Making Sense Quality Consignments

Tammy Cortright

2024-05

Please Don't be mad Mr. Mad Badger..I did not have electricity for 2 weeks. How ever I was open with the exception of 2 Saturday's!Life is too short to Be so Mad Mr. Badger! Sorry for any inconvenience. I have a text club in which I have texted all my customers everyday giving them updates It's impossible to reach everyone. Text SENSE TO 51660

Mad Badger

2024-04

This is the second Saturday my family has swung by to check this shop out during their normal business hours only to find it closed for no apparent reason. Waste of time.

Mitchell Feidt

2023-06

This is one of my favorite places to shop.Everyone is so friendly,helpfulAn great prices.I pick up these pillowsThe other day ,gorgeous

Judy Smith

2021-05

I got 2 beautiful rings! Place is clean and organized. It has all sorts of items from clothing to furniture and jewelry.

Alyssa Showers

2023-06

I have really enjoyed shopping here and have come back several times. Awesome people and great prices!

Miss Richardson

2014-05

I have been mostly pleased. Tammy and Deanna are very cordial but the shorter gal is unpleasant. She makes me feel like I am imposing on her day. She never smiles. I only buy when Tammy or Deanna are checking out customers. Otherwise, I like the furnishings and clothing very much. Prices are just slightly higher than other consignments shops when it comes to clothing but I enjoy shopping there anyway.Just avoid the shorter lady, she's consistently not pleasant.

Monica Shirey

2019-05

They have a really diverse collection of quality consignments. They must be very selective in what they consign because everything seems in nearly new condition. I really enjoy popping in once a month or so, and every time it seems like a brand new store. The prices are reasonable from the outset, but you can find some excellent bargains if the items have been there more than a few weeks. It's a fun place to wander through.

Debra Wise

2019-05

This place is great! Tammy & Deanna are so friendly and make you feel like you are home. Merchandise is displayed well and there is always something that catches your eye! My favorite place to shop!

Gomer Pyle

2022-05

From a sellers perspective every time I go in they simply ignore me. Sometimes it’s for 20 plus minutes and I would understand if they were dealing with buyers but that’s not the case. So much more pleasant at the Carriage House

Valbona H

2022-05

I've been coming to Making Sense for 12 years now. I love the home selections, I will always keep coming. The owners were always super sweet.

Robert Basom

2024-01

My favorite shop in newcumberland.

Brigette Hare

2023-06

Tammy the owner is just the sweetest. Great prices and lot to see.

Vickie Wentz

2019-05

Love this place. Great prices and always changing inventory. You see it and like it.....you better purchase it right away due to not being there the next visit.

Drew Xavier

2018-05

Great service and very friendly employees. I found what I was looking for immediately upon entrance of the store. Even if you do not buy, it is a great place to visit.

Judy Troutman

2020-05

Making sense is a great store. They are very helpful and the prices are reasonable. Can't wait to go again

spectrumom1

2021-05

Very disappointed that not one employee wore a mask. Such a small thing to do to protect their customers. I guess that tiny bit of defiance is worth more than other people’s safety.

Lisa Harman

2019-05

Bargains, bargains! Ladies are very nice. I just am not happy there is always a dog there--does no one consider customers with allergies?

Karen Seibel

2019-05

I love this shop! The prices were amazing and the variety was great!Shop on a Friday with cash and get a discount!

Senpai God

2016-05

I love these gals and their store. I only go for housewares and find all kinds of interesting things at great prices.

Sue Wilson

2018-05

Ive been shopping her for many years. ALWAYS a pleasant place to shop! The owners are are eager to help. Overall the best consignment shop that sells clothes, jewelry and home decor.

Bonnie Baker

2018-05

I find something everytime..love the special discounts offered occasionally..nice selection..I've purchased lots of quality furniture..very friendly....I recommend the store to my friends..

Marylue Durff

2018-05

Great place...well organized...excellent quality...tons of choices...very helpful staff. Prices are amazing! Something for everyone!

Elaine Szebin

2020-05

We go almost every week. Fun place to shop. Awesome owners!!!

Cameron W

2020-05

Stopped by the new location and it was very nice and clean. Close to home as well. Will visit often looking for goodies.

Cheryl Brosi

2019-05

Love this store. Good selection for the home and person. Very fair prices.

L Davis

2021-05

While this was an interesting shop a year ago, staff was a bit snooty and the merchandise yard sale quality. Going downhill fast.

Janet M Fry

2021-05

Excellent shop. Very nice clothing and furniture. Very well run and nice specials

Sharon Simpson

2018-05

Very nice Consignment shop, we bought some nice pieces for our new home. Surprised to hear they downsized.

Trent57

2019-05

Good selection of home items and decor. Usually running promos if you are on their text list

Anthony Smolenski

2018-05

Quality consignment store with friendly service, lots of furniture, decor, womens clothing, and jewelry. Smaller mens clothing section, but the quality and brands are much better and more selective than others.