4.7 (616)
2753 Buchanan Trail W, Greencastle, PA 17225
(717) 597-2888
lizzysgreencastle.com
Service options
Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.
Tyler Harrison
2024-03
Man I’ll tell you what, this place was sensational!! Food was out of this world! I got the the Pittsburger(pulled pork, coleslaw, and a burger patty). Service was great, the owner came out and talked with us to make sure everything was good. It was awesome. I highly recommend it. I was pretty full after eating just my burger, and I still had my fries to eat. They definitely weren’t shy about giving you food either.I honestly can’t wait to go back!
Connie S.
2023-08
…More
HP
2024-04
Small diner style restaurant. Not a lot of seating, but they will come out to your car and take your order if you'd like. We havr eaten here a few times. The staff is excellent, the service is wonderful. The cheese burgers are top notch. More of a smashburger style than a big thick patty. The fries are skinnier mcds style, but very good and seasoned uniquely... in a good way. The wife was not impressed with the roast beef and gravy sandwhich. We have also tried a cheesesteak and the roll was lacking, but its been a bit, may have to try again. They have hersheys hand dipped ice cream and the soft serve is the best I've had recently. I noticed the drinks are quite small, minor thing some may not like. Also the wife is a sweet tea lover and she did not love theirs.
eric hallberg
2024-04
…More
Joseph Clopper
2024-02
Not a lot of atmosphere but it's made up for with really good food and friendly, attentive service. We were very pleased with or diner staples of the Lizzy's special burger and a cheese steak sub. Both fresh and tasty. The fresh cut fries stole the show though. Perfectly cooked and salted just right. I rarely find myself on this side of the valley but I will definitely stop again the next time my travels get me close. All in all, highly recommend!
Emily
2024-03
Absolutely disgusting. I just visited and got a medium soft serve dish of ice cream and waffle fries with a side of cheese. The mix they use in the ice cream has to be poor quality because the ice cream tasted so bad I couldn't finish it. I took one bite of the waffle fry and nearly hurt my tooth because it was so hard. I walked inside and threw it all away and didn't even finish it. WASTE OF $10! I will not be returning. I miss the previous owners. Absolute trash, don't recommend this place anymore. The only positive is the curbside service and even that's iffy.
David Danh
2024-04
…More
Donna Sevcovic
2024-04
…More
Spaceboy
2023-12
Great place to go for a quick eat. Reasonable prices and many different options. Delicious perfect buns smashed burgers. There are many unique combos. Had batter dipped waffle fries like chick-fil-a but crunchier. Very quick service. Would highly recommend.Parking: many spotsKid-friendliness: Friendly staff no alcohol on the menu I saw. safe for kids.
Sara North
2022-05
Great place! Clean and up to date. Burgers were AMAZING! Good portion size for the price. Milkshake was smooth and had that fresh homemade flavor. I was pleasantly surprised that they even had organic ketchup!
Treneshia Jones
2024-03
…More
Christopher LaPole
2024-01
By far the worst club sandwich, I have experienced. Charging $9.50 is crazy. Picked up and took home. Opened sandwich. After looking at it. We had to weigh the total meat with our food scales. Couldn't believe our eyes. Total meat, turkey ham, 4 ounces. Turkey hard on edges. A piece of bacon broke in 3 pieces, in total. 2 slices of cheese. One piece of lettuce on top half. Mayonnaise on top slice. No tomatoes. 3 slices of Texas toast. Clearly in toaster, way to long. And the one slice was toasted as stale bread. If you like a dry, dark white bread tasteless sandwich. You found it. Been going to Lizzy's off and on for about 4 years. It's not consistant. I've never had the same make on a sandwich at anytime. Either to much of one ingredient or barely no ingredients of another. Reading other comments. Don't apologize for it not being made the way we like it. This is just a poor attitude with inconsistently and poor quality. We are done!!!! I will not support a poorly trained manager and staff anymore. My dollar means something to me. Go support it, if you desire. Speaks for what you'll eat and call it acceptable. Done here .
Ash Seiders
2024-03
…More
Rachelle Geyer
2024-04
…More
Samuel
2024-02
Delicious food and even nicer people! If you’re looking for some quick, quality food and great service I cannot recommend this place enough.
Kitty Kat
2023-05
…More
Amber Ford
2024-01
…More
Jared Clugston
2022-05
…More
Jane Bryan
2021-05
Food and service were great. Decent prices and a very large selection of choices. Restaurant is very clean!!!! Will come back!!!!
Jennifer Hoak
2023-11
…More
Mildred Santiago
2024-03
…More
Pete H
2024-03
…More
Stacy & Lisa Crawford
2021-05
The staff was friendly and kind when explaining there is no indoor service due to renovation. Can't wait to see what it looks like when they're done. Ice cream was great. Want to try the mac n cheese next time.
Zeke Stupelman
2024-02
…More
Lori Lashley
2024-04
…More
Nicholas Poulos
2023-05
I love this place great good reasonable prices excellent service I eat here everytime I'm on this side of town . Pic of my youngest son enjoying his first burger ever he loved it.
Adrienne Zeger
2023-06
…More
C.S. Livengood
2024-04
…More
Michelle Atherton
2023-07
This was a first and last visit. The food was okay, nothing to brag about. Burgers, wraps, fries, ice cream. There was 3 of us- 2 adults and a toddler. We got simple food items (burger,wrap, grilled cheese, French fries), an ice cream sundae, 1 scoop, and a 3 scoop ice cream. The bill was about $80.00. That’s simply WAYYY overpriced and the ice cream sundae was small. Honestly, there’s better food/ice cream options nearby that are far more reasonable. On a positive note, the service was excellent!
Erin Ormsby
2024-04
…More
| Monday | 11 AM-9 PM |
|---|---|
| Tuesday | 11 AM-9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM-9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM-9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM-9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM-9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM-9 PM |
Scan the QR code to leave a review.
Powered by bulkqrcodegenerator.com
Pet Stores in the USA
Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.
Broswe by Population