Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

Ms. G

2023-11

…More

Charles Robertson

2024-03

…More

Madalynn S

2023-05

Love this Rita's. It can get busy, and the parking can get awkward when it is, but it's not far from my home.I love their custard and their ice, so I definitely recommend the gelati. So yummy! The sizes are good for the price. A lot of ice flavors, custards, and toppings to choose from!

Bryan Edwards

2023-11

If you go on a weekday you will be served fast and be able to sit down and enjoy your ice cream or ices. Do not go on a weekend you will probably stand there for 10 mins or more in line.Ice cream tastes similar to Carvel and the Ices are better than a Ralphs Ice.

Marie P.

2024-04

…More

Cathy Nelson

2023-05

Flavors have gotten away from fruit into names that mean absolutely nothing - Unicorn? Ocean something or other? And the items are too sweet without having a discerning taste beyond cotton candy or sugar.I got the cheese cake custard, and I don't know if the machine needed to be cleaned, or if the mix wasn't adequately mixed, but the fat globules weren't completely blended, leaving them on my spoon, with a weird texture.Still, good service, and a tasty treat.

Shaneil Johnson

2024-03

…More

LaKeisha Garnett

2024-04

…More

Daniel Eickhoff

2022-05

Wasn't very busy, so we were served right away- no waiting. I had a butter pecan custard was delicious. Wife had a 5 layer Gelati, which she said was very good too! Looking forward to visiting again to try other menu items!

Cassie Dunlap

2023-08

Just got home with my Italian ice with custard on top and the custard was gritty and curdled it’s so nasty I’m upset I didn’t try it before I left I would’ve wanted a refund.

Ray T

2023-05

The treats were great and tasty!! Service was good but it was towards the end of the night so it was pretty busy. I did have to wait but Staff were definitely working hard and quickly as they could!!

Amber D

2022-05

I got to this Rita’s around 8:25-8:30 and there were about 5 groups waiting… stood in line for about 30 mins (how you can be soo slow at scooping Italian ice is beyond me 🤣) They had 2 people working at the windows and 2 people who were so worried about going home that instead of getting the line through quicker they cleaned. There was about 3 groups of 2-3 people behind me and i was up next and one of the workers goes “the people at the windows are the last we’re serving tonight”… my suggestion is to drive the extra 10 mins and go to the one in Etown. They can have 10 groups and get you some Italian ice within 10 mins and you can be back in highspire by the time this Rita’s can get one person some Italian ice.

Curtis Thomas

2023-05

At the time I went one girl was mopping and the other serving. Help getting the line moving then clean.they can use a bug zapper for the flying insets that can land in ur food

Brian G

2021-05

I thought it was okay. Your typical Rita's. I haven't been there in over 5 years so I forgot what it was like and I needed help. I felt rushed even though I was the only one there for what could be a half hour and because of that I left with something. I'm at fault too but a little bit of more guidance would've been nice

Corey Kennedy

2023-05

Great and Delicious Ices, all the flavors I love.…Two(2) scoops of Swedish Fish, please.Thank you, Rita’s.

Beatriz Garcia

2022-05

You can never go wrong with Rita's , had me a mango gelato. They have many flavors and toppings to choose from .

Esther Bair

2022-05

I love the frozen custard. It reminds of when I was little and my Grandfather would would take us for frozen custard. 60 + years ago there was a place on the old Swartar Creek Road. Great memories

Krissy Keezel

2019-05

Great flavors and have never had an issue with the customer service. And the puppy sundae is the best!!! My pup gobbles it down every time :)

Abigail Mallon

2019-05

Highspire Ritas is the best. A large selection of both ice and custard flavors. Friendly knowledgeable manager and quick staff. Plenty of outdoor seating for warmer weather.

Mary F OKeefe

2023-05

Thank you for the Free First Day of Spring Rita's! I enjoyed the cantaloupe flavor today!

Jeanette Geadrities

2020-05

The chocolate twist was yummy! Excellent service.

Marcus Carter

2022-05

My daughter asked me to consider moving to a certain house in Highspire just because it would allow her to be able to go to Rita's everyday.. nothing is better than Rita's!!

Antonia Mosteller

2018-05

Came for the Grand opening today, what a great change. Customer service is so much better tons of flavors now try the black raspberry custard it is amazing.

Ofoe Amevor

2022-05

The staff there help us though the menu. They was great. Thanks guys for making our first experience fun

Curtis Smith

2022-05

Twice now the custard was melting before I even got it. Also the large cone is really a small compared to any other place I've been.

Kellie Le

2018-05

Nice place! They opened early this year. Like any other Rita's, you just order from the window. Enough parking for everyone.

Maria Miller

2022-05

Gelato was delicious, service is great. There are quite a lot of flavors and options to choose from.

Bianca Wherley

2023-09

Love gelatis!!!!! Staff is great too!

Terri Spencer

2021-05

The custard was really good today and service was great. Just wish they would have the orange cream one again

dean johnson

2019-05

This is a great place for ice cream and Italian ice!! Its really good! I would recommend it ice cream and any frozen treats.