some help maybe open more days ...month in advance just ridiculous

Linda Patterson

2023-05

Have the BEST BREAD AND BUNS I have ever had.

Timothy uhrin

2023-05

Best bakery around hands down

ed prinkey

2021-05

A definite must stop local bakery!

Victor Rosano

2022-05

Delicious doughnut’s and cookies

Betty Hawranko

2021-05

Love your cookies and donuts

Theresa Bradley

2021-05

excellent selection