Taste Of Little Italy

Wesley

2024-05

…More

Trista Miller

2024-04

If I could give a negative star I would. The lasagna was disgusting, watery, and no flavor.we also got 2 chicken Alfredo and that was no flavor watery it was disgusting the Stromboli flavor was okay but really greasy the jumbo chicken wings tasted good but was really hard. The owner is disrespectful. 40 some dollars wasted down the drain

Sharon Lewis

2024-05

…More

Taylor Escobar

2023-06

I recently ordered online from Taste of Little Italy in New Berlin, Pennsylvania, and it was a delightful experience. The Greek pizza was an absolute treat for my taste buds, with its perfectly baked, thin and crispy crust that held up well under the generous toppings. The combination of fresh vegetables on top, complemented by a drizzle of balsamic glaze, created a burst of outstanding flavors. The tanginess of the glaze enhanced the natural sweetness of the veggies, resulting in a delightful and refreshing taste. I also indulged in a side of fries with melted cheese and gravy, which provided a true comfort food experience. The golden, crispy fries paired with the rich and creamy melted cheese, along with the savory gravy, created a perfect combination of textures and flavors that made this dish a definite winner. If you're looking for exceptional pizza and delicious sides, Taste of Little Italy is a must-try

Kelly Beaver

2023-05

…More

Eric Curry

2024-04

…More

Melinda Vyskocil

2023-05

We were in town for SU graduation, & needed some last minute catering. Staff was very nice & accommodating. We ordered two trays of food & a salad. The food was amazing! The salad was beautifully prepared- wish I took pics. Tried to tip them & they wouldn’t take it, just thanked us for being a customer. Nice family business!

Daniel

2023-07

…More

Angie Smay

2023-05

We were disappointed by this place. The reviews are all so good, we were excited to try it. My husband had a chicken parm sub which was chicken tenders rather then a chicken breast. I got a cheese steak that would have been good except for the bun. The buns were very doughy with an almost under done consistency. Very disappointed by the experience.

Patrick Cushing

2023-05

My wife and I visited here fairly recently, and while the food was good, service was lacking due to being short staffed. I can't blame the restaurant for this, as this is a condition that is plaguing the food service industry.Please be patient with the staff here, they are trying very hard to keep up with high demand!The dining room is very small and seating is limited.Prices seemed a bit high to me, we paid around $50 for a large pizza, a cheesesteak sub, fries, and mozzerella sticks. Due to inflation this is somewhat understandable as this small family restaurant is just trying to make ends meet.Definitely worth a visit if you're in the area, I'm planning on giving them another try someday!

Mr. Gunk

2021-05

A little slow because of tons of take out orders but the food was great. My super sub was huge!!!! My new favorite sub!!!

M.l. Weber

2023-05

Some of the worst food I ever had, don't try there Cheese burger subs! The meat taste fake.. bad texture, bun smelled like yeastOrder took forever to come out.. They have a soda fountain machine, but they fill your cups from warm 2 liter bottles.. And they charge you a 1.99 a cup.. There service was .... As bad as visiting the county morgue! ( Dreadful ) to say the least!! Eat there at your own riskVegetarian options: NoneWheelchair accessibility: Yeah ok 🤣🤣🤣

Carrie Miller

2023-05

Our first and last visit was during lunch the fountain soda machine wasn't working they use 2 liter bottles to fill cups the cups were dirty and had chiping paint that came off on your hands. We ordered a cheese steak, meatball hoagie, bacon cheese burger with fries and cheese burger with fries...the hoagie rolls were very under baked, burgers were rubbery and way to small for the massive bun, bacon was undercooked, not enough meatballs on sub was all bread, meatballs were old and smelled like they about to turn rotten, window sills were dirty booths were very wobbly and there was garbage and junk laying outside along the building....I do not recommend this place

Hamp Underhill

2024-02

…More

Jason Thone

2023-05

This place is a run of the mill pizza joint. Nothing special about their pizza. The restaurant is small and the booths are small. They don’t have those pizza holder things. But whatever you do, don’t go in their bathrooms. They stink to high Heaven with the smell of sewage.

Jennifer Munns

2022-05

We order here often. We have pretty much tried everything. Not a fan of the hoagie pizzas because they arent the doagies we are used to in the coal region, its the crust on them. But we love everything else. Their lasagna is great, calzones, stromboli, wings are huge and crispy... they also run daily specials and usually have their cold subs on sale once a week. The last 2 times we ordered it was super busy and our garlic knots were completely black but otherwise great food. Delivery never takes very long. The owners delivered already so its nice to see them all come together when its busy or short staffed. Great pizza joint.

Belinda Albright

2021-05

Nice, clean pizzeria. It was my first visit. They offer typical fare; pizza, subs, Italian dinners. The pizza is middle of the road. Service was good. Eat in dining or take out. They had many calls for takeout while I was there. Unfortunately for those placing orders on the phone, they were on speaker phone, volume all the way up, so anyone in the entire building could not only hear the order but name and phone number as well. Privacy is important to most of us and I personally had no appreciation for their ordering system. Bathrooms are very small, so small your body is against the toilet paper in the holder (you have to lean to get any tp.)I will give the place another try, maybe a hoagie next time.

Lillian Skulsky

2021-05

I have come out of town just to try this restaurant due to all the recommendations I’ve received from customers who’ve eaten there and it was such a disappointment to even waste my time and money driving there. The lettuce on the salads do not seem to be washed whatsoever as to I found dirt in my salad. My daughter ordered a pizza and the amount of oil was disgusting. My husband noticed not one person was wearing gloves or a mask during their shift. The dining room was dirty and sticky and I personally don’t feel like I should have to clean up after other customers. Also, the soda I received was flat and warm like it wasn’t refrigerated for some reason. All I can say is it seems very unprofessional and looking at the condition of the dining room I can only imagine what the kitchen looks like

Susan Guyer

2022-05

Late afternoon...place was dirty.waitress not very personable ,terrible service..ordered xtra heavy mayo, maybe had swipe..ordered xtra onions, couldn't find one..Cosmo, bread was hardly baked..soda pored out of two liter bottles and was flat as flat could be. Too Much else to go on about ,was disappointed after hearing good things..will not go back because entire time there , owner and a delivery person were talking about pizza shop owners in Middleburg!! Do that in private, not so your entire place of business can hear all their private issues!!

Paula Morris

2023-05

…More

Tammy Smith

2022-05

Everything I have gotten so far was delicious. Price was fine to me. Can eat in, take out, and if your in their range of delivery they deliver. Sometimes it takes awhile though they are usually always busy.

Kyle Kolowsky

2022-05

Delicious! Cheese pizza and spinach ricotta mushroom bacon pizza!

joshua struble

2024-02

…More

Tim Cooley

2022-05

…More

Jeff Bowersox

2022-05

We got a bacon pepperoni pizza for the second time. Love the sauce and crust. The bacon was uncooked and made the pie grossst but the bacon was like they never cooked the bacon. It Was uncooked

Gus Shultz

2022-05

…More

Luke

2023-05

This place is terrible just like the owner(s). SUPER creepy around the employees and the owner of the restaurant is very disrespectful and rude he disgusts me. This place will be losing some of its business because I get the word around. Will never come here again.

Bill Wagner

2022-05

The wraps were very good but the lasagna had one noodle and some meat with the majority being sauce and cheese. Good flavor but not like any lasagna I ever had.

John Rothrock

2021-05

Takes over an hour to have 3 subs delivered to middleburg. 10 mins from there shop!!!! Owner is very very very rude. Refusing to make it right! I would not recommend this place to ANYONE third time this has happened. And we order from them once a week!!! Never again. Vinnies will now have my business forever!!!

Jennifer Clouser

2023-12

…More