Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

Stephenie Koerne

2023-05

Really disappointed today. Got two large Misto’s but they were barely 3/4 full. Not to mention they weren’t well blended - the ice is basically just sitting on top of the custard. And one was supposed to have two flavours but only tastes like one. For the price, do better.

Lanah Odum

2023-11

This place is amazing! The staff is really nice and the cool thing about this place is that you can call and order what flavor you want in advance! I ordered a gelati and not only was there a huge chunk of ice cream on the top but there was some at the bottom as well! Recommend to everyone!

Jim Smith

2023-10

Employees refused to honor the buy 2 get 1 free on weekends! False advertising?

Jim Morrison

2024-01

…More

Debbie Wentz

2023-08

Service was good and so was my gelato. However every time I go to any Rita's they never have rootbeer water ice.☹

Collin Zimmerman

2023-08

A wonderful place to grab some sweet treats!

Suzy Cartright

2023-05

What a delightful place. My kids and dogs have been coming here for years. The traditional lemon, as well as the lime, mango, and sour apple are family favorites. Our new puppy has been thrilled with the peanut butter topping on her Gelato. She now tries to order at the counter by herself.

Jason

2022-05

Had the Mango Strawberry. This was my first time to Rita's this season and I was so happy to see chunks of strawberry in my ice.bring back the fruit pieces. We love you Rita's.

Tammy Lynne

2020-05

I think I was served the most beautiful black raspberry ice cream cone tonight. I gave the gentleman a compliment about how perfect it looked. It was magazine advertising worthy! Just as tasty too I might add! :)

Curt Raymond

2022-05

Frozen custard is so far ahead of frozen yogurt it isn't even in the same league. We stopped in on a Sunday afternoon, there was a long line and after getting our custard we know why there is a line. You NEED to visit Rita's...

Linda Becker

2019-05

As usual Rita's ice was well enjoyed! Wanted black cherry flavor, none available but said they'd make some up and have ready in 15 min. Went in nearby Giant for a few minutes then returned. They had the ice ready , it even had chuncks of cherry in it and was the best ever!!

Kent Rogers

2022-05

Not a single naturally flavored Italian ice is offered at this location. Also, their custard contains bad (non-food) ingredients. Finally, their prices are outrageous - $2.43 for the smallest scoop (kid serving) of chocolate custard (chocolate custard has the least bad ingredients) you could imagine. Horrible.

Samantha Dennen

2023-05

Great place to stop and get a cold treat on a super hot day!! Staff was super pleasant and very helpful, especially since I was indecisive as all getout. Keep up the awesome job!

Alex Dorf

2021-05

Just went to go grab water ice and none of the employees were wearing masks, and none of the customers sitting around the patio were either. I’d prefer not to have my dessert topped with potential coronavirus sprinkles. Also this location never has quite the selection of flavors that the Manheim Pike one does🤷🏻‍♂️

Maurielle C

2020-05

We came at 9:50 expecting that they would still be open. I looked online and it said that hey were open until 10. We made the trip only to find out that they were closed before even arriving. Super disappointed, never go here at this time. Hope that they can do better in the future with honesty.

Elaine Foultz

2023-05

Always yummy, I come with my bike group and buy the time I get my order is time to go. The staff needs more help.

kyller tiamatson

2021-05

Ritas is always a hit. Today my attendee was a very nice and helpful young lady. She made my experience much better. If you are anywhere by the shops by Kissel Hill, please stop by Ritas, you will love it.

Daniel Garman

2023-06

The place has a large selection of Italian Ice and one of the best Ritas in Lititz!

Chad

2023-05

Always delicious! Always a fun treat!

Konrad Fritz

2023-05

Love their Italian ice and frozen custard! Great flavors and lots of choices.

Tom Wolf

2018-05

Coffee & Chocolate Custard - I love it!A lot of people inline but servef in 5 min. Friendly staff. Poor parking especially if handicapped as you park behind and away from the serving windows.

Savannah

2023-05

I asked for green apple the girl thought i said mango and clarifies with me you wanted mango. I said no green apple. What do i get? Mango. Maybe you should get better staff that listen

Cory Shollenberger

2019-05

Serving sizes are considerably smaller than other Rita's locations at the same price. And their chocolate and vanilla custard were not in the same machine even though they were the only two flavors so couldn't get a cone of twist.

Peggy Castle

2022-05

Went to support kissel hill elementary. Perfect treat for a warm evening. Fast service for the amount of persons attending the fund raiser

Ellie Smith

2023-05

Always a delight, this location has umbrellas at the tables which is nice.

Charles Sutton

2020-05

Rita's is very good at what it does. I can't give it five stars because it has a very limited menu; The ice cream is only chocolate or vanilla.

Michael Schaeffer

2018-05

I always get a chocolate and Vanilla Custard cone. I loved when they opened 1 month earlier this year. They opened Presidents Day Weekend.

Madhuri Patil

2023-11

Ice Gola n ice-cream teste awesome

Jason Schlegelmilch

2022-05

Buddy and me were very impressed by the polite service of the employees josiah and luke. 10/10 Would definitely recommend

T B

2023-05

Great spot, but the flavor choices lack sometimes.