Cedar Valley

Rex Hall

2024-02

After a day on the road and unloading a moving truck, my wife and I were absolutely exhausted. We decided to try Cedar Valley because they were within 10 minutes of the new house. We walked in and there were only a few booths. The place had only one other customer and we were greeted by the owner and her sister. We told them about our exhausting day and they told us to sit down and they would take care of us. That is exactly what they did. I'm a big guy and would not fit into the booths, so they brought an office chair out and put it at the end of one of the booths. We ordered a large pizza, which was delicious! While it was being cooked, they sat out in the small dining area and talked to us the entire time. What a delight they are. Two of the nicest people I have ever met. We were so tired, and we told them that we were staying in basically an empty house. When we went to pay, they brought out 6 homemade cookies, which were delicious, and a quart of homemade vegetable soup and gave it to us. They wouldn't hear of taking money for the soup and cookies. I was just overwhelmed by the kindness of these two ladies. Oh yeah, the pizza was delicious and we can't wait to try other items from their menu.

Darlene Sherman

2024-02

This is a ma & pa kind of place that just makes you feel at home when you enter. All of the staff are wonderful and struck me as people who are just genuinely kind hearted. The inside is kept clean and neat, homemade cookies are displayed perfectly through an old school diner case which complimented the atmosphere well. The food was absolutely delicious. The personal Stromboli was baked to perfection and was a huge portion for such a low price. The cheesesteak sub is a new favorite and easily one of the best I have ever had. The meat was deliciously seasoned, the sub was well packed, the cheese melty, the fried onions blended perfectly. Even the BLT was done well. The pumpkin rolls were mouth watering and a sweet savory finish to top off a delicious dinner. I cannot say enough good things about this unexpected gem. From its atmosphere and people to its seemingly homemade recipes and prices, I can see why this shop has been around for so long. I only wish we had known about it sooner. I highly recommend a stop in for some food and good conversation if you're in the area.Kid-friendliness: Kids menu options available and the staff was so kind to kiddoWheelchair accessibility: Easily Accessible

Rhianon Capo

2024-04

i hate leaving negative reviews for small business but i don’t know how this place is even open or has the reviews it has. i’ve tried this place multiple times and have never been happy. decided to give it another try last night because it was close and needed something last minute. 30 min wait, when i got there i stood at the counter for 20 minutes before someone even noticed me. the tea i got out of the fridge was 2 months expired and had stuff floating in it, pizza was watery and 2 slices were missing cheese completely. and their dog was walking around the kitchen and begging customers for food. absolutely ridiculous. the only nice thing i can say is the ladies who work there are very nice and welcoming other than that, not worth it.

Ryan Jacoby

2023-05

The pizza that I got was good 👍. I have a couple other pizzerias closer to me and I like them a little better but this was tasty. Really has the old country charm and a small family owned feel. They aren't my favorite but they are good and I hope more people try them out.Kid-friendliness: They have ice cream, candy and snacks available as well as presumably home made cookies in a family friendly old-style dining room

Hope Strouth

2023-05

We stopped here on a whim, we live an hour away and are debating on coming back more than once. It’s an adorable mom& pop place, it looks a little precarious but it’s so worth it, everyone was so nice and it was very reasonably priced. Also 6 stars for the dogs I was able to pet!

C Vogel

2023-05

Have been going here since around 1975, when Miss May and Pop-Pop had it, with video rentals back in the day. Moved back into the area and found their daughter Jo Anne had taken over for the family and the food is still awesome! Try the broasted chicken! Subs are great too. Pizza? Oh yeah! There's even a special low price pizza night which goes up each minute after it begins, fun stuff! (You'll have to check out the store to find out which night. Oh, did I mention Hersheys' Icecream and special soft serve flavors all through the summer?... Malts? Uh-huh. I could go on and on. Love this place and the family heritage our neighborhood is proud to have.

David Crizer

2023-07

…More

Nicole Montanarelli

2023-12

…More

Jen A.- A

2022-05

They are so nice. I have a lot of allergy issue and was so hungry for pizza with the guys a few weeks ago. They made me a just cheese on dough and toasted it perfect like a foccacia , so I could have food out and on a Tues when they were slammed. They also let us put up fliers when our kitty Leelou got out. Just awesome food and neighbors. ❤

Mike Hateful

2017-05

I've been stopping here for 3-4 years. For the longest time I only ever bought the drinks and their home made cookies. The peanut butter marshmallow cookies are fantastic! Within the last 12 months I've discovered their pizza is also one of the best around. This place is every bit of the little Ma and Pa shops you remember from years past. The food is great and the service is friendly.

Christopher Galeone

2019-05

Excellent soft ice cream; so creamy and delicious! We had a black raspberry cone and a strawberry milkshake. Skip the shakes and cookies if you don't really enjoy sugar. Too sweet for my blood, but others may like them.Very friendly lady was working when we visited. She said they have rotating ice cream flavors; next week is peanut butter. I may have to revisit just to sample all the new flavors!As for all the haters down voting this establishment due to local political issues, ignore them. This is not the venue for name-calling and pettiness.Bottom line: The staff is friendly, the prices reasonable, and the ice cream is great! Next time I'm in the area, I'll be back in for another ice cream cone!

Keith Wiley

2020-05

Stood inside the shop for 16 minutes until someone came out from the kitchen to greet us and the staff (older woman cooking the pizza) was absolutely horrendously rude. Hated spending our money in the establishment after this woman treated my wife like garbage but unfortunately it was the only place within miles that had food for my hungry family. Terrible service, pizza not too shabby however.

Cyneathia AJ Gray

2021-05

The Owners were pleasant, the Restroom was Clean, the Cookies were Reasonable and Tasty. The Pizza was reasonably Priced, but there was No Sauce on Either of the Large Pizzas. The Buffalo Wings were a little dry.I was overcharged $4.62, until I recalculated my order. I was Gladly refunded the difference. This was my First visit.However, they did have a Sign that I'll Always Remember...😊🤣🤣🤣"Robbers, Please Bring I.D. So We Can Notify Your Next Of Kin."

S Hh

2018-05

Loved their pizza but I'll never be back. Joanne is excited to have local farms destroyed by Powerlines. All so she can make a quick buck selling food during the construction.

Carrie M Hillegass

2020-05

I’ve never been there before but she was so sweet! Amazing visit - the pizza and cookies were the best!!! Will definitely be taking an hour trip just for this shop soon

Cummins Daily

2023-05

People were very nice and food was very good. The dogs made it like at home, highly recommended and they have cookies!!!!

Missing Reagan

2023-05

Best pizza around. Love this place.

Christina Hohenbrink

2020-05

LOVE LOVE LOVE Joann and Pop!! Love their subs and pizza, but most of all soft serve ice cream!!! Best place around! Tuesday pizza deals are awesome!

Daniel Blue

2021-05

Wonderful staff, fast service, absolutely the best Philly Cheesesteak in the area! My wife and I order three and split them with a side of Cedar Valley Fries for the perfect meal. 😁

matt blake

2023-05

Drove by for years, finally stopped. Had a really good Italian and lived the old school feel. Will be back to try other items.

Craig Jones

2018-05

Sell out, Joanne hopes to profit off of Transources decimation of nearby farms. She can temporarily sell pizza to construction workers while our farms are destroyed. Don't support this business unless you enjoy the views of 140ft tall powerlines with no reduction in our energy costs.From the York Dispatch:"I think it's wonderful," said 58-year-old Fawn Township business owner Joanne Wilson."(Transource Energy) compensates farmers for their land, and brings their yards back up to better than it was. I say bring it on. Bring in the construction workers; I'll feed them all," Wilson said.Why don't any of the farmers agree with Joanne?

Shawn Patrick

2022-05

Very delicious food. Great little country store and the owners are very nice people. You dont see stores like this anymore!!

Thomas Gayer

2017-05

Great little local place, offers the basics but has great food. Some of the best pizza I have ever had.

Stacy Turner

2022-05

Super cute and friendly staff. We went on a Tuesday and had subs and took advantage of the Pizza special!

David Brenneman

2021-05

We love the pizza and ice cream. Today we tried the broasted chicken, and it was great! Fantastic people, too!

Jon Herculson

2023-05

…More

karl hohenbrink

2020-05

The food is great and the owners and staff make you feel like family. Pizza Tuesday is a great deal.

elizabeth scarito

2018-05

Love their pizza and today had delicious Italian hoagies. Homey atmosphere, good people!

D J

2021-05

Excellent pizza soft ,serve ice cream!!!! Food just like out your own kitchen!!

Edward Scheitlin Jr

2021-05

Small Mom and Pop shop, very nice people, pizza's mmm mmm good!