Pizza City & Subs

Andrea M

2024-05

…More

Robert Barber

2024-04

We went driving through the mountains for our anniversary and stopped to eat here. Well, the sandwiches were great! I worked for years at a 🍕 and sandwich place, a small business, not a chain, so I'm a little picky. Well, this place was great. It's unassuming, but authentic. If you're about this kind of food, and know the deal, you'll like it.

Douglas Jahnke (ASYLUMLORD)

2024-04

…More

Eve Failor

2024-04

Being a small town pizzeria, this place is great! Their classic Stromboli is very good. We had a cheese steak Stromboli last week that was soooo good! I really enjoy the chef salad as well.

George Schneider

2023-12

…More

Derek Reed

2023-05

…More

Jessica Ortiz Shull

2023-05

I absolutely LOVE this little local pizza shop The food is made with love, and is soooooo delicious!!! My favorite it the cheese steak subs and strombolis, they use this amazing garlic butter sauce and I can't get enough of it...this picture is next day, my breakfast and it taste just as good as it did that night. The owners are a big happy family that all work together and I love them all, I am looking forward to the next time we eat out, because I'll be calling Pizza City!!!

Maria Wright

2023-07

…More

Samantha Martin

2024-04

…More

Thomas Weitzel

2023-05

Good sub. Give them a try. Will try the wings next time.Just happened to have the wife with me doing some contracting work. Always like trying new places. Will def go back

Lindsey Randle

2023-05

…More

Jennifer Snyder

2023-05

We pass this place everytime we go to our camp and finally had an opportunity to stop and check it out. The service is excellent, very friendly, the food was amazing, the Pizza was hot and ready when we got there, the French fries are fresh cut. If you are in the area definitely stop and try it you will not be disappointed.

Tom Hunter

2023-06

Don’t judge a book by its cover. This place makes amazing pizza and strombolis at prices you can’t beat. Staff is friendly, the food is always fast and hot. Make sure you stop in if you’re in town!

Christina Hardy

2023-05

Delicious. Looked great , tasted amazing. Regular large stromboli. $24 for 2 large.

Aleksander

2024-04

…More

Sylvia K.

2023-05

…More

Brandi K

2023-05

…More

Melinda Montero

2023-05

The best Pizza fries on town 😉 I love it all on the Menu I recommend it come and try it 100%

Ameenah Taylor

2023-07

…More

Matt Ayres

2019-05

You want a damn good Sicilian pizza this place has some of the best... I've been to Chicago New York City and 20 different countries and this place can't be touched when it comes to the sicilian if I could make one suggestion since I only live 5 minutes away, could you add a margarita pizza to the menu, olive oil, fresh basil, tomatoes, and mozzarella cheese. Also to be more competitive you could make a homemade wingsauce or add more flavors of wings

Michael Stouffer

2022-05

Used to love ordering from here. Food was almost always on point! Prices are very reasonable. The guy who owns the place is in there making pizzas and other things every time I go in and he is friendly and courteous, even when they are super busy on a Friday night. I would love to recommend this establishment, but as of late, the quality has definitely taken a downturn. I will give them another chance because I believe in promoting and supporting small businesses but if things don't improve, I probably won't return after that. Fingers crossed!

kemble masonry

2023-05

Ordered a large pie and one of the slices had no crust. Best slice ever, but there was no way to pick it up....Got the Jersey Supreme pie tonight. Real good and piled high! New favorite

Anna H

2023-06

…More

Garrett Stambaugh

2021-05

There have been a few pizza shops pop in and out of this area, and I can confidently say this place makes the best pizza I have gotten anywhere around here. Their specialties are great and have none of the chain store restrictions like a minimum size for a specialty. Their sandwiches and fried food honestly started a little subpar when they first opened but have so dramatically improved that I'd say they're great and it's worth disregarding any early critical reviews about them. The prices are fair and about what you'd expect out of a pizza shop today. The service is friendly and quick, the owner and staff are friendly, and I've never had a bad experience. They can understandably get pretty bogged down during the dinner rush, so you might want to order your food a little off peak or it might take a few tries until someone can get to the phone. If I have one criticism it's this: make sure you have your own pizza cutter at home, because my gosh if I haven't gotten some wild cuts across my pizzas. Seriously, sometimes a single piece is a full quarter of a large with a tiny sliver next to it! They'd really benefit from a cutting guide. Still, overall it's a great place, and it's great to have good food locally instead of having to drive half an hour for pizza.

Tim

2023-05

Yet, ANOTHER great meal from Pete and the crew. You guys ROCK, ESPECIALLY the Jerk Chicken Wings. You guys always remember us and always hook up our Son. Keep up the good works guys !!!!!!!

Rohit Sharma

2022-05

This place was a great find. We came by to grab some lunch while camping with friends nearby. They made the pizza and sandwiches with fresh dough and ingredients right in front of us and they were delicious. The owner was generous and threw in a few sodas and chips for free! The prices was very reasonable as well.

Cassandra Heck

2018-05

Absolutely LOVE coming here. My husband and I are good friends with the owner. We hadn't made it up for a while but, we were there about 2-3 weeks ago and he still remembered the details of our orders. (Likes and dislikes). Pete is a great guy, and Tina is great as well. They're very welcoming and remember their customers. And the food is FANTASTIC. I Highly recommend this place.

Amanda Kline

2019-05

Our favorite go to spot for pizza, wings, and subs. staff is always super friendly and we have never had a bad meal. My husband is from New Jersey and their pizza is the only place my husband will eat from without complaining that he misses Jersey pizza. Prices are great and again food is always excellent!

Jeanette Smith

2021-05

Pizza City is the only place we love. Best food around. If we have any trouble which we never did they are always there to make it right. The owner/workers awesome awesome people. Kind,Friendly,ways smiling asking if I needed anything else. Need a hand taking your food out someone is there to help.Thanks for the great food Pizza City. Jeanette and Brian Smith Loysville.

Jason Etter

2023-05

Food was excellent the amount of fillings in my sub was enough for two subs. Very friendly employees made you feel welcome before even entering the establishment.