Reesers' Soft Ice Cream

Vito Salem

2024-04

Great place to stop for ice cream and food. And the serving sizes are huge and the cost ain't bad at all. Good luck eating all the ice cream. It's delicious.Parking: Big stone lotKid-friendliness: Mini golf right down the road. Great food and plenty of room aroundWheelchair accessibility: Flat, no steps.

Brandon P

2022-05

We came here for the ice cream only. But they do offer basic sandwiches, burgers and typical carryout dinner/lunch affairs to choose from. As far as the selection of ice cream flavors and types, wow. They have a lot of things to choose from. The oach Sunday was delicious and my son's reseed Sunday was delicious and the portion sizes are good enough that a small was plenty. They had a line sitting out but it moved fairly fast. The people working behind the counter were pleasant and we would come here again if we were in the area.

Sarah Landerer

2023-08

Reeser’s has the best soft serve in the area! Always consistent service and food/ice cream. Favorite flavors are Black Raspberry & Peanut Butter! Play some mini golf next door too while you’re there. All family owned and operated for 50+ years!

Josh VanBuskirk

2018-05

Always friendly service. Different flavor available on weekends, check schedule. A lot of different sundae options. Also serve Italian ice. Good food options from their kitchen. Outdoor covered and non covered seating available. Mini golf right next door.

Rachel

2023-08

Been coming here for decades but unfortunately had a very bad interaction last time and will not be back for the foreseeable future due to the poor treatment. The worker at the window (unsure of name but had tattoos on her arms) was extremely rude and demanded we let her speak, when we simply were trying to ask a clarifying question about a menu item. Not sure if she was having a bad day or if she’s always like that, but not a good attitude for a customer service position. Really a shame, as we love Reeser’s ice cream. But it left a bad taste in our mouth - no pun intended.

Nikki

2023-05

The ice cream is soft serve and it is kind of fluffy. It is almost like it is whipped in a way. I don't know what they do to it, how they make it, or how to explain it, but it is certainly awesome! We really like the variety of flavors that they offer throughout the summer. The soft serve ice cream flavors are unique. They usually offer the soft serve ice cream in peanut butter every other weekend and on the off weekends they offer it in flavors like blackberry, blueberry, coffee, peach, raspberry, and many more. It would be great if they were able to offer their famous peanut butter soft serve ice cream all the time as well as another flavor, but I suspect that would mean getting another machine. Regardless, it is worth the trip. We live quite far away and still make the time go most weekends.

Daniel Stump

2023-08

After spending the day hiking at Gifford Pinchot State Park, what a treat to find this place on the way home. Friendly, curtious service, huge selection of ice cream flavors, and even food made fresh, if you're hungry. This place rocks! Don't pass them by, if you're up that way. You won't be disappointed.

Amanda Green

2023-07

Reeser's is the best! My girls and I look forward to getting their soft serve every year when they open for the summer season. I just wish they put Raspberry and Blueberry in rotation a bit more. They are my favorite flavors, but they aren't available very often.

Kim Shank

2023-10

Love this place! They always have chocolate and vanilla soft serve and a special flavor on weekends. Our favorite is peanut butter!

Bruce Rayner

2023-07

The staff was very nice. Large selection of ice cream flavors, some non-dairy items, plus quite a few food options as well. The milkshake I had was great!

Robert Picker

2023-06

The ice cream is good but it does have excessive overrun. Also I went only one time this year and ordered a small cup. It was definitely much less ice cream than years past. If it wasn’t a mistake I will say good bye

adam williams

2023-05

Great, delicious food for cheap. They do get busy, but they're worth waiting in line for. Once your food is ordered it doesn't take long before you're enjoying it. The ice cream and milkshakes\malts are fantastic and the flavors are spot on.Sandwiches, subs, and fried foods they have plenty!

Chris Rastyk

2023-06

Family favorite for soft ice cream. Specialty flavor each weekend. Family business that has been in operation for years.This is one of the most missed things during the Covid era. They sell pints over at Karns in Etters, but fun to come here.They do offer food, but we go for the ice cream.

Sam Kell

2023-08

Some of the best ice cream I have ever had.Got the peanut butter soft serve and all I can say is WOW SO GOOD.

Barry Fallon

2023-10

All summer long great food and ice cream. Special flavors every weekend. Plenty of parking. Nice patio to enjoy your food and ice cream.

Sue Delozier

2023-09

They are friendly and the prices are really good! I got a large cone for only $4. Not bad. They do need a bigger sign because we drove past it.

Erin K

2023-08

The ice cream and food are what one would expect from a small shop. The chocolate fudge sauce is slightly bitter, and could use a switch to a better recipe.

Elisabeth

2018-05

The wait depends on when it is. Every weekend, the flavors change and each flavor is delicious! The food is also amazing!

Kat W

2023-05

Every weekend has a special flavored soft ice cream in addition to vanilla and chocolate. There are lots of other ice cream treats as well as burgers, fries, and other good food!

Josh B

2023-07

Best ice cream in the area! They also have a great food selection if you are looking for something to eat as well. Friendly staff.

Dave Bruno

2023-07

Wonderful ice cream with many varieties to choose from. If you're anywhere near Reeser's, you must check it out - you won't be disappointed ...

Alice F

2022-05

The food here is excellent. I had a BLT and it had tons of bacon. I saw a kid with a grilled cheese and I wanted to take it from him, it looked so good! The ice cream creations are always yummy. Lots of choices. I rated this a 3 because of the yellow jacket nest in the awning over the seating area. No one could eat in peace for the bees swarming them. This is a real problem, especially since so many kids are there eating and playing on the grassy slope. I hope the owners take note of this review and have the nest removed before it is too big to handle. It will be order and take away for me until the bees are gone.

Robert

2023-09

Great food, and great ice cream. Prices are very reasonable. Have been going here for 20+years.

Melissa Cathey-Hoffman

2023-05

Fresh peach sundaes are excellent. Lovely soft serve. A gem of a spot, we always enjoy coming for summertime ice cream treats.

SamanthaFreet

2022-05

Reesers has always been a fun family spot for me. My grandpa took us as kids and now I get to take my kids. The food is spot on- I highly suggest the meatball sub when it's available. Also, peanut butter, orange, & raspberry flavor ice cream are my favorite!!! There are tons of food items to choose from. Friendly staff. ❤️

Tish Gillette

2020-05

Delicious hot dogs which are very reasonable in price. And how can you go wrong with soft serve ice cream? I've never had peanut butter vanilla mixed. Soft serve that dreams are made of. That was my first visit and will not be my last. Very busy place but they keep the line moving and a little wait is worth it. Try it you will love it.

Howard Zeigler

2023-07

Love the ice cream. Wish they still did the hard shell dip. When they have the peach Sunday, it is yummy.

Alicia Wolaver

2020-05

Been going here for years. Still the best soft serve I've ever had. My girls love it too!

Michael Stackpoole

2023-05

Good Ice cream. Nice hill for kids to play on. Be prepared for a long line on weekend evenings for sure. Look at FB for weekly flavors Really wish the line went along the side of the building instead of into the middle of the parking lot. Really worry about people pulling in right along the line.

Lauren Lindsey

2023-05

Stopped in for the blueberry and vanilla mix and I'm going to tell you something...*Michael Scott voice* I do declare, that I have had one of the best ice creams ever in my life. And considering the line, I think the rest of the locals may agree. I think there should be a live feed set up of the line that they play on their Facebook....kind of like the live feed that they have at ocmd s boardwalk.