Bargain Barn

4.5 (124)

1687 William Penn Hwy, Mifflintown, PA 17059
(717) 436-8808
m.facebook.com

Claim this business

Consignment shop

Service options

  • In-store shopping

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

Sarah Hornbaker

2024-04

This was my first time here. I really loved looking at everything. There was a deal on all clothes and shoes half off. The man working was very friendly! His service was kind and on point! If you've never been here before, you must go!

Kayla Mar

2024-02

Really enjoyed our visit here! The shop is pretty big, is kept clean and has a wide variety of items for mostly decent prices. We had a lot of fun looking through to find treasures!Don’t miss the upstairs! 🙂

Bobbijo Adlon

2024-01

I love this place.You can find a lot of good stuff there for road teeth. And it's not like goodwill where they just take your stuff and resell it. This place takes your stuff and then gives you some of the money when they sell your items. That's what people need to start doing instead of donating to goodwill....

Joshy Cox (Smush)

2024-04

This store has been a fixture in the community for as long as I can remember. From clothing, videos, kids toys, housewares, to furniture the Bargain Barn has you covered and the Bargain Barn is not just a clever nickname. Brand new mattresses and box springs with prices so low no other retailer can compete with the bargains at the Bargain Barn. Conveniently located along Old US Hwy 322 William Penn Hwy just off the Arch Rock Exit of US Hwy 322. Tell Greg that I sent you.

Theresa Bookler

2023-07

Best place in town to shop. Great prices and with very friendly and helpful people.Stop in and see for yourself, you won't regret it.

Coming Judgement

2023-05

Very nice consignment store with a wide variety of things. Great vibe here. It reminds me alot of the consignment store my wife worked at for over 20 years. The owner retired. The Bargain Barn is a fantastic place to browse. You never know what you're gonna find here. The pricing is really good, and the inventory is good quality.

Andy Barnes

2023-11

Cool place. Never know what you might find.

Tammy Fetrow

2023-05

Love this place. Friendly workers. Never know what you might find. Some great bargains

B P

2023-05

Absolutely love this place it's like a treasure hunt cause you always find something that brings back memories or a diamond in the rough

Mandy Thomas

2021-05

I gave three stars because the store employees may be nice and the prices may be great, I’ll never know.The aisles and racks are so over stuffed. I got anxiety walking through the store. I tried to look at a couple items and it was so hard to get off the rack and put back. The aisles are very narrow, can’t get past anyone.If you are claustrophobic or have Anxiety - I would maybe go else where.

Ronda Haldeman

2023-08

Great place to find bargains. Love walking around the place for something to do.

Ellen Mohamed

2019-05

They are such nice people. I'm a handicapped lady. A friend of mine was looking for a floor lamp. So I went up stairs and found one.i came back down stairs and be asked young lady if she could bring it down for me because my balance is bad and I need to hang on to railing so I couldn't carry it. She smiled said yes of course.not only did she bring it down she offered to take to my car.i said oh thank you but I can manage. Her kindness is rare now a days. So I would recommend this place not only for there good prices but there kindness. I'm sorry I don't remember the ladies name

Tammy Hosler

2024-02

Good selection, friendly service.Great prices!

Christeena Burkholder

2022-05

I love The Bargain Barn I always come out of there with a bag for something else it's the best thrift store around I've never had a problem there and I'll keep going back there

James Ressler

2023-05

Nice bargain shop. Things are priced to move. Clean and well organized.

Brad Zeigler

2024-04

Great People and Products

Angel Her

2023-05

Not sure what's going on , on Sundays ppl don't seem to be paid for items sold that day .

Edwin Claybaugh, Sr.

2024-04

We will be back.

Rolando Carrasquillo

2022-05

Good prices and you can find things that you don't find anywhere else.

Jeremy Bilger

2023-05

Great place for second hand items from clothing to tool everything in between

Scottie R Dunn

2023-10

Amazing products cheap 👌

Emily Smith

2022-05

Love. Love the owner!!! Great man very helpful and very nice.. Do alot of business for the barn!!Go to for consignment

Jason Garrett

2020-05

Great selection on some used clothes, furniture, and even toys. The conditions of the items are usually quality, and if not perfect they are always reparable.

Ashley Reichert

2020-05

You just never know what you're going to find here, and their prices are absolutely amazing!

Alison Grimm

2023-05

It's a nice thrift store for a small town

Zachary Bowser

2021-05

Decent place to go for used items. Never know what might find week to week

Dawn.

2017-05

Love this place . I find awesome deals all the time.

Shelly Damiano

2023-05

Open until 8 pm week of Christmas, 2022.

Gwendolyn Blake (BrokenParaWitch)

2017-05

Definitely one of my favorite stops. Everyone is do friendly and I always find something I need.

Sharon Harlan

2022-05

I love it! You don't know what you might find

Opening Hours

Monday 10 AM-8 PM
Tuesday 10 AM-8 PM
Wednesday 10 AM-8 PM
Thursday 10 AM-8 PM
Friday 10 AM-8 PM
Saturday 10 AM-6 PM
Sunday 10 AM-6 PM

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet