Wild Rabbit Pies & Pints

Miss Val

2024-05

We stopped in on a Sunday evening for pizza and a drink. We sat at the bar. The drinks were good. The pizza was good and was big enough to share between at least 2, maybe three depending how hungry you are. The bartenders were friendly and attentive. The atmosphere was laid back and casual. They have a game room in the back but we just chilled at the bar. This is in a neighboring town so I’d go here again for sure.Parking: I’m not 100% sure on the street parking being free all the time but you can put alt check New Cumberland Borough. I don’t remember seeing meters. We parked in a private parking lot that had signs about towing at your expense but there were a ton of cars in the lot and we took a chance because there was no street spots and it was raining. We were not towed.

Dion Woods

2024-01

Food was really good! the one downside is I stood for like 7 min in the front waiting for some one to seat me. I had to flag a someone down to get seated. Once seated it took another 10 min for someone to take my order. The Dumpling special was amazing! The white soy sauce was a real treat! The smash burrger was pretty standard but the bacon on it was done perfectly. Side salad was super fresh and the dressing was also very very good! Would eat there again.

Tommy K

2024-05

Came in after a show at West Shore Theater across the street.I am very thankful for the bartender and hostess that didn't just blow us off because we arrived within 5 minutes of closing time. We were still served food and made the last call for beer. Thank you so much!Zero attitude since some places just want to rush everyone out that close to closing.On top of that I never felt rushed even though the bar was gradually closing and patrons leaving.The jalapeno pepperoni pizza was incredible. The smoked honey was a wonderful touch on the pizza. The Mexican lager was delicious and paired well.Thank you again for making us feel welcome and not just blowing us off considering how late we arrived. I was starving and it was very appreciated that your staff remained friendly and hospitable even though things were closing up for the day.Ended up taking a peach bear 4pk to go after being welcomed to try sample first.Outstanding customer service and quality!!

Diane Gentile Klimovsky

2024-05

…More

Jeffrey Wilson

2024-01

The food is great, and they have a wide selection of well-made local beers. I’ve had the smash burger, chicken sandwich, pizza, and a variety of appetizers; all have been delicious. The last few visits I’ve enjoyed excellent, attentive service. The only negative is how loud it is inside, the place should really consider installing sound baffles hung from the ceiling.

Thomas Boyd

2023-12

This place is unique. It has a really cool game room and fun decor. The bathrooms are unisex and very clean. We had a group of 9 and the only dish that was good was the fire oven macaroni and cheese with an added side of chicken. The mushroom and classic boli was average to less than average. Be wary of the paper they lay under the strombolis because it deteriorates and you might eat it by accident (not wax paper). The sauce is not good. The service was ok. Unfortunately they brought out each dish 2 at a time. My Mother got hers last (we had to ask for it). We were here to celebrate her birthday. Also it's very loud so having a conversation isn't practical. Maybe there's a better time to come (Certainly not Friday night).

Derek Reed

2024-04

…More

Luke & Aubrie Weaver

2024-05

Delicious/ quick food, great service, beautiful atmosphere. We were seated so fast and all of the staff were so welcoming and helpful (Kendra especially)! We will definitely be coming back soon and use the arcade next time.

Allison Marino

2023-11

…More

Dennis Davis

2024-02

Get there early... it's a popular place for a reason. Loved the sweet heat pizza... but there was enough to take home and I loved it two more times the next day! The pies are decent sized, I'm a glutton for pizza, so I had to tell myself to leave some for later. I would say one pie and an appetizer would work for two people.Evergrain hefeweizen is pretty spot on too, I never turn one down.

Tamara Ramer

2024-03

Great atmosphere, service, beer, cocktails, and food! There's a kid's menu and it's kid-friendly, even has some arcade games in the back. The key lime pie martini is absolutely amazing and tastes exactly like the dessert! Also, the margherita pizza was delicious!Vegetarian options: My vegetarian/gluten free friend had no trouble ordering a pizza and other food items when we've been there together.Dietary restrictions: My vegetarian/gluten free friend had no trouble ordering a pizza and other food items when we've been there together.Kid-friendliness: It's loud enough in there to mask kid noises. They have a decent kid's menu and arcade games.

Shannon Godlasky

2023-07

…More

Thomas Weber (halifax9)

2024-03

The service is hit or miss. The five bartenders pool their tips which in my opinion allows them all to care less. There is one female bartender that went way beyond and should have received the full tip but she had to share it. (It took over 30 mins to our drinks)The food was good. Like most places these days you are much better off just ordering an appetizer. The main course will certainly disappoint.They are new so maybe they need to iron out the wrinkles.Update. 01/13/2024. They put noise cancelling boards on the ceiling so you can now hear each other speak.The service is still very slow and the food seems to always be served Luke warm. Perhaps they are understaffed and just can't seem to get it to the table fast enough. There does not appear to have any management in the place keeping an eye on things or helping out, unless they are in the kitchen with the dying food.

Sebastian Marin

2023-08

…More

Kara Watts

2024-04

…More

Shaun Steckley

2023-05

Finally made it and it didn't disappoint. The place is larger than expected, lots of seats. The bar is huge, probably at least 25 seats. Food was really good. Fries are more shoestring style but fresh cut and seasoned really well. Huge portion also with the fish and chips. Wife's pizza was good also. Bunch of arcade games in the back. We will return... Often....

Joseph Harburg

2023-06

We have four kids and our baby had a some issues and the service staff was extremely kind and helpful! After we ordered and were waiting for the food (not a long wait mind you) the kids played the arcade games. We paid 10 dollars and it was more than enough for 3 kids to play. Absolutely wonderful service, food, and beer. Highly recommend, especially if you have children!

Simon Heintzelman

2023-09

First time visitors this weekend and was totally by accident. We stumbled on Wild Rabbit after another stop on our list closed at 4 on Sunday. We popped in after reading this was a sister establishment to Evergrain, and we were not disappointed in that decision.The drink menu was on point and each drink was carefully crafted, including the incredibly cute baby clothespins to hold on the garnish.Not picture, but very much enjoyed, were the nachos. The wood fired salsa was 🔥🔥!Will most certainly return and can’t wait!

Lisa Charleton

2023-06

…More

norman seitz

2024-04

…More

ali nicole

2023-05

Went for lunch during a weekday. Beautifully designed. Each table gets a cold water carafe when seated. My son ordered the chicken ceasar salad and I ordered the chopped salad with shrimp. The salads were huge and delicious! I loved the white balsamic vinaigrette on the chopped salad. We also ordered the prosciutto and arugula pizza. The pizza was good but didn't have very much flavor. We will definitely eat here again. The service was excellent!

Angela Briggs

2024-05

We visited Friday night on a whim. They were very busy, but we were able to get on the waitlist and were seated in about 20 minutes. There is a large waiting area in the back of the restaurant with a selection of arcade games. The food was absolutely worth the wait! I highly recommend the "lazy onion rings". Their pizza is also delicious with some of the most flavorful crust in the area!

A

2023-05

I believe this place just opened today.They have several large tables which can accommodate bigger parties. But small parties may be sharing a table with another small party (not an issue personally). They also have bar seating.Staff was attentive. Sometimes when a restaurant has just opened, staff can be overwhelmed and not at their best, but I didn’t have any issues.There are three unisex bathrooms on the way to the back room which houses arcade games.I tried the fungi pie which was delicious. The dough is probably the best I’ve had in the tri-county area. It has that great chewy texture. The only complaint I have is that the crust takes up about a third to nearly half of a slice, meaning you’re getting considerably less of the pizza with toppings. However, maybe this was a one-off. I’ll be back to try some of their other pies and menu items.

Sami Gatesman

2023-05

Went there a week or so after opening. Definitely a neat place and I’m sure it will be busy/crowded for the coming months especially in summer. The chips and dip were amazing - lots of flavor. The pizza was good. I would have loved to have three times the amount of cheese though. It also has a smokey/brick oven flavor that can be a little overwhelming if you don’t like that. Overall the flavor was good.

Matt Bitner

2023-09

Update 2: I stopped in for lunch and they have new bar stools that look a lot more comfortable and they have some sound boards hanging from the ceiling to help with the noise. It wasnt busy so Im not sure if it will work, but Im excited to try them for dinner soon. It's nice to see they are listening.Update: we finally were able to try the Rabbit for dinner on a Wednesday with no wait. Either the menu changed or there are some additional choices for dinner. We had the Bacon jalapeno smash burger, the smash burger, and the shrimp nachos. The nachos seemed oddly bland, but the burger was good. The 3 of us shared one of the tables with another party of 3, it's just a little odd being so close to another party. It was difficult to stay fully engaged with our parties conversation since we could hear our neighbors so easily. It was difficult to have a conversation in general since it was very loud, and my ears are still ringing a bit.I stopped in for lunch and tried the smash burger with a side of tomato soup. I really like they have options besides fries. You can also get a side salad. We sat at a high top on the bar side, which is first come seating. I will say everything looks great, and I look forward to trying them for dinner. We tried on a Friday night, and there was a long wait, and they were packed. When we were waiting in line to see what the wait time was on that Friday , it was very loud with the people chatting and the acoustics.

Corrie Harris

2023-05

Fantastic new and very hiprestaurant and bar with DELICIOUS food!! (I had the chicken pie). Great drink menu too. The place was packed on a Monday night. Cool atmosphere. My one complaint and advice for this restaurant. GET RID OF THOSE AWFUL CHAIRS IN THE BAR AREA!!!!! Too high, too small, and I stood up because they were so painful.

Lauren Good

2024-04

The drinks and food were good and the atmosphere is very nice! The service was terrible. We walked in (party of 2) and stood for 5 minutes looking at the empty host stand. I could see a server in the back area but she never came up to us. There were only about two other tables of people in the restaurant. I saw there was a bartender so I decided head over to the bar area since there was no one to seat us. I asked the bar tender if I could sit at one of the high top tables (they were all empty) and she annoyingly paused said yes. Eventually we got menus and ordered and it was fine. Not in a hurry to come back here.

Chris Ozz

2024-04

…More

Navya Voleti

2023-06

Wild Rabbit was such a cute place to celebrate a special event. Their ambiance was great and they had cool art throughout the restaurant. They have table seating, high top tables, and bar seating available. Their high top seats were pretty slippery, and we had to ask to switch to a regular table but they were very accomodating.Their drink menu and beers are very similar to evergrain; they do not offer flights.In order of best to least best, what I would recommend are: Pepperoni & Jalapeño pizza (slightly on the spicy side), truffle potato pizza, and sopressata pizza. Their fries that come with their burgers are thin and crispy. Their pretzel is also soft but has a hard shellx and is not too salty. I recommend their beer cheese for sure.Cocktails that were a hit for the table include “here comes the sun” and “yellow submarine”. OR we may just be the biggest Beatles’ fans ;)

Dan B Ross

2024-02

Our server/bartender was very knowledgeable, extremely friendly, and helpful.Excellent dining experience all around!I look forward to visiting again!