Andy's Pizza

Keystone Reviews

2023-11

…More

Danielle & Jason Westgate

2024-05

…More

Ian Eiriksson

2024-04

Seat yourself service. Andys pizza is a good contender for the best pizza in america and i havent found anything close. The crust is delicious, the plain pizza is amazig, but my favorite is their spicy sweet pizza. Its absolutely divine. Worst part is how little parking there is, but most people park at the bank across the street. Bar has a good selection.

thatladiikt

2024-04

The place wasn’t even busy at all and we had to wait over an hour for four trays of pizza. The waitress didn’t even come to the table to mention any delays or check on us and after the long wait our order was incorrect so we had to wait for that too. Terrible customer service & extremely expensive. Definitely not worth going here anymore if it’s going to be like this from now on.

Tim Latsha

2024-03

…More

GRIENDRR

2024-01

…More

Ric Ravier

2021-05

Pizza along the Lackawanna Drainage is a little different. Cooper Cheese vs. Mozzarella on the pie? Whatever is going on, it is good, and historic.

Michael Uhler

2022-05

A must try. Beware - Andy’s is cheesy. You will notice on the menu, “don’t be shy,” meaning that you can request lite cheese, burnt cheese, etc. So order the way that you’d like.Also, CASH ONLY at the time of this review.Great place…the interior is a bit dated but in a way that makes you feel like they have something great and they are sticking to it.This is worth a try and I will be back to try their speciality pies.

Marc Fasiecki

2024-03

…More

Sherri Hoban

2024-04

…More

janice soltysiak

2024-04

…More

iLove2Travel

2023-05

We love Andy’s! Plain cheese cooked well done is our go-to order. If we’re not in town, we ship Andy’s to us to satisfy our cravings.

Stephen Greeley

2023-08

…More

Mary N

2024-01

…More

D K

2023-10

…More

Michelle Rowlands

2023-05

I love this pizza. It’s not a type of pizza you could have everyday & really is not anything like a regular pizza. I feel like people who may be disappointed are expecting a traditional style, which this is not. The dough is really get - but not typical pizza dough & the cheese is a blend of a few different types that give a creamy texture. It is not a stringy mozzarella type & really is better if eaten with a fork(assuming it’s still hot). Not great to have as leftovers the next day as it just doesn’t reheat the best. All that being said, I would highly recommend this to anyone. I would just be sure to clarify with them beforehand not to expect your typical type pizza

Lori Bodnar

2024-04

…More

Brooke Walters

2023-06

Slightly disappointed. I feel like they skimped out on the pepperoni. The pizza was also doughy.

Danielle

2023-09

first time ever having andy’s. we got a plain and a hot sausage/ sweet pepper! it was delicious! slightly disappointed with the plain, thought it lacked some cheese. tastes exactly like Angies used to ( with the original ordered) ! very tasty and very pleased would definitely recommend to anyone and will be back !!

Laurie McHale

2024-03

…More

Baba Booey

2023-05

…More

Michelle Collins

2023-08

…More

Liss

2022-05

Love it but i cant eat it anymore. Make a gluten free pizza taste just as good as ur cheese pizza and I'll buy it from u every week. Amazing other wise. Must have cash.

Gregory Arnone

2024-03

…More

Tammy Laughlin

2023-12

…More

Charlene Smith

2024-04

…More

Celine Belmore

2023-06

…More

richard evans

2023-05

…More

Anndrew Vacca

2023-05

…More

Beth Servas

2024-02

…More