Sportsamerica Sports Cards

Ann Cirelli

2023-10

I was sold a 10 pack of cards (soccer) for $15. My son opened them with two cards completely ruined and a third with some damage. I called the store and was told to bring them back. I did just that and was told, “no, that is part of those cards, it is from the gum.” Prior to this I brought my son here about every other week. I will just buy his cards on eBay. Bummer, it was great to support small business, but over $15 they lost a customer.

Kenny Ryan

2024-02

Run by two men and two women who were miserable and unfriendly during my encounter. Singles are priced at 3-4x comps, otherwise some nice cards. Decent selection of wax, Card Stadium is still the better option for me.

Michael Lyle

2023-05

I was in town on business and decided to check out the shop. Guys were great. Found some very nice 77 Topps for my set and got them at a great price. Highly recommend! Thanks!

Jeremy Brown

2023-12

I visited the Wow Store! It was my 1st time & I was very impressed w/ their variety of selections for different items 👍🏾 I'll def be returning...great customer service as well!

Derek Kline

2023-12

Best card shop in the region! Awesome staff, great selection of products, and really good prices.

Scott Sines

2023-12

It’s a card shop serving the Mechanicsburg area of Pennsylvania and online customers.

Collin Krakowski

2023-07

100% was not worth the drive from Harrisburg. Box selection was good, but as far as the singles, asking prices were nearly 10x ebay on some cards. One card in specific last did 17 11 and 9 and the asking price was 100$. Very hard to do business like this. Another card i had wanted last did 78$, with a few up currently having buy it nows under 150$. Me and my friend placed a bet saying they would be asking 175. We were wrong. 250$. lol.

Gibby Leroy

2023-10

Great store. Really nice layout and has all of the newest cards. My new favorite card shop.

William Brown

2023-10

They don't buy what they sell well they do but but it's not really anything that the regular Sports Card Collector would have and if they did have it they probably wouldn't sell it mentioned to Nolan Ryan rookie I mean there's not too many good players from the 60s I would think probably Hall of Famers but people want the new and best thing friendly people but you know I would say 40% of the time when someone Smiles in your face it's not cuz they are happy

M E

2023-05

First time here and it was AWESOME!! They had everything I ever wanted from Pokémon booster boxes too hockey & football hobby boxes. No more ordering online. I’d much rather support the local card shop. Little bit of everything for all kinds of sports.

David Heckard

2023-05

Great people who own and work here. Lots to chose from. They are very patient with my son who wants to look at every card in the store 😆. I saw someone said not kid friendly I think it must have been a bad day, because I think they are absolutely kid friendly more than any shop in the region I have been to.

Kyle Mace

2021-05

I've been in an out of the hobby over the last 15 years, and have really gotten back into it over the last few months. I knew about the store from a quick search, but never stopped in until recently and was blown away how awesome this shop is. Amazing selection, beautifully laid out store, and probably the nicest staff I've ever come across when shopping at a card shop. They are so kind, so willing to help, and I truly enjoy looking forward to my visits to come in, chat, and grab some packs or boxes from them. If you are in the area and love sports, you have to stop in this store at least once!!!

Curtis Lingenfelter

2022-05

Absolutely incredible store. Well-kept and organized with an amazing staff! Everyone was incredibly friendly and so willing to talk and help. Cory and crew are a top sports card stores in the area! Would highly recommend to anyone looking for higher end cards as well. Definitely will stop by when in the area again!

Ty Faichney

2023-05

Not many in the area, but this is my favorite LCS. The people are great and their prices are always fair. They have a massive selection, you will always find something you're looking for. When you stop in, make sure you get some of the puppy chow! Buy the big container because you'll be wishing you had more!

T K

2023-05

Absolutely terrible place. The two old lady's are beyond rude. No customer service whatsoever. Who greets someone as soon as they walk in the door with "yes?" They may treat regulars better but for anyone new, take the extra time to drive somewhere else. I came here with a box of baseball cards from the early 50's and a box of error cards from the early 60's. Now, I know I'm a young female who is new to this hobby, (These cards came from my grandparents) but I'm not stupid so when the two old ladies told me they would buy both boxes of cards for $300.00, I POLITELY said "okay well I'm going to call another store and see if they would be interested and what they would offer." Who wouldn't want to get the most bang for their buck? Plus, like I said, I'm new to this so definitely want more than one opinion. Both ladies got so aggressive and told me "if I didn't like what they had to say I can leave their store" they told me I was being "disrespectful to them" and that the "cards I have are fake anyway" (which if they were fake why would they offer me $300?) I called VSM Sports Card Outlet in Lancaster and they told me they'd be interested in both boxes if I could come down on Saturday. I went there and the experience was literally A MILLION times better. Now they didn't buy every card I had (some are more in demand than others) but the cards they did buy, I made a lot more than $300.. So please, do your research before coming to SportsAmerica in Mechanicburg. I still have boxes of Hockey, and Footballl cards, know where I will NEVER take them to? You guessed it. SportsAmerica. I'd rather take the 45 minute drive to Lancaster where I was treated like a person and not like an intruder in their store. Terrible store, Terrible people. VSM deserves your business, SportsAmerica deserves to go out of business.

William Brown

2023-10

Great little shop lots of product friendly and understanding willing to work through any sort of discrepancies tyty

Greg Turcott

2023-05

Great store great merchandise the lady who owns it is pretty uptight and not much of a card person. I was in with my 3,year old and she was very agitated. Not very kid friendly. I did not leave with a warm feeling

Kalyn Cole

2021-05

Great selection and good prices! I also like that they have women working there. Makes buying trading cards more comfortable lol. Usually it's a male-dominated hobby so I was pleasantly surprised to see women working in this store. I also like that they have some sets that can't be found in stores like Target and Wal-Mart anymore. (Pokémon) I'm sure I'll be back!

Amanda Marciel-Deaner

2021-05

My fiance loves this place. He buys cards here and is able to send cards he sells through here also. The people who own and work here are very nice. Lola(I believe her name is), the dog, is a great incentive to visit also.

Paige & Deeneebeen

2023-05

Great Sports Card ShopThanks for the 1971 Topps CardsWill definitely recommend and visit again!!

Donnie Fisher

2023-08

Friendly service, tremendous selection of cards and hobby boxes. Along with great prices.

John Eckerd

2023-06

Great shop!!! Good selection....packaged and open cards...reasonably priced

NinjaTerd473

2019-05

Great store, friendly staff. A little far to drive frequently for me at least being in the hershey area. They usually have a very nice selection for mkst card games and definitely for you sports card fans.

Paul Duffy

2020-05

Great place, very good customer service and selection. And I just have to say, to Glenn in a comment below, what kind of idiot gives a 1 star review because a place doesn’t have as many Eagles cards as you like. That is the most asinine thing I have ever heard. What a d-bag. - Written by Paul

Dave ICFoodneat

2023-09

Great store and staff, reasonable prices and big selection.

Natasha Logsdon

2022-05

Great place! Dont go anywhere else for our cards. Great selection and even better service! Prices are great too

Dev

2023-07

It showed they were selling Pokémon cards individually on their website but none there. Also VERY overpriced.

David H

2020-05

Me and my son stopped in a couple of days ago. The employee working there was really nice. We will be back this week for more football cards. Great prices and service.

Terry Powers

2024-02

Very limited supply of football card packs and boxes.

Jon Milliken

2018-05

Very friendly staff. I wish they would have advertised their selection of Yu-Gi-Oh!, Pokemon, and Magic. They will definitely get more business for me