Tyler's Custom Cuts

4.4 (45)

655 Big Spring Rd, Newville, PA 17241
(717) 860-8599
tylerscustomcutspa.com

Claimed
Meat wholesaler

Service options

  • No delivery

Accessibility

  • Wheelchair accessible entrance

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

Margarita Molodan

2024-04

I never thought I'd be writing a review for lamb! I honestly hate lamb normally, but my husband made a meal with the Halal Ground Lamb, and it was so so good. We bought it at Mediterranean Market in Mechanicsburg, and will definitely be trying out other Tyler's products. Thank you for making such a great product, and making it easily available to purchase in local stores as well :)

Sunil Prajapati

2022-05

Great place to get goat meat, chicken and beef. They cut it skin out or save the hair for goat and burn it if you want. Same with chicken. They got good selection of male and female goats. They process it real quick. It’s very clean and they are very professional at cutting the meat. One think you gotta be aware is don’t put turmeric or any color on the goat skin , coz some people can be allergic and for that reason they don’t cut it into pieces, ( I did that smh) prices are great and they take EBT. They also clean all the innards and give the internal organs. They have ice and a small grocery store for fresh produce. It’s in the middle of nowhere so download the map or directions ahead. Highly recommend for goat meat.

Ali Allawati

2024-03

Bought lamb today from here! Was so expensive, unfresh, no date, and smelled bad! Also steaks were double tje price. You think they are providing a service but seems they are taking advantage of the Muslim population!

Vivian Sterste

2023-12

Pennsylvania's finest female butcher works here! We saw her wield her knife, making masterful cuts, slicing and trimming in full view! Goat, lamb, beef, chicken, rabbit, all available. Halal butchering. Will go back, often!

Farhan Sadique

2022-05

Great service, halal fresh meat available here! People come from far away.Good management. I hate the smell, but it’s obvious!

T H

2023-11

I bought 35 pounds of beef, and unfortunately, all of it turned out to be subpar. While the meat appeared red and fresh, it seems the butcher sold me low-quality cuts, possibly from aged cows. No matter how long I cook them, they remain rubbery and nearly impossible to chew. This was my first time buying meat on my own, and it was a big mistake. Please be cautious and make sure to inform the butcher that you’re paying for fresh, quality meat, not tough, inedible portions from aged cows. I’m extremely disappointed.

Surovi Khan

2023-05

Let me start by saying that everybody that works here are very nice. Amazing customer service! The meat is very fresh, so are the eggs, milk, cheese and vegetables. Very happy to have found this place. Of course it’s about to become my regular!

Joshua Hobbs

2023-05

I shop here often mostly for pre cuts and produce from their grocery section but it’s a very busy place given their hours and people coming from everywhere. You will see bad reviews for them being rude or ignoring customers but it’s probably bc the people were working with other customers. Patience is required when looking for fresh slaughter. My DOG gives them 5 stars for her bones too. Prices are extremely reasonable at the best of times and with inflation I’d almost call it cheap.

Beth Demarco

2023-05

Extremely impressive. I needed bonz for 3 great pyrenees. Got eggs and various items maybe spent 40.00. I was treated with the same respect and professionalism as customers there spending hundreds of dollars. I will be returning.

ROBIN TAMSANG

2021-05

Good place to get farm to table. Beef, goat,chicken turkey.. good service, great price. Support your local farm and butcher.

Mark Heefner

2023-05

This place is awesome. They'll get you anything you need. Just ask, be patient, and kind. Don't mistake their focused work with rudeness. When it's your turn they treat you like family. I love getting meat from here. It's the best in central PA!

David Greifzu

2023-05

This place is kind of out of the way. A place in between Shippensburg and the newville Sheetz. I didn't order an entire animal, or anything like that. I was looking for a place to find some goat and lamb meat for somebody who misses that kind of thing, which you cannot find in any grocery store around here. They got a tiny little store, and they had what I was looking for. It appears to be a clean place, well organized, and the people there seem to be extremely friendly. If you are looking for meats that you cannot usually find anywhere else, this is the place you should look.

Rosca Nick

2022-05

It is one of the best Farm to buy beef and chicken all are fresh meat. Above all the people are very friendly. I will recommend anyone to buy meat from this farm. They’ve better price that you can’t find it anywhere.

p sam

2022-05

Today drove 60 miles to get a rooster. Several times told I want medium size cut meat. When I reached home and opened the bag they were super big piece not a single piece cut from the joint. Believe me you will make better pieces of fire wood with a blunt axe what that guy did with my rooster. I cud do nothing cuz I had no tools to cut it further.I hope Tom trains them little bit and make them responsible. Or he too does not care... Time will tell.

Anas Sayed

2023-05

Amazing service ! They are certified halal. Best part is, you can have all the meat cut the way you like it and they can vacuum seal all the meat for you ( for small extra charge ).

Jawad Ahmad

2021-05

Sells fresh Halal meat at reasonable price. Has all kind of animals you can pick. Ample parking. Takes cash, check and may be credit cards. Closed Sunday.Rude and bad customer service

Humza Ahmad

2021-05

The product is very neat and clean.Reasonable price. I have been visiting 4 year.There employees so humble and helpful guys. They are give you quick service.

Ali

2023-05

Thanks to Mr. TomHe is helpful person also the person in grocery store is helpful.Meat Is very good but chicken stinky and InedibleThank you very much.

Nitte Joseph

2022-05

Fresh meat at reasonable price & everyone was nice. It was my first time there and definitely going back.

Gopal Dulal

2022-05

Now a says They increases price too much. They accept EBT. Very clean and good customer service but too much expensive. They increases double prices

Sudanese American's Vlogs SAV

2022-05

Cash-out guy is rude. They getting greedy. But, in the slaughterhouse, butchers provide good services.

Butch Gossage

2022-05

Have bought hamburger from them a few times now. Good price great flavor.

Krystle Darr

2022-05

Friendly & super affordable quality meat. No where else compares!

Erin Baber-Sherwood

2022-05

Great local source of quality meat. Family run.

Liz Paloskey

2021-05

Nice people, great prices and quality of products.

Jeremy Chestnut

2022-05

Excellent beef,super nice helpful people.

Angelia Imhoff

2021-05

Awesome customer service top quality product!!

Brent Miller

2021-05

Awesome people, awesome pricing, GREAT MEAT!!

Jurabek Ziyadullaev

2021-05

Very nice place halol kill

Roka Abdou

2023-12

Bed service

Opening Hours

Monday Closed
Tuesday Closed
Wednesday 2-4 PM
Thursday 2-4 PM
Friday 2-4 PM
Saturday 8 AM-4 PM
Sunday Closed

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet